All Through the Night (Steve Harrington x Byers!Reader)
A/N: should I be working on the actual fic that this comes from instead of a one shot set 2 years in the future from the present (of the fic)? Yeah, but, whereâs the fun in that?
Pairing: Steve Harrington x Byers!Reader
Word Count: 7.9k
Summary: Y/N Byers and Steve Harrington have history, and lots of it. From being best friends in elementary and middle school, to never speaking again from 9th grade until Y/Nâs baby brother goes missing⌠but, things change, and people change (with the help of middle schoolers and an inter dimensional slug). So, it only makes sense that Steve would ask Maggie to senior prom, right?
Warnings: mentions of body image issues, Y/N is actually an OC from a WIP but I tried my best to take out any identifying characteristics!
Hawkins, Indiana
May 1985
The sun is warm, spring humming in the air. As soon as the final bell of the day rings, seniors are buzzing with prom talk everywhere â dresses, tuxes, limos, after-parties.Â
You try to ignore all of it.
Prom has never been in the cards for you. Prom is for girls with money to spend on dresses and shoes and makeup. Prom is for girls who actually have dates⌠so, not you.Â
Never, you.Â
You adjust your backpack and start toward the parking lot, hoping that Jonathan and Nancy werenât sucking face in the car again. Bonnie was out of commission for the time being, her alternator had decided to give up, and you didnât feel like begging Hop for a raise before turning in your notice. With the new mall opening in a few weeks, you figured you would get a more⌠normal job for a girl your age.Â
You're halfway across the lot when you hear the familiar beep be-beep beep.Â
You look up.
Steve Harrington, leaning half-out the driverâs window of his BMW, waving at you like youâve just returned from war.Â
âY/N! Get in! Iâll give you a ride!â
You feel your stomach flip â the stupid, traitorous butterflies that have moved in permanently since last Christmas â but you force yourself to stay normal.
Totally normal.
âSteve, I do have a brother ya know,â you call back, laughing. âHis car isââ you pause, looking over to the see the familiar sight of said brother crawling into the back seat with a giggling Nancy Wheeler. You were happy for Jonathan, and for Nance. They deserved to be happy, especially after the mess their lives had become since November â83. But, did they have to always do it in the backseat?Â
âYeah, but Iâm offering a cooties free chauffeur service,â he insists, grinning widely as he pushes his ray bans up into his hair. âAnd it comes with excellent conversation and terrible music.â
You roll your eyes but walks over anyway.
Because itâs Steve. Because you always do.
You slide into the passenger seat, the familiar scent of pine air freshener and vanilla shampoo hitting you all at once.
âDonât you have swimming practice?â you ask, buckling in.
âNope.â He pops the âpâ, leaning back in his seat, the picture of comfort. âCoach canceled.â
He seemsâŚnervous. He keeps drumming his fingers against the steering wheel.
You glance at him. âYou okay?â
âYep. Totally. Completely normal. Justâuh.â He clears his throat. âJust wanted to talk to you about something.â
Those butterflies turn into a swarm.
âOh?âyou say softly. âWhatâs up?â
He pulls out of the parking, but instead of heading toward your house, he steers toward the lake. The one the two of you used to bike to in middle school to escape the world.Â
Y/N's heart thuds, Steve rarely wanted to âtalkâ.
Complain about their brood of middle schoolers? Sure, daily. Bitch about his parents? At least once a week. Bond over the newest episode of Dynasty in secret, because Steve would NEVER live it down if Dustin heard about that⌠absolutely.Â
But, he never looked this serious, and he never looked like he was about to pass out.Â
Steve parks beneath a blooming dogwood tree, kills the engine, and suddenly looks like he might pass out.
âY/N,â he starts, leaning forward on the wheel, âso⌠prom.â
Your stomach drops, brain immediately going to the worst possible explanation. âI thought he was over her? Itâs almost been a year, and he knows how happy she is with Jonââ
âOhâSteve, if this is about Nancyââ
âNo!â he blurts. Then, softer: âNo. Itâs not about Nancy.â
He turns toward you fully now, one arm resting along the back of your seat.
He looks so earnest. So nervous it almost hurts to watch.
âI was thinking,â he says, âthat⌠it might be fun. Yâknow. If we went.â
You stare at him, brain turning to straight static as you take in what heâs just said. âThere is no wayâ
âWe?â you echo. âLike⌠you and⌠me?â
He bites his lip. Nods.
âYeah. I meanâonly if you want to. I just thought⌠weâve been having a lot of fun lately, and after last year being⌠hell⌠maybe we deserve something good? Something normal?â
Your mouth has gone dry.Â
You opens it, but nothing comes out but a squeak.
He panics instantly.
âOh my god, sorry, forget it,â he rushes. âYou donât have toâlike, at all. I justâI donât want you to think this is, like, a thing. Unless you want it to be a thing. But itâs not a thing! Itâs justâprom. As friends. Like a⌠friend-date. A frate! Two best friends going to prom together. Totally normal, right?â
Y/N tries very, very hard not to melt into the seat.
He asked you to prom. Steve Harrington asked you to prom.
Your heart is screaming, of course, yes, god, yes, but what comes out is a soft:
ââŚyou want to go with me?â
He swallows hard, adamâs apple bobbing in his throat as he nods. âYeah. I do.â
You smile â shy, startled, happy.
âIâd really like that.â
His shoulders DROP in relief.
âYeah?! Okay! Cool! Awesome. Great. Perfect.â He clears his throat. âSo⌠um⌠Iâll pick you up? In a tux? With, like, one of those flower things?â
âA corsage?â you tease.
âYes. That.â
Silence settles â not awkward, but warm and trembling.
You looks out at the lake, cheeks pink.
He watches you instead.
And in the soft spring sunlight, you donât notice the way he looks at you â like heâs already in love, and trying very, very hard not to realize it.
By the time the two of you reach the house, you have come to terms with the fact that the past 30 minutes havenât been a dream. Steve asked you to prom. Steve wants to go to prom with you.
Your brain is mush, and time isnât timing right. Maybe you were abducted by aliens, and this is an implanted memory? You've read all about them in those magazines the boys read, and false memories are a symptom. Alien abduction would make more sense than reality at this point.When you come to, you realize youâve been sitting outside your house for almost a full minute. 'Lost time is also a symptom', you think.
Neither one wants to get out.
Your heart is still somewhere up near your throat. Steve keeps drumming on the wheel, staring at the windshield as if it owes him money.
He glances at you sideways, lips twitching.
âSo uh⌠just so you know,â he says, âthis is also my official makeup for not asking you to the Snow Ball in eighth grade.â
Your head snaps toward him.
âWhat?â
âYeah!â he laughs nervously, holding up his hands. âI mean, we did our little redo thing after the Mind Flayer⌠stuffâŚÂ and all, but uhâreal prom, actual dressing up, slow dancing, terrible spiked punch? I figure it makes up for not asking you back then.â
You blink at him. Hard.
He doesnât notice the way you stop breathing.
He just keeps rambling.
âWhich, by the way, I still feel crappy about. I shouldâve asked you. I wouldâve had way more fun. And Iââ
Suddenly, he stops talking, his mouth snapping shut like he caught himself revealing something too real.
You whisper, almost too soft, ââŚyou really mean that?â
His eyes flick to yours. And something warm, vulnerable, dangerous flashes there.
âYeah, Y/N,â he says quietly. ââCourse I do.â
For a second, neither moves.
Then he clears his throat and ruins the moment in the very Steve Harrington way he always does.
âAnyway!â he says brightly, slapping the wheel. âProm. Weâll, uh⌠be the coolest non-couple couple there.â
You snort. âSteve, that doesnât even make sense.â
âIt does in my head!â
You both laugh â breathless, nervous, trying so hard to hide the fact you both desperately want to kiss each other more than you want oxygen.
You reach for the door handle.
âSee you tomorrow?â
His voice drops a little. âYeah. Definitely.â
You step out of the carâ
âand then the second the door closes, you explode into pure giddy energy, running toward the house with your hands covering your mouth to muffle the squeal.
Steve watches you go through the windshield, smiling like he just won the lottery.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Joyce is on the couch folding laundry, looking exhausted, worn, normal in that way that you love.
She looks up when you burst in.
And for the first time in yearsâ Not since Josie and the Pussycat pajamas and sticky toddler curlsâ Joyce hears her daughter giggle.
Full-body, youthful, unguarded joy.
Joyce drops the dishtowel sheâd been folding, brows furrowed.Â
ââŚ.Y/N?â
You're pacing the room, hands in your hair, trying not to scream.
âOh my god,â you whisper. âOh my god. Mom.â
Joyce stands slowly, heart in her throat. âY/N. Honey. What is it? What happened? Are you okay?â
You finally spin around, cheeks flushed bright pink.
âHe asked me to prom.â
Joyceâs eyebrows shoot up, heart returning to a normal rhythm. The small smile that makes its way across her tired face says it all, that she knows immediately who you are talking about. Â
ââŚSteve?â
You scream-whisper back, eyes wide with every possible emotion the human body could produce. âYES.â
Joyce claps a hand over her mouth, eyes welling with tears â because you are happy. Not surviving. Not bracing. Not carrying the weight of the world.
Just⌠happy.
âOh, sweet girlâŚâ she murmurs, coming over and pulling you into her arms. âYou⌠that is so wonderful!.â
Y/N bends low and hides your face in Joyceâs shoulder, the same way you did when you were little and would ask her to check the drain for clowns.Â
âMom, what am I gonna do? Itâs just as friends, but also maybe not as friends, and he said something about eighth grade and the Snow Ball and I thinkâ I think Iâm dying.â Your words come out in a flurry, excitement and nerves evident.Â
Joyce laughs into her hair.
âYouâre in love,â she says softly. âThatâs all.â
You freeze.Â
That word⌠that feeling⌠you'd done everything in your power to avoid it since December, since Steve showed up at your door with a boom box and the words âSnow Ball redoâ on his lips. But today, with the way Steve had looked at you, and the way your body had melted into the leather seats of his car with the utterance of the word âpromâ...Â
You couldnât really deny it anymore, at least not to yourself⌠or your mom.Â
ââŚyeah. I think I might be.â
Joyce tightens her hug. It is warm, gentle, and absolutely overflowing with relief. Because this â THIS â is the daughter she missed. The one with hope.
âIâm so happy for you, baby,â Joyce murmurs. âIâm so, so happy.â
Your smile widens, because it hasnât left your face since you exited Steveâs car, and you say something you didnât think yourself capable of saying anymore. âMe too mom. Iâm happy too.â
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
The little store in downtown Hawkins smells like perfume, steam, and the faint scent of Bonnie continuing to rust in the front yard. There was no way you were leaving here without spending all of the money youâd saved to repair your precious bug.Â
Nancy is already rifling through the prom racks like a seasoned pro. Max is sitting in a rolling chair, kicking herself back and forth, humming ABBA and complaining loudly about being there, even though she insisted on coming.
You, meanwhile, stand near the doorway.
Frozen.
Hands in your jacket pockets. Anxious. Already doing mental math about how many hours of overtime you would need to beg Hop for just to afford half a prom dress.
Nancy looks up.
âY/N? You coming?â
You force a smile.
âI⌠yeah, justâuhâlooking.â
Max rolls her chair over, sneakers squeaking on the tile.
âYou okay? You look like you just sucked on a lemon.â
You huff a tiny laugh, ruffling the younger girlâs hair, much to her chagrin.Â
âItâs just⌠dresses here are expensive. Like, really expensive. And I should probably find aâmaybeâcheaper option. Something simple.â You lift up the price tag on a teal silk gown, eyes bulging at the amount of numbers that could fit on such a small piece of paper. âMaybe we should just go look at the Salvation Army. I mean, I could find something there and make it work.âÂ
Nancy exchanges a look with Max, blue eyes shining with mischief.
She steps forward, voice warm and firm.
âY/N, Donât worry about the price.â
You blink. âUhâNance? Iâm absolutely worrying about the price.â
âDonât.â Nancy insists gently. âSeriously.â
Max rolls her eyes and elbows Nancy. âOh just tell her, Nancy. Sheâs gonna figure it out when itâs time to check out and the lady asks whoâs paying.â
You tilt your head. ââŚWhat?â
Nancy takes a deep breath.
âSteve gave me money.â
Your stomach drop-kicks itself into your shoes.
âWhat?! Why?!â
âFor your dress,â Nancy says. âWhichever one you want. He said those exact words.â
You shake your head, mouth falling open.
âHeâwhat? No. No way. He didnâtâNancyâno way.â
Max is already back to rolling around the store, humming again.
âOh he totally did,â Max calls. âPulled out a wad of cash and gave it to Nancy like it was nothing.â The redhead grimaces at a puke green monstrosity in the guise of a gown, âHarrington finally decided to use his rich boy privilege for good, Mags.âÂ
Nancy steps close to you squeezing your hand.
âHe wants you to feel special, Y/N. He wants this to be good for you.â
Your throat gets tight. Too tight.
Nobody has ever done something like this for your Steve Harrington â her Steve, the boy who once forgot you existed â wants to make sure you have the perfect dress?
It shouldnât make you want to cry. But it does.
Nancy gives your hand a tug.
âCome on. Letâs find your dress.â
It takes almost an hour.
Max picks out things that look like they were stolen from David Bowieâs closet. Nancy picks things she would wear â elegant, structured, very âWheeler.â
You try on at least six different gowns.
You hate every single one. None of them felt like you, and they all fit weird. You're about to give up when the shop owner brings out a dress from the back.
Dark purple, soft, romantic fabric. Puff sleeves at the shoulders. A shape that would hug your waist but flow beautifully over your hips into a large ball gown skirt.Â
Nancyâs eyes widen. Max stops rolling.
You touch it like it might disappear.
âTry it on,â Nancy whispers.
You hesitates.
Then goes into the dressing room.
Your hands shake as you unzip the back, and you slide it on.
The fabric settles around your body like it was meant to be yours.
You turn toward the mirror.
Andâ
You don't breathe.
You don't move.
Because for the first time â maybe ever â you see yourself the way other people sometimes insist you are:
Beautiful.
Soft. Strong. Curvy in a way that isnât something to hide. Sparkling in a way you didnât know you could.
You presses a hand over your mouth. Your eyes sting.
âY/N?â Nancy calls. âYou okay?â
You swallow, then step out before you can lose your nerves.Â
Nancy gasps. Max nearly falls off her rolling chair, jaw dropped, brows raised.Â
âY/NâŚâ Nancy whispers. âOh my god.â
Max scrambles back up, a genuine look of awe on her face. âHoly shit. You lookâ you look likeâ I donât even know what Y/N, but you look beautiful.â
You laugh nervously, tugging at the skirt.
âReally?â
Nancy walks over, takes your shoulders, and turns you gently toward the three-way mirror.
âSee?â Nancy murmurs. âThis is how we already see you.â
Your breath catches. You looks at you reflection â really look.
âSteve is going to die,â Max says matter-of-factly.
âMaxine!â You yelp, face burning.
âWhat? He is! Heâs gonna short-circuit like a broken Etch-A-Sketch.â
Nancy giggles behind her hand, giving the younger girl a fond look. âSheâs not wrong.â
You turn back to the mirror, fingertips brushing the soft fabric.
ââŚI love it,â you whisper.
Nancy beams.
âThen itâs yours.â
And you â for the first time in your entire life â let yourself believe that you deserve to feel beautiful.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Byers house smells like hairspray, fabric steam, and the grilled cheese Joyce made because you âneed to eat something real before you faint.â
You are standing in front of the hallway mirror in your slip, cheeks pink, hands fluttering nervously.
Joyce is fussing with the dress hanging on the closet door, smoothing the fabric with reverence, like itâs something holy.
Will sits cross-legged on your bed, a comb in his hand, watching the process with wide, earnest eyes.
âDo you want me toâuhâhold something?â Will asks for the seventh time.
You smile, turning to him as you put your earrings in.Â
âYou can hold my sanity,â you joke weakly.
Will grins. âOkay. Is that heavier than the dress?â
You snort. âMuch.â
Joyce turns, eyes shining.
âYouâre so beautiful, honey.â
You swallow. Joyce hasnât said something like that to you in⌠years. Not because she didnât love you â but because life had been too loud, too harsh, too urgent.
But right now? Joyce is fully focused on you.
Sheâd been focused on you all day. Waking you up for a mini spa day, painting your nails like you were 9 again, doing your hair, your makeup⌠it felt nice, to have everyone's mom be your mom for a bit.Â
You sit on the edge of the bed. Will scoots closer, legs bumping yours.
He looks you over with a smile, brown eyes warm.Â
âYour hair looks really nice,â he says softly.
âThanks, baby cakes,â You murmur, brushing his bangs to the side. âYou look pretty handsome yourself.â
He blushes immediately. âIâm not going anywhere.â
âYou can still be handsome and not be going anywhere.â
Will shrugs, but heâs smiling â that small, shy smile you've missed since before⌠everything.
Joyce comes around behind you with a makeup brush.Â
âHold still,â she says. âIâm not letting you go out there looking pale. Youâre going to glow.â
âMomââ
âNo arguing, miss prom queen.â
You almost laugh â almost.
But then Joyceâs hand touches your cheek, thumb brushing gently under your eye.
âHoneyâŚâ Joyceâs voice softens. âYou deserve a night like this.â
And your throat closes.
Joyce sees it â of course she does â and immediately pulls her daughter into a hug, careful not to mess up your hair.
âI know things have been⌠hard,â she whispers into your curls. âAnd you grew up too fast. Way too fast. But tonight? You can just be a teenager.â
You hold her tightly, swallowing the sting in your eyes.
Will leans in, wrapping his small arms around both of you, making it a three-person Byers hug â the kind they used to do when Will refused to sleep by himself, and Joyce would tuck him into your bed.Â
âI like your dress,â Will says into your shoulder. âYouâre gonna be the prettiest one there.â
You laugh through the ache in your chest.
âThanks, Will.â
âAnd Steve is gonna freak out,â he adds helpfully.
Joyce snorts. âWILL.â
âWhat?â Will shrugs.
Your face burns. âHe is notââ
âHe is,â Will insists like heâs reporting a scientific fact. âHe acts different when we talk about you.â
Joyce raises both eyebrows. âOh really?â
âWILL.â
âWhat?!â He throws his hands up. âIâm just saying.â
You hides your face in your hands as both your mother and baby brother laugh.
Joyce gently takes her hands away.
âAlright sweetie, dress time.â
You hesitate. Then stand.
Joyce helps you step into the dress â careful, loving â zipping it up with hands that shake just a little.
The fabric settles around you like it was made for you.
Joyce covers her mouth. Will looks up at his big sister like you've hung the moon, but, heâs always looked at you that way⌠tonight, he looks at you like he hopes you can finally see that in yourself too.Â
âOh⌠Y/N,â she whispers. âLook at you.â
You turn toward the mirror.
The girl staring back isnât tired. Isnât burdened. Isnât the caretaker or the fixer.
She's radiant.
Sheâs beautiful.
Sheâs a teenager that hasnât fought inter-dimensional monsters.
Will gets up and wraps his arms around your waist.
âYou look like a princess,â he says softly.
Joyce places her hands on your shoulders.
âYou look like you,â Joyce murmurs â and thatâs somehow the sweetest compliment of all.
You smile at your reflection, cheeks warm.
And for once⌠For once you allow yourself to feel excited.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Steve's POV
Steve stands on the Byersâ front porch, tux slightly crooked, hair perfect (after three tries), and hands vibrating.
Heâs fought demogorgons with a bat, twice. Heâs survived inter-dimensional tunnels full of demodogs. Heâs dealt with Dustin Henderson, near daily, for 5 months.Â
None of that prepared him for knocking on Y/N Byersâ door.
He wipes his palms on his tux pants. Takes a deep breath. Knocks.
Inside, thereâs chaos â shuffling, a small thud, the sound of Joyce whisper-yelling: âWILL, STOP PEEKINGââ
And thenâ
The door opens.
Not all the way. Just a crack.
Jonathanâs face appears, deadpan as ever.
âWell,â he says. âTry not to pass out.â
Steve blinks. âHuh?â
Jonathan rolls his eyes, opens the door widerâ
And Steve Harrington forgets how to function as a human being.
Because you're standing at the end of the hallway.
Lit up by the living room lamp. Dress shimmering like moonlight. Hair soft and half pulled back with sparkling clips. A nervous smile pulling at your lips.
Steveâs breath leaves his body so fast he actually sways.
He doesnât move. He doesnât blink. He doesnât even breathe.
Joyce peeks out from behind you, sees Steveâs expression, and mutters, âOh yeah. Heâs gone.â
And Will â sweet, blunt Will â whispers way too loudly, âCalled it.â
You walk toward the door, fingers brushing the skirt of your dress. Steve canât even look away long enough to see where heâs stepping. He misses the step entirely.
You reach him quickly, managing to catch him by his arm before he falls flat on his face against the Byersâ living room carpet.Â
âHi,â you say softly, hand still on his arm.Â
Steve opens his mouth.
Nothing comes out.
He tries again.
ââŚHi.â
His voice cracks like a thirteen-year-old.
Jonathan snorts behind you
Joyce elbows him.
You rub his arm once, blushing at the warmth, before taking a step back to look at him.Â
âYou look⌠nice,â you say.
Nice. The boy looks like he was tailored by God.
But Steve shakes his head, almost offended.
âNo. No way. Notâ not compared toââ He gestures helplessly. âYou.â
Your blush deepens.
Joyce clutches her chest.Â
Jonathan mutters, âJesus Christ.â
Steve fumbles in his pocket, pulling out the corsage.
His hands are shaking so badly he nearly drops it.
âUmâ I got you this. I, uh⌠ya know, I told you I'd get you a flower thing.â
You hold out your wrist, shy but glowing, both from the amount of blush your mom had applied, and from⌠well⌠everything you were feeling.Â
He slides the corsage on, fingers brushing your skinâand thatâs when Steve realizes:
He is doomed.
Utterly doomed.
Your eyes meet his, and Steve Harrington experiences an emotional heart attack.
You beam up at Steve, soft and warm and full of something he doesnât have a name for yet.
âYou ready?â you ask.
Steve nods too fast.
âYeah. Yep. Totally. Ready. Very ready. Letâsâ go. Prom. Dancing. Stuff.â
You laugh â really laugh â and the sound almost knocks him off the porch.
Before they leave, Joyce rushes forward and kisses your cheek.
âHave fun,â she says. âBe careful. But have fun.â
Steve promises â to Joyce, to Jonathan, to Will â that heâll bring you back safe.
And when you takes your arm, Steve looks down:
You havenât stopped smiling since he pulled up.
And he hasnât stopped staring.
Steve opens the passenger door for you.
It feels old-fashioned, chivalrous, like something from the movies you love. He doesnât even think about doing it â his body just moves, compelled by some instinct he didnât know he had.
You step in, gathering your dress so it doesnât snag, smiling shyly up at him.
The smile nearly kills him.
He shuts the door carefully â carefully, like you're made of glass and wildflowers â then circles to the driver's seat, trying to breathe normally.
He fails.
The moment he sits down, the perfume hits him. Not strong. Not artificial.
Just⌠Y/N.
Soft. Warm. Floral. Familiar in a way that rattles something deep in his ribs.
He puts the keys in the ignition and misses on the first try.
You bite back a grin.
âAre you nervous, Harrington?â
âWhat? No. Pssh.â He clears his throat. âIâmâ Iâm great. Iâm cool. Totally cool.â
You raise an eyebrow. âYour hands are shaking.â
âCold,â he lies. Badly.
You smirk â and he feels that smirk in his knees.
The two of you pull onto the road, and for a long, breathless moment, neither of you speaks.
Then you turn to him, voice soft:
âThanks for asking me.â
He grips the steering wheel harder to keep from saying something stupid.Â
âThanks for⌠saying yes.â
You look out the window, cheeks warming.
âIâm glad weâre doing this. With everything that happened last year, and, well⌠I didnât think Iâd ever get a prom.â
Steveâs chest tightens.
âI wouldâve dragged you in myself if I had to.â
You laugh â a soft, breathy sound that fills the whole car.
He glances over at you.
Just a quick glance.
Long enough to memorize the curve of your smile, the shimmer of your dress, the way the corsage looks impossibly perfect on your wrist.
You catch him staring.
âWhat?â you ask, playful.
Steveâs brain short-circuits.
âNothing. Justââ He swallows hard. âYou look really pretty tonight.â
Your smile drops into something gentler, deeper.
âThank you,â your whisper.
Silence settles again â but itâs a warm silence. A full one. The kind that only happens between people who fit.
Steve reaches to turn on the radio to fill the quiet.
But you beat him to it.
Your hand lands lightly on his arm.
âI like the quiet.â
And that â that tiny gesture â feels bigger than the entire damn prom.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Steveâs POV
If someone asked him later what the prom decorations looked like, he wouldnât be able to answer.
If they asked what song was playing when they walked in, heâd guess wrong.
If they asked who stared at them, whispered about them, froze mid-dance when they saw Y/N Byers looking like that â
He wouldnât know.
Because Steve Harrington sees one thing and one thing only; Y/N gripping his arm like you actually wants to be there with him.
Your hand is warm. Your perfume drifts around him like a spell. Your smile is small but real â and itâs for him.
Not your siblings. Not one of the kids Not some imaginary boy you deserve more than him.
Him.
You're nervous â he can feel it in the light squeeze of your hand â but you're also happy.
And that?
Thatâs enough to level him.
People are staring. He knows they are. He can feel the shock rolling through the room.
Y/N Byers â quiet, bookish, last choice, Y/N Byers â looking like a dream?
And sheâs on Steve Harringtonâs arm?
But Steve doesnât see any of them.
All he sees is the way Y/N's eyes widen with wonder at the decorations. How her dress glitters under the lights. How she laughs nervously when she bumps into him because sheâs trying not to step on her hem.
He leans down slightly.
âYou okay?â
She nods. âYeah. Just⌠a little overwhelmed.â
âMe too,â he admits before he can stop himself.
You look up at him â really look â and your smile softens into something that turns his bones to dust.
In that exact moment, Steve Harrington decides:
Heâs never taking anyone else to anything ever again.
Prom, weddings, fighting monsters, grocery shopping â you're it.
He offers his hand.
âWanna dance?â
You blush, then nods.
And as he leads her onto the dance floor, Steve realizes something that makes his pulse trip over itself:
He doesnât care whoâs watching. He doesnât care what they think. He doesnât care what "King Steve" used to mean.
All he cares about is the girl beside him.
Smiling like he's the one you wanted to be with all along.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
You have imagined prom before. Not often â not seriously â just the vague, impossible daydreams girls allow themselves when life gets too heavy:
A dress. A dance. A night without fear.
But you never imagined this.
Not Steve Harrington offering his hand like you're the girl heâs been waiting for. Not the warmth in his eyes when you take it. Not the trembling flutter in your stomach as he leads you onto the dance floor.
And certainly not dancing to Cyndi Lauper with your head just close enough to rest against his if you were brave enough.
You aren't brave enough. Not tonight.
Maybe not ever.
But your heart tips forward anyway. Just a little. Just enough.
Steveâs hands settle lightly at your waist. Hesitant, like heâs holding something breakable.
Your breath catches â embarrassingly loud â and he smiles, soft and lopsided, like the boy you used to know before Tommy H and high school poisoned him.
You set your hands on his shoulders.
Heâs warm. Heâs steady. Heâs Steve.
Not King Steve. Not popular Steve. Not Nancy Wheelerâs boyfriend Steve.
Just⌠the boy who remembered your birthday in seventh grade. The boy who made you laugh even when her home life was falling apart. The boy you never really stopped missing.
He sways you both gently as the music shifts into the chorus:
âWe have no past, we won't reach backKeep with me forward all through the night..â
You knows people are watching.
You know Carol is whispering something cruel. You know Tommy Hâs mouth dropped open the moment the two of you walked in. You know people are wondering how Y/N Byers ended up here, in a dress like this, with Steve Harrington.
But for once â For once in your life â You don't care.
Not about the whispers. Not about the stares.
Because Steve is smiling at you like none of it matters. Like he doesnât care that you're a little taller than him in your heels. That he doesnât care that you have 2 left feet.Â
Because Steve is holding you like you belong here.
Because Steveâs thumb just brushed the side of your waist â just barely â and it sent a shiver up your spine.
You look at him.
He looks at you.
And suddenly your heart is so full it aches.
So you blurt, softly, teasing but not really:
âSo⌠does this count as my first date?â
His eyebrows fly up. Then knit together like he suddenly forgot English.
âWhat?â he breathes.
You swallow, feeling your cheeks warm.
âWell, you said we were going as friends.â You force a smile, hoping it covers your nerves. âSo I donât want to break the rules or anything.â
He stares at you. Stares through you.
Like you just cracked something open inside him.
His grip at your waist tightens â gently, but enough to make you lose your breath.
âYeahâŚYou can count it,â he whispers, voice low and rough.
Your throat goes tight.
âOh,â you manage. âOkay.â
You fall into a softer sway.
Closer now. Closer than friends should be. Closer than you've ever let yourself be with anyone.
You can feel his heartbeat through his jacket. You wonder if he can feel yours hammering back.
The lights blur into warm halos. The room dissolves into static and music.
And Y/N â tall, awkward, usually invisible Y/N â feels beautiful.
You feel wanted.
You feel seen.
You bends down slightly and rests your head against his shoulder, just briefly, just to feel him. Steve hesitates â one breath â then rests his cheek against your hair.
Your knees nearly buckle.
You feels his hands shift at your waist, pulling you a fraction closer, like he isnât sure heâs allowed but wants to try anyway.
The world narrows.
Just him. Just you. Just this moment.
You wonder â for one dizzy, fragile second â what it would feel like if he kissed you.
And then you shuts the thought down so fast it hurts.
Because this isnât a date. Not really.
Because Steve doesnât see you that way. Not now. Not ever.
Even if your whole body feels like itâs humming with the possibility of him.
Even if this is the happiest you've been in years.
Even ifâ
He whispers your name.
âY/NâŚâ
You lifts your head, heart in your throatâ
And your noses nearly brush.
Your breath stutters.
You sees his eyes flick to your lips.
Just for a moment.
Just long enough that youâll replay it in your head for years.
Then the song ends. The lights shift. Someone laughs too loudly nearby.
Steve steps back first.
Of course he does.
He gives you a smile so soft your stomach knots painfully.
âYou wanna⌠get some punch?â he asks.
You nod even though your chest feels like itâs cracked open.
âYeah,â you say. âYeah, that sounds good.â
He offers his hand again.
You take it.
And you walk off the dance floor together.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Steve POV Steve Harrington has danced with girls before. Plenty of girls.
But he has never â not once in his entire life â felt what he feels the moment Y/N Byers puts her hands on his shoulders.
Itâs electric. Itâs dizzying. Itâs holy shit why canât I breathe.
And then Cyndi Lauper starts singing and Steve nearly drops dead on the spot.
She looks up at him with those eyes â warm, nervous, shining â and he swears his heart forgets how to pump blood.
He tries not to grip her waist too tightly. But he also tries not to let her go.
Both feel impossible.
âRelax,â she teases softly.
Relax. Relax??
Relax while Y/N Byers is standing in his arms in a dress that could kill a man?
Impossible.
He swallows hard. Focuses on counting the steps.
One⌠twoâŚ
But then he looks at her again.
And the count is gone.
He sees her blushing. He sees her biting back a smile. He sees her absolutely glowing under the lights.
And God help him â he wants to say something stupid and earnest like Youâre the prettiest girl here, but heâs terrified his voice wonât work.
Then she says itâ
âSo⌠does this count as my first date?â
Steve short-circuits.
Literally.
His brain fries like someone jammed a fork in an electrical outlet.
What??? WHAT???
âWhat?â heâs breathless, hands tightening around her waist to keep himself upright.
She gives a tiny shrug, looking anywhere but his eyes.
âWell, you said we were going as friends. So I donât want to break the rules or anything.â
Sheâs asking permission to call him her first date?
Steveâs stomach flips so violently he grips her waist tighter just to stay upright.
âYeah,â he whispers. His voice cracks. He wants to die. âYou can count it.â
She nods shyly.
And Steve Harrington falls in love.
Not dramatically. Not suddenly. Not like fireworks or sparks.
But deeper. Quieter. Like something inside him clicks into place.
They sway.
Her dress brushes his legs. Her perfume fills the space between them. Her breath grazes his neck.
He thinks: If I died right now, itâd be fine.
Then she rests her head on his shoulder.
And Steve stops breathing altogether.
His hands move on instinct â sliding from her waist to her lower back, pulling her closer, his head nestling against her own.
Just an inch. Just enough to feel the shape of her against him.
Heâs aware â horribly, beautifully aware â of every place their bodies touch.
She fits.
Thatâs the only word for it.
She fits.
He closes his eyes for a second, letting the moment soak into his bones.
Then she lifts her head.
Andâ
Oh no.
Oh no.
Their faces are inches apart. Her lips are right there. Right there.
Soft. Pink. Tempting in a way that makes his entire chest clench.
He feels himself leaning in without meaning to.
Just a fraction.
Just enough.
Her breath hitches.
âY/NâŚâ
Sheâs not pulling away.
Sheâs notâ
He panics.
Full internal screaming.
Abort mission! Abort! Abort! ABORT!
He jerks back slightly.
Not enough to be obvious. Just enough to not ruin their friendship. Just enough not to kiss her when heâs not allowed to want that.
Because Steve Harrington remembers:
Heâs her friend. Heâs her prom date âas friends.â He doesnât get to want more.
He doesnât get to want her.
Not tonight. Not ever â not like that.
The song ends.
He forces air into his lungs.
âYou wanna get some punch?â he manages to say, like he didnât just almost kiss the one girl who makes him feel like the world isnât falling apart.
She nods, smiling up at him with the kind of smile people treasure. âYeah, that sounds good.â
And as he leads her off the dance floor, Steve thinks:
If this is as close as I ever get to her⌠Iâm ruined.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The gym is loud. The music is thumping. The punch is questionably strong.
But outside?
Outside, under the faint glow of the parking lot lights and the warm late-spring breezeâŚ
Itâs quiet.
Steve holds the door open for you as you step out, lifting your dress so it doesnât brush the pavement. You shiver slightly, and Steve immediately shrugs off his jacket and drapes it around your shoulders.
He doesnât think. Just moves.
Always for you.
You smile at him â a tired, soft smile â and Steve feels it like a shot to the chest.
They walk to the side of the building, where the students sneak cigarettes, and you pull one out with a little embarrassed shrug.
âProm night exception,â you say. âIâm trying to quit.â
Steve takes the cigarette from your fingers.
âYou donât have to,â he says, lighting it before handing it back. âJust⌠stay out here with me.â
You blush, inhaling slowly, letting the smoke calm your nerves.
For a long moment, you both stand quietly. Listening to muffled music. Watching your breaths fog in the cool night air.
You exhale and stare up at the sky.
âThank you,â you whispers.
Steve looks over, confused. âFor what? Punch? Dancing? My excellent tux?â
You laugh â light and pretty.
âFor tonight,â you say. âFor all of it. For⌠this.â
He swallows.
âY/N, you donât have to thank me. Iâm the one who shouldââ
âNo,â you cut in gently. âI do.â
You turn to face him fully.
Eyes shimmering. cheeks pink â from the cold or from the spiked punch, heâs not sure. Dress glowing under the moonlight.
âI havenât been this happy in a long time,â you admit quietly. âLike⌠a year and a half, probably longer.â
Steveâs smile fades into something softer, more serious.
Your voice trembles as you continue,
âWhen Will went missing⌠when everything happened after that⌠I kept feeling like I was disappearing. Like I had to be strong all the time. For my mom. For Jonathan. For the kids. For everyone.â
He nods slowly â he knows that feeling too well.
âAnd then the monsters. The lab. The⌠everything.â
You take another shaky inhale from your cigarette before flicking the ash away.
âI got hurt. Twice. Almost died. Twice. And I thoughtâŚâ You laugh, but itâs not funny. âI thought that was it. That maybe this was my life. Being scared and tired and alone.â
He wants to take your hand. He wants to shake his head. He wants to tell you that you were never alone.
But you keep going.
âAnd then,â you say, voice softening, âI looked up one day⌠and you were there again.â
Steve feels his heart stop.
âYou came back to me,â you whisper. âRight when I needed someone the most. You didnât have to. But you did.â
He stares at you, breath caught somewhere between ribs and throat.
âY/NâŚâ he murmurs.
You shake your head lightly, the movement loosening a curl near your cheek.
âWhen we stopped being friends in ninth grade⌠after everything happened with Tommy and Carol⌠I used to wish on shooting stars that youâd come back one day.â
Oh.
Oh no.
Oh God.
Steveâs chest caves inward.
You laugh softly, embarrassed. âStupid, right?â
He whispers back immediately,
âNo. No, itâs not. Not at all.â
You search his face, eyes tired and open and heartbreakingly honest.
âTonight⌠I feel seen. Really seen. For the first time in a long time. And itâs because of you.â
He canât speak.
He canât.
Because all he can think â over and over, deafeningly â is, âI see you. I see you so much it scares me.â
You give him a small, shy smile.
âSorry. Punch makes me chatty.â
He manages a breathless laugh. âYeah. Uh. Definitely the punch.â
You step a little closer. Close enough he can smell your perfume again. Close enough that your shoulder brushes his arm.
Close enough that if he leaned forwardâ
He doesnât. He canât. Heâs not allowed.
But he wants to.
God, he wants to.
You flick your cigarette away and wraps his jacket tighter around yourself.
âThank you for tonight,â you whisper again.
He forces himself to meet your eyes.
âY/N,â he says quietly, voice rough, âyou donât have to wish on stars anymore.â
You blink.
Because heâs looking at you like you hung the stars heâs talking about.
And before anything more can be said â before you can ask what he means, before he can ruin everything by answering honestly â
The gym doors crash open and Tommy Hâs laugh echoes across the lot, ruining the moment completely.
Y/N steps back, startled. Steve clenches his jaw.
Reality returns.
But something has shifted.
Something irrevocable.
Because you smile at him, a little shy, a little sad, a little hopeful.
And Steve â heart pounding, lungs failing â smiles back.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
The drive home feels like a dream.
You humming along to the radio. Steve sneaking glances when he thinks you arenât looking. You clutching his jacket around yourself because you still hasnât given it back.
They donât speak much. They donât have to.
The night feels suspended â like the stars themselves are holding their breath.
When he pulls into the Byersâ driveway, he parks but doesnât move.
Neither do you.
Not at first.
Then you laugh softly â a breathless, happy sound â and says,
âI donât think Iâve stopped smiling all night.â
Steveâs heart absolutely detonates.
âYou shouldnât,â he murmurs. âYou look⌠perfect when you smile.â
She turns scarlet.
He only realizes what he said after the words leave his mouth.
âOh. Uhhâ I meanâ not that you donât always lookâ you justâ tonight youâ you lookââ
You giggle.
Actually giggle.
âItâs okay, Steve. I know what you meant.â
He rubs the back of his neck, ears burning.
âGood. Yeah. Cool. Great.â
You both laugh â the easy, nervous kind â and finally climb out of the car.
He walks you to the door, steps slow, hoping the moment stretches on forever.
Y/N stops at the porch steps, turns to face him, and suddenly the world narrows to:
Your dress brushing the wood. Your curls catching the porch light. Your lips â soft, pink, parted just slightly.
You smile.
âTonight was⌠everything I never thought I would have. It was perfect, Steve.â
Steve swallows hard.
âIt was,â he whispers. âBecause of you.â
Your breath catches.
You take a tiny step closer.
And something electric snaps between them.
He feels it. You feel it. Even the porch light seems to flicker like, well? one of you is gonna do something, right?
Steveâs voice drops low â the kind of voice he only uses when heâs completely honest.
âYou know⌠I was scared to ask you.â
Your eyes widen.
âWhy?â
He laughs â short, nervous, rough.
âBecause you matter to me. Way more than I know how to handle.â
Your heart slams against your ribs.
You whispers, âSteveâŚâ
He steps closer â close enough that you can smell the sweet punch on his breath. Close enough that your dress brushes his legs. Close enough that your hand grazes his chest without meaning to.
His breath stutters.
âSo if tonight felt good for youâŚâ He hesitates â brave for once, stupidly brave. âI can promise you that it felt ten times better for me.â
Your eyes soften. Your lips curve.
You step into him â close enough that your foreheads almost touch.
Something in your chest bursts open, wild and warm.
âI should⌠probably go inside,â you whisper. But you don't move.
Neither does he.
You hover there.
Two heartbeats. Two breaths. Two people leaning forward without meaning to.
His hand lifts â fingertips brushing your cheek, trembling.
âY/NâŚâ he breathes.
You whisper back, voice barely a sound:
âSteveâŚâ
The door opens just as you can practically taste the cigarette you'd shared on his breathâŚ
Jonathan stands there.
Half-asleep. Hair everywhere. Wearing an old Clash t-shirt.
He looks between you.
Steve jumps back like heâs been shot. You nearly trip on the hem of your dress.
Jonathan blinks.
ââŚAm I interrupting something?â
âNO,â you both blurt in unison â suspiciously fast.
Jonathan lifts an eyebrow.
âMmhmm.â
You turn bright pink. Steve looks at the porch railing like heâs considering throwing himself off it.
Jonathan steps back inside, holding the door open with the weariness of a single dad whoâs been through too much.
âWell⌠come in before Mom thinks youâve eloped.â
You laugh â warm, mortified, full of butterflies.
Steve grins â actually grins â like he doesnât even care that you were caught.
And you walk inside, shoulders brushing, smiles matching.
Another almost-kiss lost. Another moment stolen.
But youâre not angry.
Youâre floating.
Giddy.
Because tonight?
Tonight, you both know something has changed.
Tonight, you both felt it. Itâs no longer if.
Itâs when.











