I really couldn't let this be on my dash and NOT respond to it.
I understand where you're coming from, and as someone who doesn't actually struggle with a mental illness this probably makes perfect sense to you.
Let me start off by saying that a lot of people who self-harm don't actually struggle with a mental illness.
However, mental illness CANNOT be fixed by "getting out" of a situation. Mental illness is something that is wrong with the person themselves, not the situation they're in. Often, if it is a situation that is making a person feel bad, they're not actually mentally ill. I'm not saying that the pain isn't as real or that the consequences of this are any less serious, but it isn't always mental illness.
"There are people in this world who are truly mentally ill and unstable. What I don’t understand is why so many people are desperate to fall under that umbrella. Is it just so they have an excuse?"
I am mentally ill. I was in no way desperate to be that way or to be labeled as having a mental illness (I actually have 3), and even though friends and family told me to go see doctors, I refused. I was scared to be labeled as mentally ill because I thought it meant I was "crazy". It wasn't until my second suicide attempt that I went to a doctor, and even then, I was forced by family (I was literally kicking and screaming) to go.
"To be honest, there are qualities within all of us that would hint some kind of clinical, classified illness, but why does it have to have a name? Why do we feel the need to be diagnosed? Wouldn’t you just want to be stronger and better and rise above it? Rather than look for signs of something seriously wrong with you and taking drugs to ‘fix’ it? Why can’t these feelings just be human?"
For some people, understanding that feelings of loneliness/depression/whatever else they might be feeling is just "human" IS enough. To realize that everyone in the world struggles with issues can help, and can make them feel less alone. But again, with people who are mentally ill, we can't see that. I remember talking to someone who self-harmed and she was trying to get me to realize that I wasn't alone in the world, and all I could think about was how annoying her voice was. I couldn't listen to what she was saying because I didn't believe her.
Also, if I didn't take "drugs to 'fix' it", I don't think I would be alive today. And maybe if I was, I'd be locked up in a treatment facility somewhere because I wouldn't be safe.
I agree that self-harm shouldn't be labeled as "beautiful". I always say that my scars are ugly. I would never want anyone to tell me they're not. I agree that telling people that THEY are the ones who are beautiful is what should be said.
I think my main point is that depression as a feeling and depression as an illness are two VERY different things, and self-harm can fall as a "symptom" under both categories.
I'm in no way trying to attack you or disagree with your opinion, I'm just more so trying to point out to others that you're talking about feelings rather than mental illness. Because mental illness can't just "go away". It's an illness, like any other illness, that needs treatment. And I want people to realize that mental illness should be viewed the same way as other illnesses - you're sick. That's not your fault. You need help. It's not a big deal. (I mean that getting help isn't a big deal (or rather SHOULDN'T be a big deal), not the illness itself.)
I'm sorry if this offends you or anyone reading it, I just worry that some people who are truly mentally ill might read your post and feel totally shitty about themselves. I know I would have a few years ago.
Keep talking about mental illness, though! We need to end the stigma attached to it.