The iPad is a wonderful product, but can do better.
* This post was originally written and posted on a social network on Monday, February 28 by the author, and then re-posted here later, which is why the dates referenced may seem back in time.*
I got my iPad last year, on the day known as Black Friday here (Thanksgiving). Having taken a test run once at an Apple store I loved it immediately, and now after months of using it daily, still feel the same way.
However, there are a few things that irk me.
The biggest issue is the fact that this product does not support Flash. Flash has been the technology of choice for most online video, with around 75% market share. With no support for Flash, it means most videos cannot be played on this device. Most of those crazy viral videos shared on Facebook , and those on Youtube, are Flash and end up looking like big empty black holes. How frustrating is it that a technology that is causing a change in our browsing habits, cannot support a video format that is a large part of the type of content we all browse daily!
Apple being Apple used its clout to make a business decision that is impacting every user that buys their product. To users it isn’t important how Apple justifies their decision, what is singularly most important is that despite using a “first-class” device, we still cannot be guaranteed the best experience. Imagine buying a first-class plane ticket and still getting cattle-class treatment!
Over time, newer technologies, such as HTML5, will be able to deliver the same, but it will take time for the newer technologies to ramp up, to be the technology of choice for videos produced going forward. But existing videos still may or may not be converted, and will need Flash to be viewed. There are rumors abuzz in the blogosphere that Apple may be reconsidering this decision to support Flash, but there are no official comments from Apple yet.
My second issue is the proliferation of apps. “Is there an app for that?” is an oft-repeated joke, and with good reason. As of last count there were 3000 apps in the Apple store for iPads alone...and growing by the minute.
The app store has spawned off an app development frenzy by every business under the sun, without due thought given to whether a mobile optimized website would have fitted the bill just as well or even better. Apps for location based services and for games are understandable and required. But apps for browsing news publications are the strangest in my opinion – what did they achieve by not making a mobile site instead?
Updates are necessary and required often. Apps need constant updates. The hardware itself needs constant upgrades – there’s no camera in the current version, but just wait and in a few months the “new, improved” version will have one. No wonder it’s been aptly called the “Wal-martization of the software channel”. Here is something humorous that sums it up well: http://theoatmeal.com/comics/apple
The iPad is a touch sensitive device. For typing, it brings up an onscreen virtual keyboard. While it has been designed well and does offer audible feedback (it emits a sound when a key is pressed) it is not quite as effective as a physical keyboard. The virtual keyboard lacks haptic feedback - a way to produce tactile feedback when a user taps or hovers over a key. If you’ve played the Wii or PS Move, you probably recall the feedback you get for an action.
This device is an example of a revolutionary product whose greatness quotient has been lowered by its own design. There are plenty of badly designed useful products out there, products that can be improved upon, but in this case we are talking of Apple. The company that is supposed to be the holy grail of user experience. Where the experience of the product starts even before it’s officially out in the market by the PR department leaking “rumors” and hosting launch events that anyone with any interest in tech wants in on.
This company designed a product which brought about a sea change in our consumption of online content. Yet it’s pretty obvious there are several aspects of the product that were not subjected to the same level of scrutiny as others. Inconsistent quality control or a carefully crafted business plan?
Either way, there are a few items I would love to see improved on the next-gen device. Let’s hope some of these are addressed – There are rumors of an iPad 2 announcement slated for Wednesday, this week. That’s less than 48 hrs away!
I would love to hear your own views of the device and what changes you’d like to see in the future. If you don’t own one and are planning to buy one, tell me why you look forward to it.