opinion on a character losing one eye in a traumatic event, but not the other? is any sort of eye trauma ableist to depict, or is it fine as long as its only one eye?
I’m not sure I have the ability to answer this, personally, and so I will turn it over to those who lost one eye themselves. The key is that while losing one eye is difficult and can certainly impair your daily life, you may not be considered blind. This is because blindness is measured with your best eye with best correction.
This means that a character who loses one eye may or may not be considered blind. It depends on level of vision in their other eye. This means they could have 20/20 vision in their remaining eye. It can also mean that they have one remaining eye that is blind. For example, their remaining eye has blind spots, only color perception, or tunnel vision.
Not all people with monocular vision are blind, but some are.
The RNIB has a good section on the difference under the header ‘can I register as partially sighted / sight impaired?’
Jessica Kelgren-Fozard also shares about having one blind eye and one with 20/20 vision in this video. She personally does not identify as blind.
This is me trying explain that while I might feel uncomfortable blind character losing an eye in a traumatic accident or to someone else deliberately injuring their eye, depending on how the event and the aftermath was portrayed, I can’t really speak for people like the ones in your question.
Readers with one usable eye who aren’t blind, what do you think?
I hope you can get some good replies in the notes. I would love to help with other things, such as writing lack of depth perception, if needed. The RNIB page I referenced also has a good section on coping skills that might help.












