‘That’s it?’ Toto’s smile fell at the words, slowly at first and then dropping altogether when the word nonsense left Judge’s lips. And then he asked him why—he actually asked him why! The fiery sting of anger lanced through Toto’s chest. This was not what he wanted. Both hands clenched into fists on the table’s surface but somehow, by some miracle, the rage did not spill over.
“I’m telling you,” he started, his tone kindling a kind of forced-calm despite being several notches louder than before, “because you were sad. You were worried that she’d be all alone. Remember?”
Only then did Toto realize he had been half-standing out of his seat. He sat back down, breathed tightly, wrestled down the urge to break things.
“I had to tell you the rest so you’d know. Because it’s the truth. And if you never knew, you’d go on being sad.” Toto flung a casual hand through the air, speaking as though the matter were obvious. His eyes wandered down to the stain on the tablecloth, and for a brief moment, he was quiet. When he looked back up at Judge, his expression had softened.
“You’re … my friend.” He punctuated the word with a firm nod, carrying the air of a new decree rather than a warm reminder but earnest all the same. “I want to stop you from drowning. You’re like this!” He put his palms at either side of his eyes, like blinders on a horse. “But I want you to be … like this!” Slowly, grandly, he pulled his hands away until they were outstretched at his sides. “Set free. Finding happiness. That’s why.”
Toto returned his hands to the table as he pinned the other passenger under a long, measured stare.
“Judge … do you think you’ll be able to be happy?”
Judge flinched at the mention of being his ‘friend’. It seemed unfair, at times, to speak harshly towards him. He had no doubt that Toto wholeheartedly believed in his preaching, and that his followers likely felt the same way, but it was impossible to justify. It would take nothing less than for him to personally find himself on that shining final stage for him to reconsider.
He tilted his head towards the ceiling, searching for a way to word his thoughts, but before he could -
“Judge … do you think you’ll be able to be happy?”
The question visibly caught him off guard. He glanced back down at Toto, waiting in hopes that he would have something, anything else to say. But the stretch of silence that followed afterwards demanded an answer out of him.
No one had ever asked before. Why would anyone ask? The thought had rarely crossed his own mind, after all. He thought back to the sleepless nights spent reading and studying, getting his degree, passing the bar exam. Then it was his coworkers and the other man, bending over backwards to please them, doing everything he could to keep them off his back.
Was that happy? Likely not. But with this question came many more.
“Why? Do you think I’ll be happy if I believe everything you say? If I die here today, do you think I could just throw everything away and be happy?” He voice was low at first, but it steadily began to pick up in speed and volume. “What about all the people who died before they can do everything they wanted to do while they were alive? Or the people who had to suffer while they lived? Do you think it’s easy for them to forget all that? Easy for them to just pretend like none of it ever mattered?”
Judge matched Toto’s gaze from across the table, unwavering.
“If your final stage can make everyone happy just like that, then why shouldn’t all of us drop dead right now?”