“Holly, it’s okay. There was legitimately no way you could have been there for me. No one even knew I was there,” Vi was quick to reassure, ignoring Holly’s words about if she needed to talk. She didn’t. Not quite yet. Her actual time at Our Lady had been uneventful, but thinking about that previous weekend only reminded her of what had gotten her put into that place in the first place. And that one was still a tricky topic. Until the dust had truly settled, she was pretending like it hadn’t happened and avoiding any reminders of it.
“I’m good, actually,” she insisted then, setting the offered cup down in favor of giving her full attention to seeing what she’d missed. Because apparently it was a lot.
“You did what?!” she asked as soon as Holly confirmed that she had, in fact, set her house on fire. “Holly! Is everything okay? Your moms… are they good? Did you figure out a way to loophole it? Are we talking a trashcan-sized fire or?” She kept firing off question after question, but they all felt like important ones to be asking.
Without even really waiting for answers, Vi pushed forward, determination evident in her tone. “Truth or dare has to stop. We need to stop it. It has gone entirely too far.” The demon could crush her relationship with her dad like it was a weak little bug, but between Holly setting her home aflame and Jamie being pushed to drown himself, she’d had enough. People were really going to start dying soon.
It didn’t matter that she couldn’t really have been there for her friend, what mattered is that she wasn’t. Come hell or high water Holly knew that she wanted to be right beside Violet fighting whatever demons came her way. That was the point of a friendship like theirs, the kind you get when you’ve never felt that kind of love and connection you could have for another human before. Whatever kind of pain her friend was experiencing, Holly wanted to rip it from her shoulders and offer to carry that burden together.
But Violet wasn’t ready, which was okay too. So she gave her coffee and pulled the old blanket from the back of the couch and draped it around her.
Slightly overwhelmed by the questions, Holly did her best to answer them. “Everything is okay, for the most part. No one was home when I did it. I god dared and the thing threatened to kill me and Edwina so I had to do it. I tried to start a small fire in my living room with candles and it worked a little too well. I um, didn’t realize how triggering flames can be for me. I ended up freezing instead of running out and Edwina called the fire department so I spend the weekend in the hospital on oxygen. I didn’t burn down my whole house. It’s only the living room that’s a mess so I would have out smarted it if I hadn’t freaked out. Maggie’s wants to sue the candle company and Lizzie is upset about her antique rugs but other than that everyone’s okay.”
“We do,” she agreed. If there was one thing everyone in the club could agree to at this point it was that stopping this life or death game of truth or dare needed to stop as soon as possible. “This whole thing sucks and I’m really tired of watching my friends almost die and/or traumatize themselves.”
When Holly-Eve finished her sentence, her face became demented like the night that thing had visited Violet and Charlie. ‘Holly’ laughed at Violet as if it was waiting for her to join in. In some sick way, it thought of them as old friends. Violet was one of its favorites now considering she played along so well last time.
“You want to stop me, Violet?” it whined, “Well the game is only over when I say it is! Just try to stop me. I dare you.” ‘Holly’ cackled in her face. “Just kidding! You already had a dare, Violet. Oh no, you’re getting truth, friend! I like to shake my games up. I get bored soooooo easily. I just have to change things up, but you know a lot about that don’t you?”
‘Holly’s’ head began to tilt to the side as she continued to look at Violet with wild eyes. When her neck should have naturally stopped moving, the girl’s head continued to tip until a SNAP broke the silence and a bone tried breaking through the skin. “Always hopping from friend group to friend group... Everyone says you’re so brave, but just how fearless could you be when you won’t even talk about your mother?”
Holly-Eve’s face was, unexpectedly, resting naturally once more. Had Violet triggered something for it to go away? When it seemed for a split moment that the thing had ran off, something called her from behind.
“Tell her why you really never had friends until now.” Mrs. Matthews (or whatever she was going by now) stood in the same outfit Violet had last seen her in before walking out on her family. The grotesque smile on her face let Violet know that this wasn’t really her back for her daughter, but there was something still very unsettling about the hallucination.
“You’re not so brave as you pretend to be, Violet.” another voice joined in. Suddenly, a swarm of Violet’s mothers circled around the two girls.
“Tell her how I ruined you and your father.” they all demanded collectively as they continued to glare at the blonde. “Tell her, Violet. Tell her.”