Sharing Your Dreams With A Crowd Of Strangers
There are a million and one blog posts out there about crowdsourced funding for musicians, tips, how-tos, dos and donâts and success stories. But no one ever talks about the emotional toll of a process that can be daunting and can have a serious positive or negative impact on the plans and trajectory of an artist depending on whether or not it succeeds.Â
Acacia Sears bravely invites us to witness her personal journey into the world of crowdfunding as her project launches and the outcomes are still unknown.Â
People are tired of crowdfunding. From Kickstarters to GoFundMes to Indiegogos and beyond, at least a few times a year (or, depending on your social circle, a few times a month) people are hitting up their friends for cash. Sometimes itâs for medical bills or similar pitfalls, sometimes itâs for a product that needs startup money, sometimes itâs for potato salad. There is no âmethodâ to going viral beyond a lot of hard work and an exponentially larger quantity of luck.
When I started planning for my Kickstarter, I found plenty of this irritation online. I also found a lot of practical advice. But I didnât see many people talking about the emotional costs. How do you deal with the worry that youâre annoying your friends? How does it feel to know failure is not only possible but easy? I still donât know the answers -- but I figure that if I write about my own journey with this campaign, other people will know what to expect, and that theyâre not alone.
In March of 2014, I left a job I loved because the business wasnât doing so well, my leaving would allow someone else to keep their job, and I wanted to have more time to spend with my kid (who was 1.5 years old) and work on my music. It was a financial strain for my husband and me; we no longer had to pay daycare, but we were still looking at a bit of stress from losing my income. We figured we would have about a year before things started to be unsustainable.
At the time, I was teaching music classes at my daughterâs daycare twice a week in exchange for two days of childcare. I learned a bunch of standard childrenâs songs, including âThe Wheels on the Bus.â At home, we sang the song often, and the Mommies on the bus and the Daddies on the bus always said âI love you.â At school, the Mommies on the bus said âshh shh shh,â and the Daddies on the bus said âkeep the baby quiet!â complete with finger wagging and stern faces.
This floored me. Daddies are just as capable as Mommies of soothing their distressed children, and the whole idea that a Daddy would sternly tell their partner in parenthood to âkeep the baby quietâ was upsetting and unfair. I took my outrage to social media, telling the story, and saying âwouldnât it be funny if I wrote an album of progressive, feminist childrenâs songs, with titles like âOnly Yes Means Yesâ and âPrincesses are for Everyoneâ and âWheelchairs are for Wheelies.ââ
The response was a resounding âYES YOU SHOULD DO THAT, I WOULD BUY IT.â My friend Josh even replied with âThe Mommies on the Bus Say F*** the Patriarchy.â
It had to be done. I would need to change it to âSmash the Patriarchy,â and I would probably need another more accessible, less confrontational title to draw in more people, but it went from a joke to a plan in the span of a few minutes. After much deliberation, I decided to name the project âYes Means Yes!â and adopted a new childrenâs music persona named Ms. Cacie (my nickname).
I spent the next year writing the songs. Most of my non-childrenâs songs are exceedingly personal, poetic, and donât come to me very frequently. With the Ms. Cacie songs, I was averaging more than one song a month, testing the songs out on the kids at the daycare, and strategizing the eventual launch of my Kickstarter campaign.
Youâre probably familiar with Kickstarter (see above, with the campaigns coming out once a month), but just as a reminder: a Kickstarter project does not receive ANY funding unless your minimum goal is reached. Anything past the minimum is gravy, but you must achieve the minimum or else nobody pays anything. This means thereâs a lot of pressure to get as much attention as possible, as quickly as possible. If you donât meet a certain threshold of attention, the entire thing is wasted effort.
But Iâm hoping to get paid, and that means putting a lot of creativity towards enticing people to contribute -- and calling in a lot of outside help, which increases my up-front costs. Most of the successful Kickstarters Iâve seen have had professional-looking videos. The pitches were short, informative, captivating, and worthy of sharing. If the person or group asking for support didnât have a broad fan-base, there would have to be a noticeable void in the world for the Thing they were attempting to provide. I asked a filmmaker friend to shoot and edit my video in exchange for a percentage of the minimum goal if the Kickstarter should be fully funded.
I did some estimations on filming the pitch, the costs associated with album production (recording, mixing, mastering, art, liner graphic design, and disc production), patron rewards, and what the last year of my lifeâs work was worth to me in dollars. I estimated somewhat high on costs and based my minimum on breaking even. I would rather see this thing exist than walk away from my dream, and if that means not getting paid, thatâs the risk Iâve decided to take.
Aside from the album itself in digital and CD format, I needed other incentives to encourage people to contribute at higher levels. First, I started with things I can do myself with no outside help: live performances, and a lyric book with chords, colorful âstarterâ ukuleles with custom, hand-painted designs or words (within reason). Then, I thought of things I could offer with other people contributing their work: t-shirts (I would need artwork), flower crowns (my persona evolved over time and now includes a recognizable crown of coral and peach-colored flowers, made by Taylorâs Maid Designs, who I found at a convention), and a limited-edition release of the album with the title âThe Mommies on the Bus Say Smash the Patriarchyâ (which meant hiring another artist to do a second album cover).
The problem is this: if I break even, I still donât have a day job, I no longer have the agreement with the daycare (times are tough, they need money, too), and as much as I believe in my own passion project, Iâm putting a lot on the line in the hopes that this will resonate with enough people to go viral and put my householdâs financial worry to bed for a while.
I am extremely active on social media, primarily Facebook, where I write about everything I deem important. This includes my deep, personal thoughts, struggles with anxiety and depression, every bit of art I create, my more intense political opinions, and the ever-more-horrifying status of my laundry situation. I keep a lot of this stuff accessible to âFriends Only,â but as an active and social musician, I often collect friends who have several other musician friends in common with me and people I might have met once at an open mic. I have sometimes been criticized for my openness about my personal life, but more often than not, Iâm praised for putting myself so nakedly out there with all my flaws; it makes people who feel like me feel less alone, and itâs always comforting to feel reciprocated.
I talk about my childrenâs music and planning my Kickstarter A LOT. I have gotten a spectacular amount of advice and support on Facebook. People share my YouTube videos, they âLikeâ my page, and there are a lot of potential supporters ready to click the button as soon as my campaign goes live.
Anyone and everyone within my immediate or peripheral social circle who might want to participate in the project is an ally. When I reached out to the woman who made my trademark crown, I told her my backstory and asked her if she would be interested in providing crowns for one of my rewards packages. She responded almost immediately, enthusiastically expressing her passion for my endeavor and wanting to help in any way she can.
These moments are the ones when the Imposter Voice In Your Head gets the wind knocked out of it. âSee voice?â you say to it, âOTHER PEOPLE BELIEVE IN ME.â
I would be horribly remiss if I didnât mention my husband, partner, and best friend, who has spent more than a year supporting our family while I have been working. I sit up at night, unable to sleep because there are too many ideas running through my head, and he offers suggestions, volleys ideas with me, and encourages me on the frequent days when the pressure to succeed outweighs the perceived amount of desire for my art. Between him and the pool of three other people whom I constantly message with ideas and anxiety, I have a very solid team on my side. On top of that, my frequent online posts about the Kickstarter provide me with the necessary feedback to keep me from sinking into the Pit of Unworthiness that so often keeps artists from creating or making their creations available to the public.
My current status:
I am waiting for my filmmaker friend to finish editing my video. I have started my Kickstarter page and filled in my rewards, though I keep tinkering with wording and pricing. I havenât filled in the âbiographyâ section yet - does anyone actually like writing autobiographical blurbs? I frequently oscillate between supreme belief in myself and my project and the crushing, all-consuming terror of failure.
If this Kickstarter fails, I will still have created an albumâs worth of entertaining, necessary-to-the-world songs, but I will have lost more than a year of my life to a failed dream. I will have to get a job that pays enough to more than cover full-time daycare in an economy that doesnât have a lot of jobs to spare. When I titled this piece, my goal was to express how it feels to create in myself these small, precious, fragile works, birth them, put them out for all the world to see, and then throw them at the mercy of strangers.
If this Kickstarter succeeds and does better than break even, it will mean that I was right: the world has a void for what I have to offer, and I had the creative ability and good fortune to offer it at the right time. It will reach people all over the world, children will hear the songs and receive valuable life lessons in an adorable and entertaining package. I will also be opening myself up to a truly terrifying amount of criticism. My song âOnly Yes Means Yesâ talks about how you shouldnât touch people without permission -- even for a hug. âPrincesses Are For Everyoneâ is about how fun doesnât follow gender norms. Perhaps the most controversial, âWe Are Who We Are,â is about how gender is fluid -- yes, even and especially among children -- and comes from the perspective of a child who is meeting the new kid in class, Alex, who is of indeterminate gender, how there was some confusion at first, but Alex says âitâs not important to me, but what do we have in common? Letâs do that!â There are a lot of people out there who will have nasty things to say about the implications of my songs. I will receive ugly threats.
Even if I win, I sort of lose.
I still aim to win.
Visit and support Acaciaâs Kickstarter project here:Â https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1368696403/progressive-feminist-music-for-children








