Countering post-finale NaruSaku "arguments"
Because they came up with ridiculous “arguments” since chapter 700, and twisted Kishimoto’s interview words.
Nope. Kishi said that he planned NaruHina in multiple interviews.
First interview:
かなり前からヒナタで決めていました。
“I decided to go with Hinata [to be with Naruto] from quite a while ago”
Second interview:
ナルトがヒナタと一緒になることは結構早い段階で決めていましたね。
“Naruto ending up with Hinata was decided on in the very early stages of the story”
Third interview:
僕の中では「NARUTO-ナルト」の少年期が終わって、 青年期に入った少し経った頃から「ナルトはヒナタとくっつく」と決まっていました。
“I’ve already decided that once Naruto’s teenage years are over, and shortly after entering his ‘young man stage’ (15-24ish) that “Naruto and Hinata will come/be together”. (trans by variatonia)
Not only that, but this interview here confirms that Kishi is anything but a sell out. Kishimoto is openly acknowledging that Hinata is more popular than Sakura, but he didn’t let that get the better of him and he kept Sakura the main lead female. That’s a good thing, especially because you can’t say he “sold out”. So while popularity troubled him, he didn’t let it get the better of him. He planned NaruHina from early on (he said this was the original intended pairing many times already), therefore popularity has nothing to do with the actual pairing.
Another example: He noticed that Kakashi was (getting?) more popular than Naruto, and thus toned him down instead of pandering. Kishimoto has flaws as a writer, but at the very least he stays true to how he wants to write the story, and doesn’t seem to be the type to cave-in for the sake of money.
“NaruHina wasn’t Kishi’s idea! It was SP’s! They gave him the idea for the movie!”
1) NaruHina has always been intended by Kishimoto himself. See above where he states multiple times that NaruHina was planned from early on.
2) SP had no idea about the baby boom in chapter 700. So SP’s anime team could not have manipulated Kishimoto into the pairings or the kids. They were shocked about the children.
3) It’s true that the anime staff gave Kishi the idea for a romantic movie and he went along with it. However, the scarf plot was based on his own personal experience and he created the plot. He received a scarf from his wife.
“When he was in meetings with the movie staff and they were planning the story, he mentioned that his wife had made a scarf for him and everyone went quiet, like, “Wow…” (this is our idea)” (trans by julinay)
I remember reading the anime staff thought the scarf plot was cliche, but Kishi insisted it had to be done.
4) When Kishimoto speaks about NaruHina romance and says this: “But I didn’t really think about the love story of the two (laughs), I hadn’t intended to write a story about it.” – It was taken out of context by NaruSaku fans (nothing new here). Kishimoto doesn’t mean he never planned NaruHina (he said he did, MANY TIMES), he just didn’t plan on writing about the specific love story. That’s why when the movie idea was brought up to him, he happily went along with it. He always wanted to include romance, but never did because he said he wasn’t good at it/gets embarrassed.
5) The movie is 100% Kishimoto approved and as canon as can be.
OrganicDinosaur translation and comments.
“Basically, Kishi said that he didn’t intend to expand upon how Naruto and Hinata actually got together sometime in between ch.699 and 700, (can mean either in manga or in the movie). The interpretation that “Kishi never intended for NaruHina at all” is wrong (based on other interviews too). It reads to me like he just didn’t intend on that particular aspect of their relationship to be fleshed out.”
“Sakura had romantic feelings for Naruto, Kishimoto confirmed it!”
Absolute bullshit. Kishimoto said this:
"I think Sakura hasalwaysbeen devoted to/had her mind set on Sasuke”
Same interview where he said Sakura would look terrible if she changed her heart from Sasuke to Naruto after so long, and the same interview where he said he planned Hinata ending up with Naruto quite some time ago.
Speaking of which. He never said he wanted NaruSaku. Ever. He never said he wanted to at all. This is what he said:
サクラにしようかと迷った時期もあってのですが
"At one point/period of time, I thought about [considered] Sakura [for the role]”
takL translation is this: “There was a time when I wondered if I should pick Sakura (for the role)”
While NaruHina was chosen first and the original, at one point he only considered/thought about NaruSaku. It’s natural to wonder/explore different paths to take your story. However, he scrapped that idea after realizing how bad it was and stuck to his original plan (which was NaruHina).
Kishi explicitly says that there was a time when he WONDERED whether he should change Sakura’s feelings. He quickly dismissed that idea because as he said, it would make Sakura look bad to suddenly switch from Sasuke to Naruto (cue fake confession scene here), especially after he’s become a “hero”. He only “thought” about changing her feelings; it wasn’t materialized. Aka, this change of feelings never happened in the manga and everything he did with NaruSaku was done on purpose with the intention of misleading (which he says in his new interview himself; 「だからこそ、ナルトとサクラがくっつくかのようにミスリードさせるために、あえてサクラとナルトの母親であるクシナの動きを重ねるかのようなシーンを描いたりもしたんです」。He drew Sakura compared to that of Kushina, Naruto’s mother, in order to mislead.) and keeping people interested. He never intended on actually getting Naruto and Sakura together. The relationship was always platonic, as we’ve said for years.
OrganicDinosaur translation:
“I decided from pretty early on that Naruto and Hinata would be together. So I kept Naruto and Sakura close together in order to make it misleading. I even dared to describe and draw parallels between Sakura and Naruto’s mother, Kushina, in repetitive scenes, on purpose, to achieve that effect.”
Why would Kishi say this if he intended NaruSaku? No. Sakura’s feelings have never changed. She has always and will always love Sasuke.
Here, another thing taken out of context from this interview.
ヒナタはナルトが最初から頑張ってるところをちゃんと見て、 ずっと応援していた唯一の子なんです。ナルトはうまくいかないけど頑張っていて、諦めないところが格好いいって分かってる。 サクラもそのことに途中で気づきますけど
“Hinata was the only kid who paid close attention to the way Naruto was working hard from the very beginning, and always supported him. She understood that the way he worked hard and didn’t give up even if things didn’t go smoothly for him was pretty cool. Not that Sakura didn’t realize that along the way too…” (trans by mezzomarinaio)
NOWHERE does this state or imply that Sakura returned or was close to returning Naruto’s feelings. NOWHERE does this state or imply she loved Naruto (hello, look at the previous interview where he states that Sakura has always loved Sasuke). He only mentions that along the way, she also noticed that Naruto was a hard worker; she noticed what Hinata did all along. Kishimoto just didn’t want to belittle Sakura, therefore he felt the need to mention she also saw Naruto as pretty cool later on.
~
I really don’t understand how people can twist things so much. It’s incredible.