"This puts Peter symbolically somewhere between father and Aslan for Lucy and - notably - closer to Aslan than their father, that is, closer to being the voice she loves best in the world. I think there is A Lot to be unpacked there" Oh man oh dude Oh Lord I really want you to unpack this please! If you can't or don't want to then thats okay! I love your writing!!
Well friend since you have asked HERE GOES
I think this scene where Lucy is trying to identify who is calling for her with ‘the voice she likes best in the world’, and her guesses go from her father to Peter to Aslan is one of the most interesting in the whole of the Chronicles. The order in which she puts them says a lot
Lucy’s actual father is a character we know almost nothing about. He’s father to her biologically and raises her early on, but he’s little more than that. At the other end of her list is Aslan. Christian lexicon is pretty strong on the idea of fatherhood, and in being at the top of the scale, Aslan is the perfect ‘father’ in a divine sense, but not a practical one.
Then in the middle we have Peter, suggesting that to Lucy, he’s the ‘father’ between her dad and Aslan who combines these things, halfway her practical parent and halfway divine leader.
The fact that Lucy is revising her guesses as she listens to the voice suggests that to her Peter’s voice is closer to Aslan’s than their father’s is. Given how Peter raised her the first time and knows her far better than their actual father, it’s not surprising that Peter is closer to being the voice she loves best in the world. Probably that also means closer to being the person she loves best in the world (which turns out to be Aslan). In Conclusion - Lucy is more attached to Peter than to her father.
What’s also important though is the fact that Lucy, when she’s at her closest guess, mistakes Aslan for Peter, and that has some serious implications about Peter. One thing the movies miss a bit is just how enormously powerful Peter is. He’s not just High King above his siblings, but above all Narnian rulers, forever - and in the books, Narnians are often obsessed with him specifically, over and above his siblings (this is also to do with his name and throne of St Peter, leader of the church, all that stuff - he’s also got a lot of similarities with King Arthur, for whom the lion is sometimes used as a symbol. To me Peter’s ‘High King’ character feels like Lewis went what if I combined King Arthur and...the Pope).
In terms of the chain of command, he’s one step below Aslan and above everyone else (which is why I’m obsessed with his book and LWW film characterisation being better than his PC film one, because I think a character who is burdened by that kind of power is more interesting than one who is possessive of it).
Lucy is traditionally the character who sees most clearly, and here she perceives her brother as being the closest thing to Aslan that is not Aslan himself, in a domestic sense of love and protection but also in a broader sense of overall authority and power. So that’s...something.