Why does Junji Ito's work turn into bad anime adaptations
Over the years, several anime adaptations have been made to the works of the master of horror, and all of them turned out underwhelming, acquiring pretty mediocre reviews. However, it's not like the source material is bad, we all know of Junji Ito's incredible storytelling and impressive artwork. This raises a question: why doesn't Junji Ito's work translate well into anime adaptations?
To answer this, let's dive more specifically into two factors: art style and the genre of his works.
Art Style
Junji Ito has a very unique art style that fits perfectly with the horror stories he creates. Take a look at a panel from his short story, Lovesick Dead (or Undying Love) of a mysterious boy who appears during foggy days.
Ito skillfully uses shading and the contrast between light and dark to create an ominous atmosphere, and the fact that the manga is drawn in monotone colors only further enhances this effect.
Furthermore, he uses a lot of lines and hatching to create detail, giving his artwork a grotesque look and an uneasy feeling. You can see this in the following scene from Uzumaki, where the protagonist's dad curls himself up in a barrel, forming the spiral shape.
Both of these features are difficult to translate into anime, as it would take too long to draw each frame (we know that the anime industry is very harsh and demanding). As a result of the flat colors and simplified designs, the story loses part of its charm. You can see by the comparison between the manga and the anime in this scene from Tomie.
Genre
This is more of me talking in general, but horror anime usually don't compare to the manga (of course, there are exceptions). In my opinion, the best way to enjoy horror manga is late at night, alone, in complete silence. Anime takes away a lot of the suspense. In the case of the Junji Ito Collection, not only did they use a j-rock song for the opening song, the background music is often inappropriately used, destroying the otherwise ominous atmosphere. This makes the overall experience of watching the show less enjoyable and could be a reason why many people disliked the series.
Final Thoughts
The reason why I decided to make this post is that I recently found out there's going to be an anime adaptation for Uzumaki, coming out in October 2022 (it was actually announced a long time ago, I was just out of the loop for some reason). I was pretty skeptical about this at first, however after watching the trailer (click here) and the teaser (click here), it is safe to say I have faith that the final product will turn out good. The music is perfectly sinister and creepy, and the art could not be closer to the original. The fact that they decided to keep the show monochrome means that it can truly capture the essence of the original work, so I look forward to watching it when it comes out.









