I have an idea: letâs detach these two slogans from their controversial contexts and present them side by side as a basic joint statement we as reasonable people can announce our agreement with. That way anyone on the right who doesnât believe that black lives matter (regardless of how they feel towards the group itself) can be cast out and recognised as a racist. Ditto with the left for IOTBW - you can despise the people who came up with the idea and recognise it as disingenuous while still agreeing itâs fundamentally true.
Youâre equating apples to nuclear waste.
Black Lives Matter, the racist domestic terrorist organization, is backed by years of violence and millions of violent racists.
Itâs Ok to be White wasnât backed or supported by any group except a couple guys on 4c who wanted to prove racism against white people and succeeded.
But that's my point - if you remove it from any context, boil it down to a simple unloaded statement, we can use it as a separating point for moderates and extremes. At the moment the extremists have been able to frame the statement to their ends - either you agree and must get on board with vile anti-white racism or you disagree and they can call you a vile anti-black racist. It creates a system where the moderates are drawn to one extreme or the other.
Imagine how much better it would be if agreeing with both these statements was essential to participate in moderate discourse. I don't want to talk to anyone who believes it's not OK to be white (I'm white and have absolutely zero shame in it) but equally I have nothing in common with someone that believes black lives don't matter. I'm happy for people to hold these views but I'm not happy to enter into any discussion with them. Unless it begins and end with me calling them a racist fuckwit.
I'm with you on one thing though - BLM the group is a whole different ballgame than IOTBW. I only equate them because I suspect, coming from 4C, there's a disingenuous and even sinister motive behind it. The statement itself has the potential to be very noble and on face value I'm in complete agreement, but then I thought BLM was entirely noble at first.























