Iâm kinda fucked up rn, Iâm posting this anyways because I know my Gareth girlies are out there and I love you guys
7 minutes to forever - Gareth Emerson x Reader
Warnings: Gareth is a virgin, boner talk, male masturbation, smut, first time sex, mutual pining, awkwardness, I donât like talking about condoms they gross me out but I tried to use one for once
It was a small party of sorts at Steveâs house, and of course Eddie was going to be there because thatâs his boyfriend.
Eddie tried to invite all the people from the club, so his friends can meet Steve and Steveâs friends, hoping everyone could kind of merge and coexist but you and Gareth were the only two to show up out of the group.
The rest were just a few of Steve and Eddieâs mutual friends, including Robin. Lately, Eddieâs been on your ass about a certain something and he sees it as some sort of sign that you and Gareth both came.
âItâs been way too long. Just go fucking tell him.â Eddie begs you.
âTell him fucking what, exactly??â
âThat you literally want to fuck him. Have you seen this dude? Zero chance heâll reject you. Heâs such a virgin heâd probably cream his pants just from you speaking to him.â
âThatâs just it, I donât wanna like⊠fucking corrupt him.â
âHe wants you to corrupt him.â
âYep.â He shrugs. âHe wants you too, itâs so PAINFULLY obvious to everyone except you guys. Weâre all tired of hearing about it.â He gestures to the rest of your shared friends.
âNo, I- I donât believe you. He doesnât like me, thatâs why I havenât fucking said anything.â You whisper, now.
âAlright.â Eddie announces a little louder than he needs to be, and gets up. He grabs your wrist and starts pulling you.
âNo, no, no. Eddie, stop, Iâm so serious.â
And now you were standing in front of him.
âGareth, here. Talk to her.â
You start to try and run the other way, away from this confrontational situation, but Eddie catches you.
âJesus Christ, itâs like taking care of literal children. If you wonât say it, I will. Y/N, Gareth has a huge crush on you. Gareth, Y/N is practically obsessed with you, wonât shut up about how cute you are.â
You put your head in your hands.
âThere, I said it, now be normal human beings.â He says, patting you both on the shoulder and walking away, leaving just the two of you standing near the kitchen while everyone else was in the living room, in another world.
âIâm sorry. About him, uh, yeah. I donât know why he did that.â You say quietly, looking at the ground.
âThatâs a relief. I donât think either of us were gonna say something.â
âYeah, probably not.â You laugh.
âOkay, so weâre locked in here.â You sigh.
Eddie basically shoved you two into a hall closet, yelling about âseven minutes in heaven,â which was a stupid game thing you thought only middle schoolers did. You protested, but he was very insistent, and you gave up. He was just fucking with you two, being extra mischievous tonight for some reason.
âYou know you donât have to listen to him, right? You donât need to do anything, you know, sexually. Itâs perfectly fine to not want to.â
âI- well, I want to.â
âWhy donât you then?â
âDonât know. Nervous, I guess. Just really nervous.â
âWould it help if I made the first move?â
You lean in quickly after that to press your lips against his. Even though he knew it was coming, it still shocked him, enough to jump a little a draw back.
âNo? Itâs okay.â You try to reassure him despite all the mixed signals you were getting from this boy.
âYes. Please. Iâm sorry about that.â
âYou do it then. I know you can.â You smile.
This time he leans in, despite his anxiety screaming in his brain. Itâs sweet, so sweet, and his lips are soft and gentle. You reach up to rest your hand on the side of his face, lightly rubbing your thumb against his cheek while you kiss him.
His hands find your waist and rest there while you try to let him lead so you donât overwhelm him. But soon, he suddenly pushes you against the wall. Not too rough but not as gentle as he had been, but you liked it either way, draping your arms over his shoulders.
This was something youâd always wanted, to kiss him, and you never thought it would happen in a million years. You thought he probably thought of you as just one of the guys, but apparently he didnât. He adored you, but heâd never say that to you out loud.
You make out with him to the point you almost canât breathe but couldnât bare breaking the kiss to get air. You fingers tangled in his soft, curly hair, accidentally pulling it a little forgetting that to some people that just hurts. He didnât say anything, though, and you just continued running your fingers through his locks at the back of his head.
âSeven minutes are up!!â Eddie calls, walking towards the closet to free you.
âShit, um..â Gareth looks down, which was a mistake because it made you look down too.
He got a boner just from kissing you, but now that your time is up, he doesnât know what to do.
âSorry.â You whispered.
âItâs not your fault.â He laughed a little.
âSo, whatâd you two get up to in here?â Eddie asks, after swinging the door open. Gareth moves quickly past him and into the bathroom as swiftly as he can.
âYou canât just put people in closets, Eddie.â
âI did, though, so yeah. I can. Please tell me you at least kissed.â
âThat is SO none of your business.â
âIâll take that as a yes. Finally.â He exclaims the last word. You walk back with him to where everyone was gathered in the living room and once you sat down, you started daydreaming about what Garethâs doing in there. You know what heâs doing, realistically, but you couldnât stop imagining it.
In the bathroom, he stands in front of the sink with his dick in his hand, desperately fucking his fist just needing to get this out of his system. Instead of having to see his reflection in the mirror in front of him, he shut his eyes and thought of you.
God, all the things he wanted to do with you, to do to you. But just then, the way you kissed him deep, the way your fingers tangled in and pulled on his hair, the way he had you up against the wall. He finishes quickly thanks to these thoughts and mental images, release spurting out into the sink and the last bit of it dripping onto his hand.
He tries to catch his breath, washing his hands and cleaning up his mess, then looked at himself. He fixed his hair to look as normal as possible, cooled off, and went back to join everyone.
âWhere the hell have you been?â Steve asks, only just noticing the boyâs absence.
âI had to use the bathroom, okay?â He answers defensively.
âOkay, jeez.â Steve said, raising his hands.
Gareth finds that his previous seat had been taken, and looks around nervously. You lock eyes with him and pat the place beside you on the couch. He smiles shyly and comes to sit.
As you all watched the movie, and no one was paying attention, you grabbed his hand and held it in yours, scooting closer. You leaned your head to rest on his shoulder, and he smiled secretly.
He made you feel all warm and happy on the inside, just like the perfect boy. That night really solidified your feelings for him, and you hope it did to him too. You thought about him a lot. Were you on his mind too?
Well, maybe tonight you could find out. DND was done and a couple of people were going back to Eddieâs for some beers or whatever alcohol his uncle had around. It was a Friday, after all.
When you got dropped off, it looked like everyone was already there. That meant he was too. He didnât have a car, so he had to have ridden with somebody. Why did you have butterflies in your stomach at the thought of going into Eddieâs trailer? Since when is that a big deal?
You pushed it aside, the nervousness, and stepped in anyway.
âHEY, look whoâs here. Thought you werenât coming for a while there.â Eddie says.
âSorry, I had to go home and change and everything, you know..â
âAlright, so⊠drinks. Weâve got two options. You ready?â
âSo excited.â You say sarcastically.
âOh, god. Terrible. Theyâre both terrible. A beer, I guess.â
He laughs and gets you one. You head into the living room again where everyone is, taking a sip of the shitty and not very cold beer.
The couch is full so you take a seat on the floor, it looked like they were all passing a joint around. When it comes to you, you decline, giving it to the next person. The next person was Gareth, who also declined.
âYou guys are total losers.â Eddie said, calling you out for not participating.
âIâm not a loser, I just donât wanna be high.â Gareth says defensively.
âYeah, me neither. Realistically, I donât even want this beer. Itâs gross, Eddie.â
âWell when none of us are 21 yet, you take what you can get.â
âIâm tired of sitting on the floor. Can me and Gare go hang out in your room?â
âGo have fun, you crazy kids. Weâll be in here, watching TV and talking VERY loudly.â Eddie wiggles his eyebrows at you.
âWhatever.â You roll your eyes, walking back to Eddieâs bedroom while Gareth follows and shuts the door behind him.
âListen, Iâm not trying to push anything on you. I didnât want time alone to do that stuff, I just wanted to spend time with you.â You say, sitting down on the bed.
âYeah, okay. I wanna spend time with you too.â He laughs. So cute.
He laughs, blushing a little. âSure.â
You lay down together, becoming intertwined, resting your head on his chest. You stay that way for a while, you couldâve stayed that way forever.
âHey,â he says after about 15 minutes, and you lift up, resting on your elbow.
âCan I kiss you again?â
His lips come to meet yours and they melt together, and suddenly so do your bodies. They press against each other, radiating heat and warmth. He wants more, he wants more so bad, but he doesnât want to push it and he also just doesnât know how to ask. His hand is on your waist again, hovering slightly.
âCould I- would it be okay if-â he starts.
âYeah?â He asks anxiously.
âYou can do literally whatever you want to me.â You assure him.
Immediately hard as a rock, immediately entranced. It was true, in your defense, you liked him *so* much,
âI mean it.â You whisper.
His hand starts to move, ending up on your ass, squeezing tightly. It also pulled you impossibly closer to him, bodies pressed together. You put your hand on his face again, holding it sweetly but firmly while you kiss.
Your tongues explored each otherâs mouths again, more familiar this time, and his hand moves up to squeeze one of your tits while the other arm props him up on his side. He needed more than this, he needed to feel your skin.
He slipped his hand into your sweater from the bottom, moving up until he felt your bare breast which he wasnât fully expecting. He thought you were wearing something, anything underneath but you werenât.
His cool fingers run over your hard nipples, making you gasp a bit, and so he goes farther and pinches one of them which makes you squeak in surprise. He just continued to feel your torso, hands running all over your stomach and chest and hips and tits.
You reached for the bottom hem of the sweater and pulled it off over your head, letting him be able to see what heâs doing, and his eyes grew wide as saucers. His eyes wandered shamelessly, curiously, all over, nearly burning a hole in you.
âYou⊠you like them?â You ask, giggling a little bit. He was so beyond fascinated and you could see that.
âYes, holy shit, yes.â He responds almost under his breath.
You take some of his soft locks in your hand and guide him down, wanting him to try sucking on or licking your nipples. He does, latching on quickly, expertly.
You start to melt now, holding onto his hair while you moan quietly. He climbs on top of you and brings his mouth to the other nipple, giving it the same attention. He gets the idea to move up to your neck, and starts kissing there.
This is where you totally fall apart, your weakness. Your noises encourage him to kiss your neck with more passion and fervor and you can feel his erection pressed against your thigh.
You reach down to grab onto it, palm it, and he sucks a particularly harsh mark onto your neck in the sweet spot when you do. Youâll definitely have a bruise, but you donât mind at all.
âFuck,â he breathes into your shoulder, stopped for a moment.
âYou okay?â You check in, pushing him up so you can look him in the eyes.
âThink Iâm just⊠god, Iâm nervous. Thatâs so embarrassing.â
âNo, thatâs okay.â You reassure. âWhat do you want?â
He burns red. Heâs not gonna be able to say it out loud himself.
âDo you want to have sex? Be honest.â
âGood, because I do too. But Gare, we can stop at any moment. Just tell me, okay?â
You reach down to untie the strings on the waistband of your sweatpants and pull them off your body, leaving you in pink panties in front of him.
You feel him staring again, at the sight of you anxiously squeezing your legs together and waiting for him to make the next move.
You were so turned on it was unbelievable, with him have not even touched you there yet. You were sure you were soaking. He fumbles with his button and zipper, looking behind him.
âYes, the doorâs locked.â
âOh. Good.â He half-laughed, because that is indeed what he was checking for. He takes his pants off and climbs back on top of you, only in his t shirt and boxers now.
He slots himself between your legs after you happily spread them for him. You could feel his cock so much better now, rock solid and a really nice size. He ruts his hips up against you, only the barriers of your respective underwear blocking the way.
He buries his face between your shoulder and neck, kissing on it again, and his hard cock continually presses against your cunt. You accidentally moan, a moan too loud for the situation, but you just have to hope no one heard it because you couldnât help it.
âShh,â he soothes, covering your mouth with his.
âSorry,â you whisper, into the kiss, smiling. You can feel him smiling too.
âShould- can- what should weâŠâ
âItâs up to you, remember? Whatever you want, however you wanna do it.â You remind him, trying to give him some confidence.
âRight. Can I take these off, then?â He asks, slipping his finger into the waistband of your panties.
You didnât want to come off as desperate and impatient, but you were growing to be. It wasnât his fault, though, you had to remind yourself heâs never done this before. He does, pulling the fabric down your legs and leaving you bare. Quickly after that, he pulls his own underwear off.
âIâm really wet, so whenever youâre ready, Iâm ready.â
âOh, shit, okay. Wait, donât we need a condom?â
âEddie should have some, if you want.â
You didnât need one, being on birth control, but you wanted to do whatever made him more comfortable. He digs around in the nightstand and quickly finds some, taking one and putting it on.
âOkay.â He repeats, finally ready. You smile as if to tell him âgo aheadâ. You immediately learn that he isnât familiar with easing into it, as he fills you up completely right away. This made you gasp, but luckily not too loud.
âOhh, fuck. Fuck, fuck, fuck.â He groans.
âSo good, you feel so good. Start moving, baby boy.â
That slipped out. That did slip out but he did not seem to mind the pet name at all, only listening to what you said and starting to thrust in and out.
You bite down on your bottom lip to keep quiet, only letting whimpers and soft moans out every now and then. You looked him in the eyes longingly, even though he was right there, and you felt yourself starting to love him in that moment.
He lets his dominant hand roam up to your throat, only to rest there. Thinking. You nod, reading his mind, answering his silent question and he squeezes gently. Soft but intoxicating. He continues to choke you with his big hand wrapped around your neck and leans down to kiss you again.
He finds a rhythm he likes, and starts to fuck you with more confidence. He wasnât the biggest youâd ever had, but he still stretched you out and reached pretty deep inside.
Amazingly full of him, you still keep your noises quiet as much as you can. You couldnât believe it, Gareth, you and Gareth were having sex. If the you from a month ago heard that, she would say âno fucking way.â But here you were. He wasnât being super vocal, so you only hoped he felt good too. Damn, it would be nice to hear him though.
âStill okay?â You ask.
âThe best.â He replies, and you smile.
He moves his hand from your throat back to fondling your breast, other one holding up his body weight over you.
He ends up getting quite aggressive while chasing his high, slamming into you quickly and filling the room with the sounds of sex. You think back to what Eddie said about watching TV and talking loudly and you stop worrying about that.
You were close, walls fluttering around him, but you knew you most likely wouldnât get to finish. Youâd just do it yourself later when you got home. The memory of this will be more than enough to masturbate to for a really long time, you think.
Coincidentally, he starts getting sloppy, thrusting haphazardly and clearly searching for something. Determined, he soon found it, cock twitching inside of you as he filled the condom and let out a long string of curse words and groans when he came.
He once again leant forward, resting his head on your shoulder for a moment. Neither of you wanted to move, and the pressure of him on top of you was so comforting, but eventually he had to.
Once all was done, you lay together, just as you had started out.
âDo you⊠like, actually like me?â He asks, head turning to you.
âNo shit, Gareth. Yes, I like you.â You say sarcastically. You hope it didnât come out mean. Thankfully it didnât, because he laughed.
âSo, you can totally tell me to fuck off if this is stupid, but⊠do you want to be together? You and me? Or is that stupid-â
You shut him up with a kiss, because he wouldâve rambled on forever and you already had the answer.
âYes. Iâd like that.â You smile.
âOh, okay. Cool, cool.â He laughs, feeling a huge weight off his shoulders. You melt into his arms, but you get interrupted when he suddenly realizes something.
âOh, shit. Iâm terrible.â He says, out of nowhere.
âYou were supposed to⊠finishâŠ.too. You didnât- I did something wrong.â He says, covering his face with his hands.
âI donât care about that. Itâs okay, I promise. If it bothers you that much, you can next time. Iâll help you.â
âNext timeâŠâ he repeats idly.
âYeah? I just kinda assumed thereâd be a next time..â
âYes. No, youâre right, there will be. I just liked the sound of that.â