Social Media Success: Not all platforms are created equal for social media success
Charli D’Amelio is TikTok’s largest star with nearly 50 million subscribers. Felix Arvid Ulf Kjellberg, or better known as PewDiePie, is the person with the most subscribers on YouTube with 103 million. Twitter’s top profile is President Barack Obama, followed by 115 million users. On Instagram, soccer player Christiano Ronaldo takes the prize with 213 million followers.
But why is there such a large difference between the top performers on these social media platforms? Below is a list of the top performers on each platform as well as their performance on other social medias.
When we look at this data, we can see that the numbers vary drastically on all platforms, with President Barack Obama having the highest number of users on Twitter but not being active at all on TikTok or YouTube.
Part of this has to do with the characteristics of the social media platform. Using social media is essentially self-marketing, meaning each decision made on the platform is a decision about your personal brand. Therefore, the use and strategy of social media is your personal marketing strategy.
For example, TikTok and YouTube are video platforms. To be successful on these platforms, one needs to be comfortable in front of the camera and in creating original content. TikTok and YouTube tend to include collaborations between other users as well, which expands brand awareness and audiences. The more collaborations that a user does, the more potential followers they can expose their content to.
On the other hand, Twitter and Instagram tend to be more still content. Photos can be staged and retouched, tweets are well phrased to fit the character limit. Additionally, Twitter and Instagram have more room for audience engagement through the form of replies, retweets, and interactive Instagram stories. Twitter and Instagram also tend to be more popular among celebrities with packed schedules because they can be run by a team as opposed to the one celebrity. With a video, the celebrity needs to spend time to make the video. With a photo post, a staff member can upload a few-weeks-old photo to the celebrity’s account to gain traction.
Social media usage is also dictated by the personal brand and unique features. PewDiePie became famous for livestreaming him playing video games and has since branched out into collaborations with other YouTubers. But this skill set and this audience is not likely to find a 140 character tweet interesting, since it does not align with his brand. Therefore, PewDiePie has chosen to align his social media usage with what is demanded of him by his subscribers.
Additionally, Charli D’Amelio is famous on TikTok for dance videos and modeling. It makes sense that her largest social media platforms are TikTok and Instagram as that is where she can best highlight short dance clips and stunning photos.
Personal Marketing is so similar to Corporate Brand Marketing. Once you figure out the product you offer better than anyone else, you have to find where you can best sell or market that product. After that, you have to determine how to make money off yourself, whether through paid brand promotions or acting/modeling contracts, etc. Then, you have to continuously put out content on your chosen platforms to keep promoting yourself and your personal brand. The 4Ps apply to every kind of marketing, even if you’re a 15-year-old TikTok star from Connecticut who is marketing in your bedroom.
As platforms rise and die, it will be interesting to see what platforms take over in the future. YouTube is beginning to fall as younger users prefer short clips to long videos. Instagram is taking over Facebook, and many in Gen Z don’t even have Facebook accounts. So, which platform do you think will withstand the test of time? Is TikTok going to win this battle? Will Twitter become the next MySpace? I guess we will have to wait and see.









