The gender swap dynamic was the whole point of Fionna and Cake. It was the fun! It's why those episodes were made in the first place!
But the second the rules mean they need to include a trans woman...out the window, she's a genderless plant person that just happens to develop female characteristics as she grows. Sounds a lot like female puberty to me...
Hunter's breasts (or lack there of) are shown proudly to signal to the viewer his overt transgender identity, but Huntress gets no such fanservice moment. Her breasts appear. They just show up as she grows. She does not need to assert her own gender identity, Fionna assigns she/her while she's still a 10 inch cabbage patch kid. Huntress Wizard might as well be afab.
Maybe the show will include more scenes that do show Huntress is transfemme, atleast in some Oo way. But to have her gender swapped counterpart be transgender overtly and to chose a more obfuscated path for huntress is just. It makes me sad.
I was so excited for trans Huntress Wizard, but I don't think we're going to get it. Trans women cannot be allowed on television.
I can understand where youre coming from, but I really dont think thats a good interpretation of the gender expression in this story.
The whole "assigned plant at birth" thing can be a joke if you want it to be, but the fact is huntress isnt human. Her biological sex, if she has one, is not something that fits in a human binary. Her chosing to present as female is indicative of an identity she landed on herself.
Plus, we dont know what pronouns huntress used as a child. For all we know, maybe she was training with her father because he thought she was a boy
Huntress and Hunter are both people who chose to present as a gender other than the one they were assigned at birth. They are both currently presenting as genders opposite to each other. Their current statuses as a trans man and a trans woman are what make them gender-bends of each other, not what genders they were in the past.
Just because nobody explicitly misgenders either of these characters doesnt mean they arent good trans representation.
And I'm sorry that the animators didnt give her a plant dick, but just because Huntress isnt the same kind of trans as Hunter doesnt mean she isn't trans. She doesnt need to have a very specific gender background in order to be the "correct" gender now.













