Okay so this is a random unfinished thought I've had for a while and it's usually something I'd keep for myself, but I remembered I have free will and I want to complain so bear with me
Friendly reminder that this isn't me talking about any person in particular and also people are allowed to like and do whatever they want in the fandom. At the end of the day we're all people playing with dolls and the way people play with dolls isn't any less dignified than the way I want to play with them. But I do want to talk about this larger fandom trend I noticing.
Honestly, something about how fandoms often treat gender expression really bothers me, and I don't think I've ever been able to articulate why until now.
I'm writing my own iteration of TMNT, rigtht? And without giving too much away, my version of Casey is going to be some flavor of trans (FTM, MTF, or nonbinary is still something I'm deciding but that's not too important) and while I'm thinking about that, I've come across a lot of genderbent TMNT content, and it almost never fully sits right with me :////
The problem isn't the genderbending itself. The problem is how shallow it often feels.
Most genderbent versions feel like a new coat of paint slapped onto the character without any real interrogation of what changing that character's gender would actually mean in the broader narrative comtext of the media piece. The core premise stays untouched. The dynamics stay untouched. The character behaves the exact same way, just in a skirt or with a beard.
Take Splinter, for example. Genderbent Splinter is usually just… Splinter. Maybe with a few surface-level tweaks to better fit a "female mentor" archetype, but fundamentally identical. Same authority, same role, same relationships. And that doesn't make sense because a female wouldn't be a ninja, they would be a kunoichi, and that's fundamentally different.
The TMNT characters aren't loose archetypes you can swap bodies on without consequence. Gender doesn't exist in a vacuum (as much as some people would like to pretend it does) and it shapes how people are raised, how they're treated, how much authority they're allowed to have, and how conflict plays out around them.
Take April as an example, as a female reporter, she'd be constantly dismissed or underestimated in ways a male reporter simply wouldn't be. That matters because it changes how she navigates the world. Sure, a reporter talking about aliens would sound just as crazy to a regular person while talking about aliens and evil ninja clans, but how many men have created careers out of talking about secret organizations and chemicals in the water making the frogs gay? Wilder stuff has been said by men who have become rich out of it, while women wouldn't be given as much leeway.
And then there's Casey Jones.
You can't just slap a "tough guy" persona onto a woman without addressing how society treats "difficult women." Rebellious, aggressive men are allowed to be messy, violent, and antisocial. Rebellious women are only accepted if they're still sexually appealing, holding a gun and looking sweaty and sexy with their shirt stuck to their lean body, but not so much with broken noses, missing teeth, and sweaty, but not the sexy sweat that makes nipples come out of shirts, but the "I haven't showered in two days and I just ran a marathon" kind of sweat that makes you smell like it. A female Casey would be read very differently, and ignoring that erases half the character's tension.
And that's before you even get to the turtles.
If the turtles were female, they wouldn't just be "female ninjas." They'd be kunoichi— and kunoichi, at least in how the show frames them, are trained differently than male ninjas. While the TMNT 2012 show doesn't go too deep into it, it's implied that female ninjas are more trained in the art of manipulation, disguise, infiltration. Karai is at her best in the show when she's operating in those spaces. (Because let's be real, she loses pretty much every hand to hand combat that she's in.)
That would completely change the turtles’ upbringing. Their training. Their fighting styles. Their emotional conditioning. You can't just switch pronouns, slap a bow on their bandanas and eyeliner and call it a day.
The same goes for the Shredder and Splinter feud. If they were both women, you couldn't maintain the same narrative for their tragic backstories. Two women wouldn't fight over a man the way Saki and Yoshi did— especially NOT in a traditional Japanese context.
That conflict would be quieter. More subtle. More insidious. Manipulation. Seduction. Some poison that goes wrong. An assassination attempt in the dark that hits the wrong target. The tragedy would still be there, but it wouldn't be "she's not yours" kind of fighting in a burning down dojo the way Yoshi and Saki's fight went down, a female Saki would probably try to kill a female Yoshi in the middle of the night, and a male Tang Shen would probably wake up and try to stop it, and maybe that's when things would turn south.
And that's really what frustrates me.
As someone who's been gender non-conforming from a young age, I notice how rarely people actually think about what it means to exist in a gendered body. I see "character but in a skirt" or "character but a dude," and it makes me roll my eyes.
People slap the turtles in bows and skirts and nail polish and give them the period cramp ray, but Raphael is still hyper violent and has anger issues, Donatello still has creepy incel tendencies, Mikey is still the party dude even if he was raised by what would certainly be a very disciplined japanese woman, and Leonardo is himself but with eyeliner
This also happens far more often with male characters than female ones, because masculinity is treated as the default. When a character is genderbent from male to female, one of two things usually happens:
1. They're exactly the same, just female-presenting.
2. They’re the same character with a "female personality"— same thoughts, same instincts, but plus makeup or traditionally feminine interests layered on top and what people think are feminine personality traits. But the thought processes? How a person actually sees the world and thinks about it? Still a masculine worldview.
And idk if it's because I was raised in a mostly female household, or because my friendships shifted from mostly male to female over time, or because I exist somewhere outside neat gender boxes myself, I just can't help but see how deeply gender shapes behavior, perception, and one's worldview.
The concept of a wise mentor isn't intrinsically male. But the concept of a ninja master is, unless you fundamentally change the gender rules of your world and shifting the power dynamics between men and women just to justify maintaing the character's personality intact is a whole can of worms by itself. You can't just write Master Splinter with boobs and expect everything else to stay the same.
Gender isn't just presentation. It's history. It's perception. It's pressure. It's social punishment. It's your entire life from the moment you are born to the clothes they'll bury you in, and I really think more AUs and fandom content that genderbends characters would be far more interesting when it actually considers how gender would affect a character's upbringing and their story, so that it still maintains the core, but actually feels like a masculine or femine version of the thing.
And I wish fandom engaged with that more deeply instead of treating gender as a costume change for the characters