A QUESTION THAT BEGETS ANOTHER OBVIOUS QUESTION: ARE YOU ASKING THIS BECAUSE OF HIM?
sometimes, despite himself, and despite every reassurance from clara that it isn’t the case, elliot can see the absence. he can see the shape of it. he imagines it not like his shadow but like something next to him. here is where the person he was before should be. and here he is, adjacent, not quite the same, overlapping but not filling the same space in the same way. he knows that there are differences. he knows it, because he knows himself, and he knows what happened. he, as elliot alderson, as the person who he is now, would not have done even half of the shit that was done during his missing year.
krista would say that he should be honest, that he shouldn’t go searching for the answer that his alter would give. that there’s no point in it. but the part of elliot that is always, always expecting to be left, that maybe sounds a little like mr. robot and mostly like the inside of his own head, is ready to look for it. so in the silence he does look for it. he tries to conjure up what sam might’ve said. he was blunt, right? yes. he was either blunt or he lied all the time. but he didn’t know what to say when people asked. he lied to the people he cared about, and sometimes he would be too honest with strangers, like it was easier to tell them and know you might never see them again.
but this is something else. clara is looking at him expectantly, the apartment quiet minus all the little noises that constantly inhabit everything. a window rattling under wind, the low hum of electronics that you don’t notice until it’s gone, the clicking whine of the radiator. all that silence and nothing to do with the noise.
❝ i don’t know why it’s so hard for me to talk about something like this, ❞ he says after another moment of pensive and strange silence. clara is looking at him with so much gentleness, and somehow that aches too. it’s like he doesn’t deserve it. it’s like he’s getting some reward for something that he doesn’t earn. sometimes it was easier to talk about things clinically in groups when he was in the facility. no one had quite the same problems, but there were similar themes running through it all. similar experiences. a shared sense of trauma, which isn’t the same thing as true and genuine connection. but it can feel fucking close. ❝ i just… i’m not sam. i can’t give you the same answers as him. maybe you mean different things to us, and i… ❞
is he feeling like himself? no. he’s feeling like a ghost in his body. yes, he’s been here for longer, but all it took was one year to displace everything about his life. it is so delicate, in the end. his life, he means. everything about it can fall apart if he doesn’t hold it together as carefully as possible.
❝ i don’t want to disappoint you, ❞ he says. ❝ because – fuck, clara, you mean a lot to me. i don’t want to give an answer that’s not good enough. but i’m not good at this. at talking to people, at saying what i think of them. ❞ his fingers, twisting in his lap, pulling at each other for a few long moments. ❝ … you stayed. i didn’t expect you to. i actually thought you might leave, when i woke up in the hospital. it would’ve made sense. you mainly knew him. not me. we’ve never met before, but i look like him and i’m sure i sound like him. maybe exactly like him, sometimes, and i thought that would scare you off. or hurt you in some way. ❞
his hands stop, still clenched into fists in his lap. it’s about keeping himself as secure as possible, about sensation that keeps him here in this moment more than anything else.
❝ … you’re one of the only people i have left. and i can’t imagine doing this with you or darlene. everything afterwards… if you weren’t around, i don’t know what i would’ve done. how i would’ve kept everything in order. it might’ve been easier to just go away again. no matter who took over instead. i get why sam thought of you the way he did, you know. because most people would’ve just disappeared or given up. even darlene’s done that to me before. so either you’re just that stubborn or you…. really care about me that much. and i don’t know how to handle that, really. ❞
he doesn’t know how to handle a lot of things. but he’s just going to try his best.
he reaches for clara’s hand finally, trying to communicate what he can’t say.
it’s weird sometimes. really weird, actually, quite weird and off and wrong--no, not wrong, just... really unfamiliar. she’ll look over at him, this bloke she’s known for ages, since before she died, since after, and she can’t recognize him whatsoever. it’s not bad, really, but it is weird. like the doctor, when his face changed, but without that change. she’s not sure how to handle it always.
she loved sam. loves him, even, although she doesn’t think she can admit that part to herself yet. he was the only tether she had left here, especially after christel died and especially after she died -- codependency, maybe, but a necessary kind. she never would’ve met elliot, this one, if it wasn’t. still, it hurts sometimes, and that hurt has nowhere to go. it’s amusing in a sick way, a lich with a broken heart, she’s sure there’s some sort of joke that could be made there.
don’t get her wrong, she loves elliot too, she really does, but... it’s hard. not the loving, the lovin’s like breathing--it’s the adjusting. knowing that this body knows her better than she knows herself but that the mind inhabiting it doesn’t anymore. except maybe it does, just a bit.
she watches him as he goes on, talks about her choice to stay and sam’s to go and how they’re both healin from this together. it’s sweet, in a way, how he sees her. none of the broken mirrors or stitches in the bathtub, just a decent person who’s stickin’ around for him. it makes her smile, even with the ache in her too-still chest. his hand slides into hers. she squeezes back.
‘i think it’s a bit of both, really. i do care about you and i’ve been told that i am quite stubborn, so both works here,’ a joke of sorts. she smiles, is glad he’s so comfortable around her. she doesn’t know what to do without sam, she doesn’t. can he see how lost she is? she hopes she’s hiding it well enough. ‘sorry for a question like that out of the blue--prolly weren’t expectin it, were you?’
i love you. i love you, i do, but i don’t know you like i knew him. i think there are overlaps, but i’m not sure and i’m losin’ control and i hate that. why did he have to leave? why couldn’t we keep you both? i’m so normal now and i know it can’t last--you’re going to see me how i am one of these days and i won’t be able to stop that. how long until you tell me to stop coming back? how long until you realize you don’t hate yourself enough to keep holding on?