CHAPTER THREE—Coffee at Ten
I changed my outfit four times.
Maya stood in the doorway of my bedroom with her arms crossed, watching me hold up two nearly identical pairs of jeans like they were life-changing decisions.
“They’re literally the same.”
I sighed dramatically before throwing one pair onto my bed.
“I don’t know why I’m nervous.”
“Because it’s your first date in…what? A year?”
“You spent forty-five minutes getting ready.”
“I do that all the time.”
“You wear oversized sweatshirts to the grocery store.”
“…Okay, maybe not all the time.”
“I’ve known him for less than twenty-four hours.”
“No,” she said. “It’s exciting.”
I looked at myself one last time in the mirror.
A gray and black striped baby tee.
Light wash low-rise jeans.
“Good enough,” I mumbled, grabbing my purse.
As I headed for the front door, Maya called after me.
“Text me when you get there!”
“And if he’s secretly weird—”
The coffee shop was one of my favorite places in town.
It sat on a quiet corner a few blocks from the park, tucked between a bookstore and a flower shop. The front windows were lined with plants, and the smell of fresh espresso hit you the second you walked inside.
I got there five minutes early.
Because I hated being late.
…Okay, maybe I was a little eager.
I found an empty table near the window and checked my phone.
Right on cue, the bell above the café door chimed.
Chris stepped inside wearing a gray hoodie, black cargos, and a backwards Red Sox cap. His eyes scanned the room until they landed on me.
The smile that spread across his face was immediate.
And, embarrassingly enough…
“There you are,” he said as he walked over.
He pulled out the chair across from me.
“I was actually worried I’d be late.”
“I hit every red light imaginable.”
“Lucky for you, I got here early.”
I pretended to think about it.
“I appreciate your generosity.”
We ordered our drinks together.
He got an iced vanilla latte.
I ordered my usual caramel latte.
“You come here a lot?” he asked as we waited.
“Probably more than I should.”
“I like supporting small businesses.”
He looked at me for a second.
“You just really like coffee.”
Conversation came surprisingly easy.
Easier than it had any right to.
We talked about everything.
The music we had on repeat.
The embarrassing jobs we’d worked before.
“I worked at a grocery store when I was sixteen,” Chris admitted.
“I accidentally knocked over an entire display of canned soup.”
“I would’ve paid to see that.”
“My manager didn’t think it was funny.”
He smiled, shaking his head.
“I’ve been serving tables since I was nineteen.”
“I go home, take off my shoes, and tell myself people aren’t always rude because of me.”
“But then someone leaves a really nice tip or tells my manager I did a good job, and it makes up for it.”
“You always find the good part.”
No one had ever noticed that about me before.
“You’re kind of observant.”
We ended up staying in the café for almost two hours.
Neither of us seemed to realize how much time had passed until my phone buzzed.
“I have work in three hours.”
Chris glanced at his own phone.
“We’ve been here since ten?”
Neither of us stood right away.
Neither of us seemed ready for the conversation to end.
“I had a really good time.”
The question came so naturally, like he already knew the answer.
He stood, walking with me toward the door.
Outside, the summer air was warm, and the streets buzzed with people enjoying the afternoon.
We stopped on the sidewalk.
For a second, neither of us moved.
Neither of us seemed sure how to end the date.
Chris scratched the back of his neck.
“I’m not really sure if this is…like…”
It lasted maybe two seconds.
Three, if I was being generous.
But when I pulled away, he was smiling.
“I’ll be disappointed if you don’t.”
“I guess I don’t have much of a choice then.”
As he walked backward toward his car, he pointed at me.
I watched him leave before getting into my own car.
The second I shut the driver’s door, my phone buzzed.
Chris: That hug was definitely too short.
I laughed so hard I had to lean my head against the steering wheel.
Without thinking, I replied.
Me: Then you’ll just have to earn a longer one next time.
Three dots appeared instantly.
I had a feeling there was definitely going to be a next time.