This contains minor spoilers for the Court of the Dead book. I’m attempting to push back on some bad faith critiques about Solangelo and Will Solace.
In the Court of the Dead, Will Solace is a better boyfriend than 95% of seventeen-year-old boys in the existence. He clearly loves Nico, yet the fandom will overreact and jump to leaping conclusions.
The issue revolves around Will’s “bisexual chaos,” referring to his capacity to be attracted to other females, while Nico is prone to jealousy. That combination can seem tricky, but it’s not what some fans make it out to be.
Some fans interpret Will’s “bisexual chaos” as him constantly flirting with or being attracted to other female characters. In reality, we only see him openly attracted to anyone besides Nico twice: once toward a supernaturally beautiful goddess and once toward a supernaturally beautiful monster. These moments are brief and contained within their scenes. Rather than pretending not to notice such obviously striking individuals, Will comments candidly to Nico.
Will is never shown flirting with other demigods or mortals, so his “bisexual chaos” likely comes from honest conversations with Nico about his bisexuality. He wants to be open about his attractions rather than pretend they don’t exist. If Will were habitually flirtatious with others, we would see it; he only comments on beauty that’s impossible to ignore.
The main criticism seems to be: “Nico is jealous, so Will shouldn’t comment on others’ attractiveness.” That’s fair, but Will isn’t trying to hurt Nico—he speaks honestly without overthinking. He wants a relationship where both partners can be open, knowing honesty doesn’t undermine commitment. Plenty of healthy relationships involve acknowledging attraction to others—it’s normal and doesn’t make the relationship unhealthy.
If anything, these moments show that Will and Nico need better communication about Nico’s jealousy. That’s a flaw, yes, but a very human one. It doesn’t erase the many ways Will shows up for Nico or make him a bad partner. You can’t expect perfection in every moment, and Will shouldn’t be torn down for being a loving—if imperfect—teenager.
Yes, I agree that there are better ways to remind readers of Will’s bisexuality than showing him attracted to a supernaturally beautiful female character once per book.