This Gay Stuff's Coming Out of My Ears
It's National Coming Out Day for at least a couple more hours. I’m out to pretty much everyone already as a big ol’ gay transman, so I figured I’d use the chance to write about something a little different, and Patrick Swayze.
But first, Barthes: in class the other day, someone brought up the idea of the “reality effect,” Roland Barthes’ notion of all the little details of a narrative that give it the feeling of realism. The dishes left in the sink don’t propel the story forward, but they make the scene more real, more relatable, and they helps us see ourselves inside the story’s world. Or, to put it another way, Patrick Swayze’s rippling triceps and chiseled abs certainly don’t advance the plot of Dirty Dancing, but they made 13 year-old me see myself inside Patrick Swayze. Wait, what?
This all got away from me way too quickly. I meant to say that this is a post about the pieces of media/stories that ended up being a lens for me to catch glimpses of my queer self growing up, before I knew such a self existed. Have you ever had one of those moments? You’re going along, watching a movie, a TV show, listening to a song, and then all of a sudden it just hits you: omg i could be gay; omg i could be trans; omg i could be gay again. I dunno, maybe for you it was a moment more meaningful than a piece of pop culture that got you to wake up and smell your own faggotry. But I’d bet it’s more common than people think. After all, we live in an age of Netflix binges, and if that creates more of these special moments of self-recognition, then that’s probably not a bad thing.
Now that I’ve given you a reason to watch all seven seasons of Buffy in a row, I can give a rundown of the three epiphanic pieces of media that helped me come out to my own self: Dirty Dancing, Brokeback Mountain, and, embarrassingly, Merlin (the BBC family drama).
Nobody Puts Jane Brucker In The Corner
Moody Mount Holyoke student on the left, little ray of sunshine on the right.
I know I said above that it was Swayze’s raw masculinity that made the movie transformative for me, but strictly speaking that’s not exactly true. Yes, I obsessively watched the film over and over when I was 13, drooling over him in adoration and emulation, but it wasn’t until I bought the soundtrack and listened to this song for the umpteenth time that it hit me: this whole gay thing might be applicable here.
"Yes," by Merry Clayton is, of course, the song that plays when Lisa, Baby’s older sister, is walking down the block of staff cabins, all spruced up and looking forward to losing her virginity. I’m not sure how much of that scene stayed with me as I listened to the song on my stereo, but I loved Lisa’s tropical prints and extreme camp. And even though she was Baby’s superficial foil, she exuded a sexual confidence from a feminine perspective that was exciting to me back then.
And sometimes it’s just really hard to tell if your “gay” epiphany means you’re a 13 year-old lesbian, or a 13 year-old faggy transman.
Only Time and Gay Cowboys Can Tell
Immediately after graduating from a very liberal East coast women’s college, I packed up everything I owned and drove to Driggs, Idaho, where an internship with a newspaper awaited me. I was incredibly lonely and out of my element among the Mormons, ski bums and grizzly bears. I rented a lot of DVDs from the public library in Alta, Wyoming, just a bike ride away across state lines under the shadow of the Tetons. Eventually I got Brokeback Mountain, and even though I’d already watched it a few times, it soon became the impetus for my second Big Gay Epiphany.
This time things got much more specific. Now I realized that I could be a man who loved other men if I wanted to. In college I’d identified as a lesbian, hoping it would make some sense, but I rarely dated and continued to feel uncomfortable in my own skin. In Idaho over the summer I’d started binding without understanding why. So when I watched Brokeback Mountain with all this weighing on my mind, it was suddenly like looking in a mirror. That was the kind of relationship I wanted—minus the fisticuffs and sheep herding.
Up until this point, I think I’d considered what it might feel like to be a man, but it’s important to note that I didn’t really crave it until I realized I could be a gay man. It’s in this way that gender identity and sexuality are actually intrinsically linked for me, and I guess that’s a coming out of sorts. The queer community makes a big deal of how separate these two things are, and I agree that it’s important that they be understood as separate. But in practice, for me anyways, I’ve identified as a gay man from the moment I started using male pronouns. It’s a crucial part of how I understand my own masculinity, and for better or worse, Brokeback Mountain helped me realize that.
And Now For Something Really Embarrassing
I love Merlin. And not the old bearded Merlin of T.H. White or Mallory; not even Mary Stewart’s badass version of Merlin in The Crystal Cave (though those books are amazing). No, for me the only Merlin is this Merlin:
I know. I know. The BBC’s Merlin has played a larger part in my coming out as a transman than I care to admit, but what can you do? The plain truth of the matter is that I named myself after the actor who plays Merlin. (OK, more specifically, I chose the name Callum after a role played by the actor seen here, Colin Morgan, in a film called “Island,” but it’s pretty close.)
It’s just that you cannot find a more feminine male character starring in his own television drama. Seriously, that’s a challenge to anyone out there. Mainlining this show on Netflix I became totally obsessed. With the stack of epiphanies I was working with, I could now not only be a gay transman, I could be as feminine as I wanted and still be a man. Merlin never uses force or violence, relying instead on his magic, wit and intelligence to get out of trouble. Plus, the overt homoeroticism of this “family” show is just … wow.
All in a day’s work for the needlessly naked Knights of Camelot.
I don’t necessarily always like the fact that so many of my really defining moments of self recognition came about because of movies and television. I prefer to think it’s in the stories and the characters that I found some sort of reflection of the person I wanted to be. And maybe that sort of visceral reaction can’t be had in books. When reading you can only picture in your head what you’ve pictured before, and it’s rare that they won’t already resemble you in some way, even more difficult to imagine a person you’ve never even conceived of before.
I’d venture that there’s even something different in the way we watch these shows today. For two out of these three “moments” above, I have a vivid image of watching the show/movie on my laptop under the covers, curled up in my own bed. It’s a much more intimate way to experience a story than in the theater or just in a room with other people. It feels like the characters are just for you, and the message is just for you, and that can lead to some interesting personal discoveries. At least, that’s what I think.