Every Rose Has Its Thorn...
As much as I hate to admit it, I can’t deny that I am sort of a part of “Bachelor Nation.” I have been watching the Bachelor franchise with my hometown friends for years and at this point, I can't stop even if I wanted to. (You could say that I’m in too deep.) The upcoming season of The Bachelorette is being hailed as a very big deal because ABC has a black bachelorette for the first time ever. The network is promoting this move as “historic” and I won’t dispute that fact because it took 33 seasons to make this a reality. Prior to Rachel Lindsay, a black contestant was lucky if he or she made it as far as the Top 10. (I’m not even joking, they used to never make the cut for the first rose ceremony.) I remember thinking that the options wouldn’t get better than “complicated” contestant Jubilee Sharpe on Ben Higgins’ sappy season, but then everyone’s favorite villain Nick Viall had a record high of eight women of color (which included the show’s first-ever bisexual) cast for his sham of a season.
Following the releases of Get Out and Dear White People, this season of The Bachelorette has me on edge as a black woman. The entire time that Rachel Rachel was competing for Nick’s heart—which I’m still confused by to this day—all ABC would have them talk about was race. Was Nick comfortable with dating a black woman? Had he ever even dated a black woman? My favorite moment was when Rachel brought Nick home to meet her family and he went to her all-black church and said that he had been to church before but “not like this” as in completely surrounded by black people. We get that being a interracial couple is full of obstacles like racism and that Nick wouldn’t have to deal with that if he chose any of the other (white) women, but we didn’t need to be reminded of it every single time they were on camera together. Plus, Nick pretty much claimed to be colorblind whenever he would state that he cared about who Rachel was as a “person” more than anything else. That said, I’m concerned that this is going to be the outline for Rachel’s entire season of The Bachelorette.
When I found out that Rachel was selected as ABC’s next bachelorette, I was genuinely excited. I couldn’t think of a person from the past four seasons more fitting for the role, especially after we were forced to watch Nick take his fourth shot at the reality show. The timing of the big announcement was way earlier than usual though—ABC didn’t wait for The Bachelor: Tell All, let alone the season finale. I didn’t read too into it at the time, but my mom pointed out something that I didn’t even consider: the network probably revealed it sooner to gauge viewer response.
I think I speak on behalf of most of Bachelor Nation when I say that none of us believed that Nick needed to be on another season. Following that lack of approval, ABC needed to make sure that their next choice was a real winner. Rachel was a risk for the most obvious reason, but Bachelor Nation loved her anyway—they just had to make sure that everyone else would too. Once that was out of the way, ABC would set everything else in motion almost a little too fast.
During the live reunion, Rachel was completely blindsided when OG host Chris Harrison decided to surprise her with five of the contestants that would be competing for her heart on the show. One of them—a white man named Dean—had the audacity to say, “I'm ready to go black and I'm never going to go back." Never in my 24 years of life have I cringed so hard; I’m pretty sure that I screamed at the television and my friend immediately refilled my glass of red wine. If I had been Rachel, I would have sent this fool home right then and there. (Boy, bye!)
It worries me that these are the types of things that Rachel is going to have to deal with for an entire season and she doesn’t deserve that. Yes, she is a beautiful, black southern belle, but she is so much more than her physical appearance—Rachel is a civil defense litigation attorney and she has a hell of a lot more to bring to the table than most of the past contestants that have held the title in this godforsaken franchise. (The only other accomplished individual prior to her was Andi Dorfman, a former assistant district attorney and the first-ever Jewish bachelorette.) She is an accomplished and successful woman and I’ll be damned if she isn’t given the most suitable candidates for her season. My greatest fear is that Rachel will be embarrassed on national television for the sake of ABC boosting ratings and keeping Bachelor Nation entertained on a weekly basis. I’m scared that Rachel is going to be forced into triggering situations for the purpose of cooking up drama on the program, and I’m worried that the viewers won’t empathize with her if the race stuff get too heavy.
Depending on how things go down, I am also concerned about the backlash Rachel could receive if she doesn’t wind up giving her final rose to a man that isn’t white. For the first time ever, a surplus of people of color are going to be tuning in to watch The Bachelorette. I find myself returning to Dear White People often and how it presented the exaggerated pettiness within POC communities when Samantha White’s black friends could not accept the fact that she was dating a “woke” white man. Imagine what type of responses could be generated from Black Twitter if Rachel makes this same choice. There is going to be more pressure on her than any bachelorette or bachelor that has come before her. We’re all rooting for Lindsay for our own reasons, but will she be able to live up to the high standards that ABC has set for (or against) her?
All of Rachel’s contestants have been revealed ahead of the premiere so we can get a glimpse at who we’ll be watching for the next 10-12 weeks, and she seems to have some diverse options as far as ethnicity is concerned but that might not be enough. Don’t get me wrong, I am happy to see progress being made on the program but I need for ABC to do it with dignity. Hopefully, Rachel isn’t used as a prop to fill a diversity quota and will guide the network in the right direction. I don’t want her season to serve as a test course for ABC.
Despite all of the anxiety that is building up inside of me, I’ll be tuning in every Monday night to support Rachel with a glass of wine in one hand and my fingers crossed on the other.
















