Apple iOS 7 Upgrade on iPhone 4S and iPad Mini
Well, hello there, iPhone peeps! I've been using iOS 7 on two devices for the last two days and thought I'd drop in to give my impressions. I'm mostly pleased, and a little disappointed, but I'll get into the details shortly.
This review is organized as follows: I start with the upgrade process, then discuss some of the changes, followed by my thoughts and feelings about various aspects of the new iOS, and sum it all up with a detailed rundown of all changes (or lack thereof) to the apps and settings.Â
Read on, kind visitor!
The Upgrading
The process was not without issue. I was forced to repeatedly initiate the install process until it finally started. I performed the installations directly on the devices instead of through iTunes, sparing me having to consume more space on my hard drive. The upgrade process also took a long time. Though I did not time it, I would estimate that it took about 45 minutes on both devices.Â
Once installed and restarted, iOS 7 has you perform a couple of configuration tasks like any other upgrade, though you are oddly asked if you want to activate Location Services again. Once done, you are taken to the Springboard and get your first look at the new design. In a nutshell, it's impressive. Everything is crisp, clean, and neatly symmetrical. There is no wasted space like in Windows Phone 8, but there is enough separation space so that it doesn't feel claustrophobic.Â
From The Lock Screen Onward
The Lock Screen has been completely redesigned, and is FINALLY useful. Swipe down from the top of the screen and you get the Notification Center. Swipe up from the bottom of the screen and you get the Control Center. You can still open the Camera app from the bottom right corner, but it take a little too much sliding to get it open. The single most useful change, however, is that you can now unlock the phone swiping left to right from anywhere on the screen. It's a lot faster and you don't have to home in on the unlock slider.Â
Once in the Springboard, everything looks familiar and yet is all new. All icons are now flat and clean with no fake, shiny 3D effects. Of course, the flat look has only been applied to apps that have been updated with new icons. It stands to reason that 3rd party apps wouldn't get around to updating their icons and look, but I was surprised to find that not all Apple apps get the iOS 7 treatment. Notably, Pages, Numbers, and iBooks look exactly the same, even inside the apps. It's clear that it will take time for developers to utilize the new user interface assets.Â
A nice surprise is that folders have been updated. Folders now have multiple pages allowing you to better organize your apps. The search feature has also been revamped. You no longer swipe left of the first Home screen, you swipe down on the icons in any Home screen, making it faster to access. Finally, the Task Manager, always hideous since it was first introduced, has been replaced with the card-style manager Apple acquired when it bought Palm OS patents earlier this year. Simply double tap the home button to open the Task Manager and swipe cards up to quit apps.
Some Words of Kindness and Criticism
There is no way to sum up what I feel in a sentence or two. It's more involved than that. There are a number of things I really like about the update. I like the new flat look and how it's universal. I'm quite fond of the new edge-to-edge arrangement where it looks like someone considered that it would be useful to actually use space for things. The old UI style just had too much white space and the controls were artificially three dimensional.Â
I'm also taken by the additional features and functionality. It's like Apple has really started listening to it's customers while paying attention to what Google and Microsoft are doing. The Control Center is brilliant, but the Today View in the Notification Center is a little bare. The additional camera features are very nice, but the UI feels over designed.Â
In fact, that's what I think the problem is with iOS 7, if there is one. It feels over designed, by a graphic designer. A designer like Jony Ive. I'll be honest. I've never like Jony Ive. He's too much of a SOHO designer hippie who sees himself as a visionary, and I bet he's an insufferable ass in a passive aggressive manner.Â
While I think that he's been amazing as the lead for industrial design, I was really thrown for a loop when he described the new iPhone 5C in one of his silly, pandering videos.
“We believe the iPhone is an experience. And experience is defined by hardware and software working harmoniously together. We continue to refine that experience by blurring the boundaries between the two.”
How does that even happen? Software and hardware can't work together. The hardware itself is only the visual medium of the product and a few controls to make the software so some things. If I press the Volume Up button, it increases the volume. How is this harmonious? He said that the iPhone 5C is:Â
“beautifully, unapologetically plastic.”
What? It's PLASTIC!! It may be very well built and solid, but it's still plastic. If Apple had decided to make all iPhones out of plastic I doubt anyone would have cared. In fact, had Ive not been bent on making the iPhone 4 into a pocket version of the unibody MacBook Pro, there likely would never have been AntennaGate.Â
Part of me wants to think that Apple and Jony Ive have been trying too hard to justify the higher cost of being an Apple consumer by making their products needlessly over-engineered. On the other hand, in my decades-long relationship with Apple, I know that they do make a superior product that has made some stumbles along the way.Â
For me, I would buy the iPhone 5C if it came in black and had the biometrics of the 5S, but Apple has decided to move the 5S up in the range, so I'll have to buy the 5S instead. Not that I'm disappointed, much. iOS 7, in my opinion, is a significant advancement over iOS 6 and has a lot of great tweaks and new features.Â
My only concern for Apple is that we are now starting to see what Apple will be like without Steve Jobs at the helm. At first I thought that Tim Cook and Jony Ive could be a sort of Jobs proxy in the form of two people, but now I think I was wrong. iOS 7 with Jony Ive at the design helm is the Jony Ive show and I don't see any of the legendary Tim Cook conservativeness here.Â
I do not doubt that iOS 7 and the new iPhones will be a success, but I do believe that if Apple is going to survive, Tim Cook is going to need to rein in Jony Ive. If he doesn't, then Apple is going to become more of an art gallery than a computer company and when was the last time you performed a useful task with a collection of art pieces?Â
The New Apps
Apple has updated all of its core apps. Of note, all of the apps now use the new user interface design and have the same general operation and layout as the previous versions. There are some minor behavioral changes in the apps, though, so here's a rundown of each:
Phone - The only thing new is more prominent inclusion of FaceTime.Â
Mail - Mostly the same, but some minor adjustments have been made. First, to get Delete/Archive you now need to swipe right to left only, but you will get more actions you can perform on the message in the More menu. Second, and I cannot for the life of me recall if this was in iOS 6, but you can now modify which objects will be shown on the Mail homescreen. I, for one, hid the individual mailboxes because I always use the All Mailboxes, and enabled All Drafts, All Sent, Attachments, and All Unread folders.Â
App Store - No significant changes, but the Purchased list loads a LOT faster now.Â
Camera - The iPhone 4S doesn't get all the new features, but this app is revamped. The HDR toggle is now at the top of the screen, and you can now choose between video, photo, square, and pano by swiping left or right across the shutter button. There are also new live filters, though they aren't particularly interesting.Â
Safari - Apple completely revamped Safari, but mostly the internals. There is a new tab arrangement that allows you to close tabs by swiping the page to the left (not right), an odd choice considering the new Task Manager.Â
Calendar - Apple got rid of the display mode picker and replaced it with a hierarchical behavior that is not immediately obvious. You start in Day mode and can back out to Month and Year modes.
Reminders - Now has a tabbed style interface.Â
Compass - A leveling bubble mode has been added.Â
Maps - No change, though I hope that it actually works now.Â
Game Center - This app got a complete revamp and has now integrated notifications for supported games that have turns waiting.Â
Passbook - Seems to now have fewer features! I have a number of Passbook apps installed, but only Starbucks appears in the app itself. Weird.Â
Weather - Nice dynamic background images have been added.Â
Photos - Apple completely revamped this app, now with much better automatic organization and a hierarchical navigation arrangement very similar to the new Calendar app.Â
Calculator - No change.Â
Newsstand - Blessed are the Lords of UX for now this app can be stuck in a folder so you never have to look at it again.
Apps With No Changes - Contacts, Notes, Voice Memos, iTunes Store, Clock, Calculator, Messages, and FaceTime.
Now, if I missed an app I'd be surprised, but let me know anyway. Now, other than all that, all existing apps still behave the way the did. Some apps have already been updated, as you may have seen in the last week or so.Â
The New Innards
I will not go into detail here since much of what already was now is again. In other words, Apple has only added features. In this section I will detail all of the changes affecting the base iOS 7 system. Here we go:
Airplane Mode - No change.
Wi-Fi -Â No change.
Bluetooth -Â No change.
Cellular - You can now select which apps can use mobile data, though it seems to be limited to a few apps. My guess is that support must be added if apps want to appear in this list, and it bothers me that a developer could choose not to let you choose.Â
Notification Center - Mostly unchanged, but Apple has added more functionality in the form of a Today View function. You can choose which data sets appear here.Â
Control Center - You don't get to choose what appears in the CC other than the existing options, but you can choose where you can access it from.Â
Do Not Disturb -Â No change.
The General settings are large, so I'll cover those in a separate list:
About - There is something called a Trust Store at the bottom, but it offers no options.Â
Software Update -Â No change.
Siri - There is now an option to select the default female voice or a new male voice.Â
Spotlight Search -Â No change.
Text Size - This is all new and controls the Dynamic Type service that works throughout the entire system. 3rd party apps will need to add support for this feature, though.Â
Accessibility - Mostly unchanged, but Apple has added controls for modifying the appearance and behavior of the new OS. The Larger Type option offers a greater range to select from on the Text Size slider, but the Bold Text option will require a restart.Â
Usage -Â No change.
Background App Refresh - This all new settings feature allows you to select if an app will refresh itself in the background. I suggest that you turn off those apps that you want to refresh when you open then. Weather is a good candidate.Â
Auto-Lock -Â No change.
Passcode Lock -Â No change.
Restrictions -Â No change.
Date & Time -Â No change.
Keyboard -Â No change, but if you want the Emoji you'll need to add it here.Â
International -Â No change.
iTunes Wi-Fi Sync -Â No change.
VPN -Â No change.
Reset -Â No change.
Now we continue with the rest of the settings options:Â
Sounds - There are no changes to the functionality, but Apple has added a slew of new Alerts and Ringtones. All of the old sounds are still available, but are relegated to a Classic sub-menu.Â
Wallpaper & Brightness - Again, no real functionality changes, except to Wallpaper selection. You now have a choice between the in-built Dynamic and Stills wallpaper, but can still select from your Photos app. The Dynamic wallpapers are nice, but they are very simple and all variations on floating bubbles.Â
Privacy -Â No change.
iCloud -Â No change.
Mail, Contacts, Calendars -Â No change, with one tiny exception. You can now select a flag style for Mail. You can pick the classic Flag or a dot.Â
Notes -Â No change.
Reminders -Â No change.
Phone -Â No change.
Messages -Â No change.
FaceTime - The Use Cellular Data option has been removed since it is now always available.Â
Maps - Label Size has been removed since that is now handled by dynamic text and a preferred directions option has been added letting you pick between Driving and Walking.Â
Compass - This is a new item and it only offers the option to enable using True North. Never quite understood this.Â
Safari - No real changes, but the options have been arranged in a more logical manner.
Now for the additional apps section:
iTunes & App Store - Some changes here. You can now control which categories of purchases are automatically downloaded. The one I like the most is app updates. You can also now choose to not show iTunes Match and other media you have not downloaded in the Music and Video libraries.Â
Music - No real changes, though there is now a redundant option to Show All Music.Â
Videos - Same as Music, there is now a Show All Videos option here, and the Closed Captioning control has been removed since it is now available directly in the video playback controls.Â
Photos & Camera - There have been some minor changes here. You can choose to disable the image summary option, though I'm not sure why anyone would. It's one of the best new features in Photos. You can also turn the grid on or off.Â
iBooks - This is all new and gives you centralized control over how books are rendered on your device.Â
Game Center - This is also all new and has some options for managing the new social features in the new Game Center.Â
Newsstand - This item was removed.Â
And finally, the social apps integration section:Â
Twitter -Â No change.
Facebook -Â No change.
Flickr - This one is all new and, like the other social apps, offers to download it if you haven't already and integrates the login to your account. Adding your account also gives you access to sharing and saving features integrated into the system.Â
Vimeo - This is also all new and is the same as Flickr.Â














