Maybe there was Blossom twincest...
So I know that Blossom twincest has probably been a theory in the back of all of our minds since the very first episode. But is it real?
(Hold on cus this is a long one.)
*WARNING: SPOILERS AHEAD*
So, after watching episode 3x04: The Midnight Club, a theory came together for me. In that episode, Penelope reveals that she was adopted when she was 8 and groomed to be Clifford's sister then his bride. But that raised a question for me: as we learned in season 2, Clifford and Cladius grew up together until they were 14, when Cladius ran away after Clifford pointed a rifle at him. So if the Blossoms were choosing child brides when Cladius was still around, where and who was Cladius's future wife?
Well, I don't think he had one. I think that Clifford was being groomed to inherit the family business and, therefore, the family only cared if Clifford's line kept the red hair. They didn't care if the children of their other son, Cladius, had red hair or not because Cladius wasn't carrying on the full Blossom legacy (the business).
But how does that relate to twincest? As in Jason and Cheryl twincest? Well, Nana Rose Blossom and her husband ensured that the heir to their business had a red-headed bride when he was 8. So why didn't Penelope and Clifford do that for their heir, Jason, when he was 8?
Because it's Cheryl! Maybe Cheryl was adopted, maybe not, but there are subtle hints throughout the show that Cheryl was being groomed to be Jason's bride.
In episode 1x10, Jughead's birthday, when the group is playing Secrets and Sins, Veronica accuses Cheryl of twincest. And everyone at the party thinks she's crazy, but if you watch Cheryl's face after Veronica suggests that, her reaction makes me think that maybe Veronica wasn't too far off.
The other subtle hint is in episode 1x12 when the Coopers storm Thornhill in the middle of the night to rescue Polly, revealing to everyone that Polly and Jason were 3rd cousins. The Blossoms have no issue with this however and Penelope even says that "nothing could be more purely Blossom" than Polly's babies. Admittedly, Clifford does also say "it's not like they were brother and sister", which leads people to think that, like a normal person, he is against sibling incest. But we'll just chalk that up to Clifford trying to seem normal instead of mentally twisted. Of course, when Penelope said that nothing could be more purely Blossom, she could've meant literally as in DNA. But I think that Penelope meant it as in the Blossom spirit... Of incest.
If you think it's a crazy theory, just reflect on episode 3x04. A red-headed bride for Clifford, the heir to the Blossom fortune, was found and guaranteed for him when he was 8. So why would Penelope and Clifford not do the same thing for their heir Jason?
"Well," says the skepticist, "maybe they abolished that tradition." Except that's unlikely. In season 1 when Polly asks Cheryl why her father has so many red-headed wigs, Cheryl says that "the Blossoms live and die by their hair", so I don't think the Blossoms would give up red hair like that.
This also explains why, when Clifford and Penelope present Cheryl as the new heir to the Blossom business, they have Archie, a redhead, by her side. Because apparently the red-headed legacy is just as important as the maple syrup/drug business legacy. "But," argues the skepticist, "Penelope said that she invited Archie because he gave her the Jersey at the funeral." And to the skepticist I say: Have we ever known Clifford and Penelope to do something nice for someone (even returning a favor) without getting something out of it? No.
And, therefore, Cheryl was meant to be Jason's bride. And the Blossoms support twincest.