A Response To Shane’s Letter, and more specifically all others who read it.
Summary: I don’t know how much I believe/what I believe after reading Shane’s letter. I think there are inconsistencies and we need to hear from more people. I think RT is doing there best to stay true but it’s not black and white and we need to give other people a chance to give their sides of the story. Don’t freak out on RT when we’ve only heard one side of this.
*If anyone wants to respond to what I say, read the rest of this, my summary doesn’t give justice to my overall thoughts. If you read the entirety of this feel free to respond to this post directly or message me about it anon or not.
I just finished reading the entirety of Shane’s letter twice. I don’t know how to feel about this.
Maybe I’m overprotective, maybe I’m ridiculous.
But I want to hear from the specific people he mentioned. Sheena, JJ, Kara, etc. I want to hear the side of people who do not have full fledged ties to RT currently (besides Kara’s voice acting). I want to hear another side of the story.
I’m sorry, but I can’t help but feel like there was something off about the entire letter. And I’ll say it again, I read it twice, outloud to myself. I’ve been sitting for almost three hours to do this because as a writer, a fan, and a person who looked up to Monty and still cries over him, I knew I needed to really think about this and not jump to conclusions at any point.
I give a shit about RWBY, because it’s one of my biggest inspirations, because it’s gotten my through a lot over the past years. Waiting for each new trailer and episode and preview has given me something to want to stay alive for.
It’s hard for me to have read that, to read a man’s words and thoughts and beliefs and feeling put out there for everyone to see, and for me not to immediately believe it entirely.
I’m a very empathetic and sympathetic person, my initial reaction to anything with a lot of emotional backing is to full out believe and support it.
There’s no way for me to accurately explain how much I hate myself for not being able to believe it all.
I’m not saying Shane made it all up, that none of it happened, that everything he said was fake or exaggerated. I’m saying that something isn’t sitting right with me after reading that.
This company, these people, they loved Monty, valued him. I don’t think they would ever want to do anything but fulfill what Monty’s dream was. If there’s anything that I don’t feel like I can believe, it’s when Shane seems to imply that Monty was not well-liked, that people thought his processes were ridiculous. That they would ignore what Monty wanted.
At the RWBY panel for RTX 2015, they did a moment of silence, those tears shed by Miles, Kerry, and Gray were real and obvious. They loved Monty.
There’s a lot of things that make me feel uncomfortable and unsure. One of which was how Shane seemed to imply that he was Monty’s only confidant in RWBY production besides Sheena. When the Red trailer came out, and Miles and Kerry were announced as writers they explained that Monty had given them “homework” when he approached them about working on the show, to watch anime. Throughout the years they’ve described days and nights and weeks of staying up writing the series with Monty, who was of course at the head of everything. Monty had never once said that these claims of working closely together were false, and if anything he confirmed them. Shane simply cannot be the only person who knew any of what Monty really wanted, I can’t believe that.
Also, many of the RT staff (Michael, Burnie, Gus, Miles, Gray, just to name a few) over the years have mentioned Monty’s work process, have commended it, have said that he works best in his environment. They’ve never once expressed distaste over how he works. There seems to be another inconsistency there.
It pains me to say that I don’t know how much I believe Shane. I think he’s possibly exaggerating things, or has a different view. Delusional isn’t the word I’m looking for, please don’t get me wrong because from what I read I do believe that he was close to Monty, that maybe because of Monty being gone the people in charge of story and RWBY in general have a different opinion and general way of doing things that every single idea that Monty had unfortunately hasn’t made it’s way into the show.
He admitted that the different plot points in Volume 3 (Yang v Mercury, Pyrrha’s death, Adam and Blake and Yang, etc) that they were all in the show obviously, but maybe they weren’t exactly what Monty had originally conceptualized. I think that Shane may be dealing with a lot and expects that somehow the show would look and be what Monty wanted it to be.
But it will never be that way, because the only way for that to happen would be if Monty’s hands were the ones doing it, and it kills me to say that it obviously can’t be that way.
In the end, I want three things moving forward, other sides of the story, and I want everyone to take a step back.
I’ve already seen a ton of “I don’t know what to believe anymore” and “Fuck RT and their business bullshit” and “M&K (Miles and Kerry) are ruining Monty’s vision” posts and the letter has been out for less than a day. We need to give this time.
Miles and Kerry are only two people in the entirety of RT and though they are the writers they don’t make every decision about the story and don’t deserve to be told they’re ruining what they’re mentor and friend started. Stop blaming them and only them about anything having to do with RWBY
Don’t throw away your belief in RT yet, don’t give up on them. Give RT a chance, give the other people (Sheena especially) a chance to respond.
Take a step back and wait until we have some more pieces of the story, I think that we owe it to everyone, and I mean everyone, involved to give them a chance.