Hey! I am not a hindu scholar but I have some doubts regarding shivling. I know it's obviously not any vulgar thing but can you please eloborate why it is called "ling". It is often used to bash hindus and troll them for worshipping a "male organ" and call them andhbhakts who worship a stone .
If you haven't seen the latest trolls on mahashivratri, take a look.
I know this already, I had been researching about this since mahashivratri and I found a legit answer. Many articles have manipulated a simple logic behind it to throw a shade at hindus who follow shaivism.
It is NOT EMBEDDED IN YONI, neither it is any male organ.
‘Shivling’ is a Sanskrit word which means ‘symbol/ representation of Shiva’ as the word ‘ling’ translates to ‘symbol/ representation’ only. Whereas ‘yoni’ translates to womb/vagina/species and 'shishin’ translates to penis , not 'linga’.
People think that it shows union of male and female genitals. But in reality , it shows none of them.
Below are the logical proofs-
A) Proof that it is NOT a male organ-
Jyotirlingas are the 12 most sacred and absolutely true Shivalingas because they are not man-made, they are made by Shiva himself. So these Shivalingas are prefect.
The above image is of Kedaarnaath JyotirLINGA . The word ‘linga’ is used , but does it looks like any male organ?
No, because it is NOT a male organ. Carefully observe it , it looks like Mount Kailash ; then also ‘linga’ is used because ‘linga’ just means ‘symbol’ and has no relation with any body part.
This is another naturally formed Shivling named Mahabaleshwar Shivling. Observe again ,it doesn’t looks like any organ , because it is not. This shape of Shivlinga represents the irregular shaped form of Shiva ( Shiva has many forms)
These are the naturally formed Narmada Shivlings. Look at their shape , they are ellipsoid. Male genital doesn’t look like it.
These are the most popular type of Shivlingas.
These kind of Shivlings (Such shaped Shivlings represent infinitely long light pillar shape of Shiva , which Shiva took resolve the arguments between Vishnu and Brahma) can also bee seen in temples and they don not look like any male organ since middle part of Shivling is octagonal and the base is square. Which human organ is octagonal ?
B) Proof that it is NOT embedded in yoni-
The base/ pedestal which uphold the Shivling is mistaken as yoni
Now please scroll up and look at the base of the above mentioned Shivlingas , they all are square shaped . And yoni is not square.
This is Omkareshwar Jyotirlinga , observe the base around it , again it is square shaped.
This is Amarnath Shivling , here there is no base/pedestal, only Shivling.
So this is the proof that Shivling neither show male nor female bodypart.
C) So if Shivling doesn’t shows any bodypart then why it is in such shape?
This form is only of a point light. This form of Shiva is known as ‘Paramaatmaa’( Supreme-Soul) form so ancient saints imagined this form as a small light flame and they made it into stone .
Now check the shape of small light flame
Such shaped Shivlings are most common Even some of the Jyotirlingas are of similar shape.
D) Then why pedestal is important?
Pedestal/ base is used only for three purposes-
To provide water drainage in one direction , hence keeping the nearby area clean.
To provide stability to the ellipsoid shivling
To keep shivling vertical , because light flame is always vertical. Nothing more than this.
Therefore in Amarnath Shivling it is not there because all the three points are fulfilled by nature itself.
Calling Shivling as a symbol of creation by union of male-female is senseless, because these rocks , mountains , oceans etc . cant be made by male-female union. So by being human organs, it can’t symbolise universal creation. And there are organisms which reproduce without mating (male-female union).
Shiv Lingaashtakam is a prayer written specifically for Shivling by Adi Shankaracharya. And if you read it, its last line says-Sanskrit -’’Paraath Param Paramaatmak Lingam, tat-Parnamaami Sadaa Shivlingam ” which says that Shivling is representation of Supreme-Soul (Paramatmak) form of Shiva.
Shiv Puran (Gita press Hindi) : Book page number- 41–44; speaks about infinitely long bright light pillar called symbol (linga) of Shiva. And it does not say anything related to human organ
So this proves that true Shivlings do not represent any human organ.
Answer source and credits 💐 - https://qr.ae/pvYj8I
One thing to note , we call shivlinga a “pinda” so its obviously not any reproductive male organ.