THE DEVIL LIES IN THE DETAILS
I procrastinated writing this post for a few months now.
I put it off because it’s hard on so many levels that it takes my breath and sucks away joy like the swirl in a draining bathtub.
It’s hard to write it because it forces me to recall the vivid description of six police officers breaking down his door with a battering ram, surrounding him by the dining room wall, and open firing their weapons into someone who said they would surrender. He requested to smoke first.
^^^As I wrote the previous paragraph,^^^ my Apple watch alerts me that my resting heart rate went from 65 to 117. And as I edit that one long sentence, I realize I unconsciously used the general pronouns his, him, they, someone, when I really mean Joshuah--in literary speak, its called distancing language; when the writer distances themselves from what they wrote, either to avoid thinking about the subject or the content. For me, it is both. I want to avoid thinking about the subject, and I need to distance Joshuah from the content, because his last morning was without a doubt--terrifying. Knowing Joshuah was terrified before they killed him wrecks me, but it gets worse.
I need to distance Joshuah, but I can't. I can't because I have a responsibility to him, and to you, the reader. And it’s possible this long explanation is also a distancing tactic. So, I am going to take a breath, and plow through it.
The following is taken from the investigative report and justification issued by Dave Gilbert, Calhoun County Prosecuting Attorney.
In reviewing the reports of the officers involved, their statements are consistent with each other as well as physical evidence at the scene. All officers agree Detective Trooper Miller knocked on the door. Mr. Prough answered the door, saw the police officers and immediately shut the door while the officers identified themselves and repeatedly told Mr. Prough they had a warrant for him, and to open the door. Det. Trooper Root carried a ballistic shield for officer safety. Detective Horn and Det. Trooper Gillespie each carried .223 M4 type rifles. While Det. Trooper Theodore went downstairs to get a battering ram to break the door, Det. Horn and others spoke to Mr. Prough in an attempt to get him to give up. At one point, Mr. Prough said he would give up after smoking a cigarette. Hearing him walking around inside and fearing that he may be arming himself with handguns, the apartment door was breached with the battering ram. The decision to breach the door was made out of fear Mr. Prough was a danger to himself, officers and the public due to his mental condition and his assumed possession of fire arms.
At approx. 0845 entry was made with the ram as stated. When finally inside, the entry officers all state Mr. Prough was holding a gun in his right hand in a threatening manner. Trooper Root saw a gun in each hand, with the gun in the right hand pointed at officers. Trooper Theodore saw a gun in his right hand at waist level, pointed at the officers. Sgt Conklin described two guns being found after the shooting, but at the time of the shooting, one gun was in his right hand at shoulder level pointed up in a threatening manner to the officers. Det. Gillespie also saw the gun raised at chest level. All officers inside state Mr. Prough was holding the firearm in a threatening manner which made them fear for their lives and the lives of fellow officers.
As someone who writes memoir, I know memory gets filtered through a perspective lens. Six people can have the same experience and remember it differently. I think the differing memories about the gun(s) and where they were pointed has everything to do with the breakneck speed at which decisions were made.
Detective Sgt. Kevin Conklin’s report is the clearest.
At 0645 the fugitive team began surveillance at the apartment. At 0815 they knocked on the door. Josh answered. “It appeared he was sleeping and was in disarray.” Josh was positively identified.
Det. Conklin formulated a tactical plan and it was executed at 0840, when they again knocked on Joshuah’s door. Josh opened it, realized it was police and “slammed the door shut.” Through the door, Detective Andrew Horn and Conklin told Josh if he came out he wouldn't be hurt. Joshuah said he would come out, he wanted to smoke first.
At 0845 the door was rammed by Detective Trooper Craig JosephTheodore. At 0851 Battle Creek Police were advised of shots fired.
Six minutes from the knock at the door to Joshuah receiving twenty four “penetrating, perforating, and grazing gun shot wounds of the neck (1) chest (6) flank (3) abdomen (1) back (1) and extremities (12).” Fifteen bullets were removed from Joshuah’s corpse by the coroner.
Twenty Four penetrating bullets.
Let’s not forget the rounds that went through another occupied apartment, shattering the patio door.
I try to remain impartial. A mentally ill man with a gun, even if it’s my son, is a potential threat to themselves and society and needs to be contained immediately. I support that 100%.
Anyone pointing a gun at a police officer is going to get shot. I support that 100%.
I don’t think Joshuah was pointing the gun. I think he was holding it--and that’s why reports differ.
I struggle with why they broke the door after Joshuah said he would come out. Andrew Horn knew Joshuah. Who made that decision? Their statements of being in fear for their lives is ridiculous. They hunted him. They were the aggressors. They broke his door.
And I’m the one who called them.
I ask a cop friend. “Did they plan to kill him?”
They replied, “Steph, that’s premeditated murder. Any cop who suggests it immediately be relieved of duty.”
They were six well armed and educated men against one disheveled mentally ill man.
Even the Uni-bomber got his day in court.
The grief and regret of those six minutes now echoes into infinity, because my family is forever shattered. And I know when those six officers sit down to eat with their families, Joshuah explodes all over again at the dinner table.
The Shield is a barrier against prosecution. It is not a barrier for their soul, nor does it monitor their mental health.