Sofia had put her foot forward, only to pull it back again like clockwork. She’d come back to Beau in the hopes of an embrace, or perhaps, in the hopes of anger, but instead she received a smile --- twisted in confusion and in pain. She looked at him then, in the mask that he wore, in the sheepishness of his smile, in the natural curve of his lips. She looked at him, and she saw beyond the happiness he put on. Beau had always been a golden boy, a boy with aspirations far bigger than himself; he searched for happiness in the darkness of times, in the darkness that others handed him. And Sofia knew this. She knew this too well, perhaps. But, to see it now, and to hear it evident in the sadness of his word, made her heart ache with a heaviness she had not allowed herself to feel in a long time.
Anger would have been better. If Beau had screamed at her or called her every bad name in the book, Sofia would have gone home in shame and in embarrassment. But, in the end, she would have deserved it. The names would have been true, and the screams would have been valid --- in the very least, she would have had this. And then, maybe, when she looked back at the meeting with him again, she would have cried --- but for all the right reasons because she’d left the love of her life and he didn’t want her back. She would have seen him angry with her, and that would have been for the best because she deserved it. It would have hurt, but it would have hurt in the proper way.
But Beau would not have been Beau if he gave her any of this.
So, Sofia took the sadness. She embraced it whole. In truth, she wanted to walk up to him and embrace him, as if that would somehow absorb the pain she knew she had caused. But something in the air told her she was not welcome to do that just yet --- or, perhaps, ever ---, so she stayed where she was and fidgeted with her fingers. Her gaze did not leave Beau’s, for this was the only way she would get close enough to seeing all of him --- and, in that moment, she did want to see. Sofia wanted to see what sadness he hid, what anger he kept, what emotion he did not allow to rise. She wanted to see and to say that she saw, to say that she was here, to say that she wasn’t going anywhere.
A person ten years too late could not do any of that, though. Despite everything she was, and everything she would later claim, this was what Sofia was: a person ten years too late.
What could she say, then? How could she reply to the question he posed? She knew the why was an encompassing thing: a question for why she left, instead of simply for why she had come back; a question for why she hurt him, instead of simply for why she was here. A heavy form of silence came between them as she thought of her answer, and in it tears began to dwell in her eyes as she thought of the only things she could say: the truth. “Because--- Because I--- I was young, and I didnt know what I wanted. I was young, so I left. I thought, you know, maybe I might make something out of myself. Maybe life had more in store. You know?” Her words quivered with her bottom lip. “I didn’t know. I didn’t know it was here all along. I didn’t know. I---”
Sofia paused only to look away and wipe the tears in her eyes before they fell. If she was going to be somebody, she would be somebody strong. Ten years did a lot to a person, and she hoped it would have made her stronger than she was before.
“And now I’m--- I’m back because I’ve--- I’ve realized all this. I--- I know I hurt you. I know I didn’t--- didn’t make it easy. I’ve realized that now. I’ve been out there, and there was nothing. All there was was the thought of you. And you”---Sofia fidgeted further with her fingers, just as she always had when she was nervous---”you don’t need to feel the same way. I--- I don’t expect you to, really.” A soft, self-deprecating laughter escaped her lips. “I just… needed you to know. You kept me going. You deserve to know that. You--- I--- I needed you to know.”