The Batfam received a total of 8 submissions for this showdown (although not all submissions listed all 6 of them included in the showdown), and have managed to make it all the way to the finals! What did those people say about why they should be included and why they should win?
“They are one of the most complex families in media today. They're not only a blended, single-parent family, but they also all work together as vigilantes which only makes they're dynamics more complex. For example, the boys not only are brothers but they also have all held the same vigilante role as Robin, which amplifies sibling rivalry, jealousy, etc. And I love them so you should put them in“
“Look, I don’t even care that much about Batman, but I love his kids and their weird sibling rivalry and devotion.”
“They're a really cool representation for family formed by adoption, as they're adopted siblings! They also are all just badass incredibly skilled vigilantes, who regularly hold their own in a world full of people with superpowers, despite being just regular humans with no special/supernatural abilities. Also, as a unit all together? There is SOOOOO much talent like truly any other sibling pair against them would STRUGGLE against a team of 5 badasses with daddy issues. Also even against powered siblings, like I said they're used to fighting people who DO have powers”
“Chosen family trope and they are superheroes. All of them can be your favorite character for different reasons. They kick ass and take names. I love them, your honor.”
“Honestly I’m sure like a million other people have submitted them by now and explained everything, so I’m just adding this nomination to make sure that Cass and Duke get included and it’s not just the Robin squad. Cass and Duke are part of the family/adopted and fostered too!!”
“They are the adopted siblings of Bruce Wayne aka Batman (except for Damian who is Bruce’s bio kid). They kind of hate each other sometimes, but in a way family hates each other. Also they love and care for each other.”
“They are all incredibly talented in a literal showdown/battle. They love each other very much. They fight and have messy complicated relationships like siblings do. They would die for each other, and due to their position as superheroes, that isn't just metaphorical, it's a real weight. They are siblings by adoption/foster status which I'd imagine isn't incredibly common in your results.”
Vote for Dick, Jason, Tim, Damian, Cass, and Duke here!