SANS VOIR (playing dirty pt.4) â§Ë · .
series masterlist | part 3
pairing: spencer reid x reader (no use of y/n)
warnings & tags: MDNI, can be read as a standalone, sub!spencer tries to fight for control (switch!spencer?), jealous!reader, insecure!spencer, palming, overstimulation, edging, usage of sex toys (m & f), m & f masturbation, m anal play, unprotected p in v sex, degradation, praise
summary: Spencer could never escape your whims. and you made sure to prove that time and time again. but today, you try something newâgifting him something special that turns a game of blindfold chess into a battle of wills.
w/c: 8.2k
a/n: after going back and forth with so many bits of this, I finally finished it. #torturing spencer for life
and thanks to my beautiful @hotchnerss for being the judge of this <3
A small box wrapped in two-toned, purple stripes, bound by a black velvet ribbon that tied into a perfect, pretty bow, sat at the bottom of your bag under your desk at the bullpen.Â
Your mind couldnât help but wander and loop back to the little box that seemed to burn a hole in the worn leather by your feet.Â
The secret, invisible connection that tethered you and Spencer together in public was an undeniable desire that excited you in ways you deemed primalâways that made you question your self-control and your fragile, tricky dynamic with him.Â
Youâd told yourself that gifting him a butt plug was nothing but a twisted, entertaining approach to loop the little thread in your hands around him and keep a tight hold of him.Â
It was only about giving you the upper hand.Â
Youâd fantasized about him wearing it for you whenever you pleasedâa physical manifestation of the exact way youâd dug your fingers into every intricate fold of his brain.Â
But now is definitely not the time to dwell on any of that. Now is for working on the local case that hit JJâs desk this morning.Â
In most cases, you and Spencerâs primary job would be constructing the geographical profile. Although you two had a notoriously volatile dynamic, Hotch believed that the two of you gave each other a push, making you the perfect pair to narrow down the search radius as efficiently as possible.
But this time, you were assigned to work with Derek, since Rossi suggested that Spencer would be the best fit to work with the local officers coming in to analyze and compare some of their recent reports that they believed could be directly tied to this caseâs unsub.Â
You watched as Spencer made his way to the opposite side of the bullpen so Hotch could introduce him to the police.Â
One of the cops that came in was a fresh-faced detective who carried herself with a bright, earnest passion for the job.Â
She seemed eager to prove that this is where she belongedâthat she could be a core contributor to solving this case.Â
Standing in the BAU bullpen clearly intimidated her just enough to keep her a little reserved, but whenever Spencer opened his mouth, her eyes would light up with genuine fascination.Â
It was nearly impossible to keep your eyes where they belongedâglued to the big map with only three red pins marking its surface, but you knew you had to force a picture of unbothered composure and focus on your task.Â
Distraction was not an option.Â
After an hour and a half of buried in dry geographic data, you were surprised with how youâd completely forgotten about the two across the bullpenâuntil Spencerâs soft, stupidly sweet laugh travelled right into your ears, instantly dragging your attention right back to him.Â
They were on a small break, because apparently being useful for ninety consecutive minutes was simply too much to ask for when a serial killer targeting innocent children was on the loose.Â
You narrowed your eyes, watching as the detective slowly sipped her coffee, looking at Spencer with the same fascination sheâd walked in with.
âBlindfold chess is actually much less about visualization than people assume. Most experienced players donât even visualize the pieces,â Spencer explained, his large hands cutting through the air between them to illustrate a grid, âthey rely on geometric relations between the squares. So itâs all about structural spatial navigation and organizing information efficiently.â
âOh, wow. And can you turn your head into live gps for a chessboard, Dr. Reid?â she asked playfully, looking up at Spencer through her lashes.Â
âYes, actually,â Spencerâs lips curved into the small smile he always wore whenever he got to brag, âI have an eidetic memory, so itâs quite easy for me to keep track of all the moves and pieces.â
âOoh, superhuman memory?â the officer let out a soft, amused giggle.Â
You watched the interaction, standing next to Morgan who had a small, red pin between his fingers as he examined the map and the work you two had done, hoping he wouldnât notice you dissecting the interaction on the opposite side of the room.Â
âOhâuh, not superhuman, scientifically speaking,â he stammered slightly, the small smile twitching as he adjusted his tie, âItâs just an atypical neurological trait. And almost anyone is capable of incredible data retention if the pathways are mapped out correctly. I just happen to have a genetic predisposition for it.â
Spencerâs explanation came off as modesty. And any stranger that noticed the tight-lipped smile he gave her, along with the quick flicker of his eyes wouldâve been certain that Spencer was humble.Â
âThatâs still very impressive, Doc.â
But you knew Spencerâknew that he is a show off. And the nerves that crept their way into reality in the form of crimson blush faintly working its way up his neck were a natural reaction of a man wholly unaccustomed to getting attention from an attractive woman.Â
What did she see in Spencer? How could she possibly be charmed by him?
To you, his smug attitude was transparent, even when he had his nicest act on.Â
Maybe deep down, you were terrified because her flirting was normal, healthy, and easy to understandâa smart, pretty cop giggling at his rants and feeding his ego with interest.Â
It was the kind of soft, simple attention Spencer was clearly flattered by.Â
You were bitter.Â
Because what you had with Spencer was nothing like this.Â
Watching him smile at her sweet praise made a spike of insecurity pierce right through you.Â
What if your undying desire to wrap him in invisible threads was a pathetic attempt at keeping something you couldnât actually control?
But you could never sit with those thoughts, so you forced them aside instead, convincing yourself she was naively falling for the polished act that hid how truly irritating he could be.Â
You patted Derekâs shoulder, âIâll be right back,â you said before turning around without giving him a chance to reply.Â
You walked to your desk, reached under it, and transferred the purple box from the half-zipped bag to the inside pocket of your jacket.Â
You made your way to where the two stood, keeping your eyes fixed entirely on Spencer.Â
The closer you got, the more you could see the tiny twitch of his fingers against the end of his tieâa telltale sign that he was already feeling the weight of your gaze and presence.Â
âReid,â you interrupted, your voice cool and perfectly professional, maybe even more composed than usual, âWe need to pull the 2004 archive file from the unsolved Richmond case. Some of the unsubâs dump sites line up with that report.âÂ
Spencer blinked, his mouth closing shut as his eyes locked onto yours.Â
The shift in his posture was immediate; the flustered boyishness vanished, replaced by quiet tension.Â
âOhâuh, s-sure.â he stammered.
You offered the officer a brief, polite, but utterly empty smile, âExcuse us.âÂ
Without waiting for Spencer, you turned on your heel and began walking to the quiet, isolated hallway, but Spencer was already trailing behind you like a leashed puppy.Â
He quickly fell into step next to you, his long legs adjusting their shift to match your stride.
As the quiet of the corridor took over, you spoke, âDo you enjoy looking like a desperate, starved dog?âÂ
âW-what?â he stuttered, the corners of his top lip tugging in confusion.Â
âOh, come on,â you took a step closer, the sheer heat radiating from his body at your proximity was intoxicating, and it only made you back him into the cold wall.Â
âDid it make you feel like a big man, Spencer? Having a pretty girl giggle at your big words?âÂ
Spencer looked down at you, the straight strands of his hair falling over his forehead as he let out a soft huff.Â
âI didnât know I wasnât allowed to make small talk with a nice officer,â his voice dropped to a whisper, âare you jealous? Is this what itâs about?â his eyes scanned yours to see if heâd hit a nerve.Â
Spencer couldnât help but smirk at how your jaw clenched beneath the harsh light.Â
His smirk wasnât as impenetrable as he thoughtâyou could see the hopeful curiosity in his eyes.Â
He was practically begging for a yes, in any form it came in.Â
You bit back a smile at how obvious everything about Spencer was. Every thought he had was immediately written all over his face, ready for you to read without much effort.Â
âYou wish,â You murmured, âI just think itâs pathetic how easily you fold for a bit of sweet-talking.âÂ
Spencerâs smirk faltered, his chest rising and falling a little faster as your body crowded him, planting your foot between his own.Â
âIt wasnât sweet-talk.â he softly said before slightly leaning his face down to yours, âYou hate that someone was nice to me. Oh my god, youâre crazy.âÂ
âYou havenât seen crazy yet, Dr. Reid,â you whispered, slowly pulling out the pretty, striped box, âBut since youâre feeling so brave today, letâs see how well you can keep up that smart mouth of yours for the rest of the day.â you pressed the bottom of the box against his chest, right over his racing heart.
His fingers brushed against your hand and the velvet bow on the side facing you, âWhat is this?â he tilted the box to look at it.Â
âGo open it in the bathroom and youâll know what to do.âÂ
Tense silence stretched between the two of you, before Spencer let out a dry, breathy laugh through his nose, âYouâre not serious.âÂ
You simply held his gaze.
âWe have a file to look for.â he whispered, trying to sound reasonableâresponsible, but his heavy breath betrayed him.Â
âThen you better hurry up,â you shrugged, taking a slow step back, leaving him cold.Â
Spencer let out a quiet, defeated breath as he rolled his eyes and made his way to the bathroom.Â
----
When Spencer stepped out into the hallway, he didnât look very different, his hair was slightly neater; the soft locks pushed away from his forehead, and his ears were shaded with a soft pink flush that deepened when his eyes fell on yours.Â
The change in his posture was obvious, but maybe that was due to the fact that you were actively looking for the micro-changes in his body.Â
His shoulders were tense, his strides were shorter, and his thighs were held slightly closer together while walking, as though he were trying to minimize the friction of every step.Â
He stopped a few feet away from you, his eyes stubbornly trying to avoid yours.Â
âThat didnât take long,â you murmured, tilting your head to study him, âYou okay?âÂ
His jaw clenched, a faint pulse visible in his templeâhe almost looked mad. âIâm fine. Letâs.. letâs just go find that file.âÂ
âOh, I actually just found it,â you gave him a wide, fake grinâthe file you were talking about had been with Emily long before you decided to approach Spencer in the first place, âI just ran into Emily and gave it to her.âÂ
You didnât make an effort to sound believable, but the foreign sensation currently occupying all of his focus made him unable to untangle your motives.Â
âWe should probably head back,â you casually pointed over your shoulder toward the glass door leading back to the bullpen.Â
Every part of Spencerâs body was telling him that he wasnât going to make it across the room, but he knew that he had no choice but to follow you.Â
As the two of you walked back to the chaos, he stared at the back of your head, wishing that he had the power to reach over and bite it off your neck.Â
He told himself that the lack of fight in him today was merely a result of stress over the case, and now the metal plug inside of him. But Spencer canât really fool himselfâhe knew that the weakness had nothing to do with the case or the plug and everything to do with his fragile dignity when it came to you.Â
In no situation would he torment you back for your cruelty, and he hated himself for that.Â
But he knew heâd have to at some point.Â
----
Unfortunately, the team was chasing dead ends in circles for three hours until another victim was found in a new dump site.Â
The unsub was moving at a faster pace now, and there was no time for the entire team to leave and examine the scene, so it was decided that youâd split into two groups.Â
You were left at the bureau along with Reid and Rossi.Â
While sitting across from Spencer on the round conference table, you âaccidentallyâ flicked your pen off the edge.Â
It rolled right to Spencerâs feet and you didnât make a move to get it as you simply looked at him, raising a brow.Â
The sharp pause made Rossiâs eyes flick from you to Spencer, then back to the collection of disturbing crime scene photos splayed out in an order the entire team had memorized from staring at the gruesome details all day long.Â
Spencer stared at the pen on the floor, a hint of pure panic crossing his eyes. He knew that bending down was going to change the angle of the heavy metal, shifting it directly against his most sensitive spots.Â
He slightly slid off his chair, trying to hide the stiffness of his moves. He bent his knees a little, keeping his torso painfully straight to minimize the strain.Â
âYouâre moving like a ninety year old, kidâ Rossi shook his head with a soft sigh, âEverything alright?â
A soft whimper threatened to slip past his teeth, but he bit his inner cheek so harsh it tasted like copper.Â
âIâm fine, itâs just aâa cramp.â his hand awkwardly pointed to his back then a random direction.Â
âYou should probably do some stretches.â
âYeah, you should do some stretches, Spencer.â you nodded in evil agreement with Rossi.Â
He grabbed the pen, slowly rising before sliding the pen back to you with a hard-to-miss tremble in his hands, âIâm fine.âÂ
âThanks, Reid,â you smoothly said, pretending that your attention was undivided and completely on what the three of you had been talking about.Â
Rossi eventually stood up to check in with Hotch over the phone, leaving an unbearable silence hanging in the harshly lit room.Â
----
An hour later, the rest of the team filed back into the bullpen, carrying fresh reports and faces that made it clear the latest crime scene hadnât offered many answers.Â
You threw yourself into cross-referencing the new victimâs timeline, only taking a few minutes off to grab yourself another cup of coffee.Â
Youâd completely missed that Spencer followed you to the break room under the guise of refilling his coffee cup.Â
The loud clatter of his ceramic mug hitting the counter startled you, making you nearly jump as he stepped far too close next to you.Â
âI canât do this anymore. Iâve been standing for forty five minutes straight, and Morgan keeps asking why Iâm sweating so excessively.âÂ
You didnât even look at Spencer as you gracefully grabbed a sugar packet and neatly tore and emptied it into your steaming coffee. âYouâre fine.âÂ
His eyes widened as he stared at your infuriatingly indifferent face with a mixture of irritation and pure desperation, âIâm so fucking sore,â he whisper-yelled as his fingers harshly gripped your wrist, stopping you from stirring your coffee, âand my legs are cramping so bad.âÂ
âI think youâre handling it beautifully, Spencer.â you finally looked up at him.Â
He softly shook his head, his fingers tightening around your wrist, âIâm not,â he whispered, âIâm really, really not. IâI canât even focus.â
You yanked your hand out of his firm, tight grip with a sharp pull.Â
âJust suck it up, Reid.â you glared at him, âYouâre a grown man, you can handle some cramping. Have some dignity, stop whining, and get back to work.âÂ
He swallowed whatever protest he had left, watching you turn your back to him and walk away.Â
The rest of the evening passed in a blur.Â
Every few minutes, you would feel Spencerâs eyes drifting back to you like a magnet, and when youâd meet his gaze, you could see the exhausted swirl of resentment and forced compliance.Â
You hadnât expected Spencer to be this obedient. Youâd underestimated the extent of his need to please you.Â
Spencer still couldnât understand why his brain was leaving him entirely subordinate to your whims.Â
He was caught in a trap of his own makingâone you proudly took full credit for.
To your luck, this case wasnât one of the tragic ones that were left unsolved, even though youâd started to lose all hope by the twelfth hour of working on it.Â
Nothing was better than leaving the office without the guilt of leaving a depraved monster to walk free.
âHeyâuh, can you.. give me a ride home, Iâd use my car, but Iâm kindaââ
âYeah, of course,â you interrupted, nodding quickly before walking to your car without looking at Spencer.Â
You didnât need to know his excuse. You just knew that you absolutely wanted him isolated with you in the comfort of your carânot that you intended to do anything to him, of course.Â
Spencer was extremely quiet, and you were just waiting for him to speak.Â
The silence stretched between you two even after you started driving.
Until he finally couldnât bite the words back.
âYouâre hitting every single bump on purpose,â he muttered, his knuckles creasing into sharp, pale peaks as he dug his fingertips into the strap of his satchel, almost as if he was trying to sink his nails through the leather.Â
âIâm driving normally,â you said without taking your eyes off the road, âthe road is uneven.âÂ
âItâs not uneven, youâre justââ the car bounced slightly over a lane marker, cutting Spencerâs words off with a sharp hitch, âyou want to make it worse.â he accused.
âWhat, you want me to just drop you off here?â you turned to look at him.
âEyes on the road,â he pointed at the windshield, surprisingly, making your eyes follow his finger, returning to where they belonged while driving, âand no, just stop making it harder than it already is. Seriously.â
âIâm not trying to do anything!â the words bubbled past your lips along with a giggle, making you seem almost angelic. âBut if youâre gonna complain the whole driveââÂ
âIâm not complaining,â he insisted, his face flushed in the dim light of the streetlights, âIâm simply stating facts. I am incredibly sore and every single movement isââÂ
You didnât let him finish the thought, âJust relax, Spence,â you murmured, your voice dropping to a gentle purr as you reached across the console.
You flattened your palm on the smooth fabric covering his taut thigh, âWill a bit of blindfold chess help you relax?âÂ
Spencerâs eyes darted between the smirk on your face and your hand that was slowly making its way higher on his thigh, âWâwhat?âÂ
You let out a soft, mocking laugh, âOh, come on. What was it you were bragging about today? That you can easily play an entire chess game in your head? I think that would do a great job at keeping your mind off the pain, donât you think?â your firm fingers tightened on his stiff muscles.Â
Spencerâs face flushed a deep scarlet, his body making no effort in stopping your wandering hand, âIâI was just explaining the framework of spatial memoryââ he choked on his own spit,âShe asked a question, and I was being informativeââÂ
âYou were showing off, Spencer,â you teased, the friction of your palm against the rough metal of his zipper making his hips involuntarily buck up, shifting the butt plug inside him.Â
âYou looked so proud of yourself. Letâs see it. Letâs see how good you actually are.â Â
Your fingers slid over his zipper before the heel of your hand pressed against the base of his erection. The shock of your touch, combined with the ache that spread inside him, made Spencerâs fingers claw at his tense thighs.Â
His head fell back against the headrest as he weakly shook his head, âI canâtâI canât think when youâre doing that,â he gasped, the buttons of his shirt straining as his ribs expanded to let him take in as much air as possible to stay conscious.Â
âI barely even touched you, Reid.âÂ
He whimpered in response, the raw sound so needy and helplessâso accepting of how pathetic it was that he was, in fact, on the verge of exploding.Â
âThis is really fucking embarrassing.â your fingers slightly traced the outline of his bulge before giving his length a light squeeze and pressing harder against the base of his shaft.
âI donât wanna go home.â he blurted out.Â
âWhat?âÂ
âDonâtâdonât take me back to my apartment,â Spencer stammered, keeping his eyes squeezed tightly shut as if he couldnât bear to look at you while admitting his shameful desperation.
Your free handâs fingers tapped the steering wheel in thought before shaking your head, âYouâre not coming to my place if youâre not gonna play with me.â
âYouâre being childish.â he choked out, his long fingers reaching for the console toward your knee, desperate to be closer to you without exactly touching your skinâterrified that any direct contact might risk you withdrawing your hand and ending the moment before he could earn his way to your bed or couch.Â
âIâll play,â he rasped, âIâllâIâll play the game. Whatever you want. Just take me with you.â Â
You pulled your hand back, the loss of contact pulling a desperate whimper from Spencerâs pretty lips paired with a soft furrow of his brows.Â
Heâd given into the game so youâd grant him the mercy of more friction right now and let him feel good to make up for the agonizing pain youâd put him through all day, but Spencer should know not to expect such kindness from you by now.Â
âOkay, letâs play,â he took a deep breath, faking his eagerness to play as if that would convince you to bring your hand back to his lap.Â
âHmm, I wanna play when we get home,â you lightly drummed your fingers on the leather-wrapped steering wheel, knowing that Spencerâs imagination can take the sight of your fingers and turn it into something completely filthy during desperate times like this.Â
And the broken noise that scraped the back of his throat proved you right.Â
âYouâre sadistic.â he whispered, his knuckles turning white as he gripped the edge of his seat, fighting the urge to beg.Â
âIâm giving you what you asked for,â you murmured, keeping your eyes fixed on the road ahead as your apartment building came into view, âyou wanted to come to my place, so you keep your mouth shut, and you play by my rules.âÂ
Spencer shut his eyes, a bitter, breathless laugh escaping his lips as he weakly nodded to calm himself down, âOkay..â he whispered, trembling from head to toe, âokay.âÂ
You glanced sideways at him, taking in the flushed skin of his neck and the way his face was already glistening with a sheer layer of sweat.Â
A small smile tugged at the corners of your lips at the sight, making you almost want to reach out, wipe the moisture from his temple, and tell him to breathe and that it was going to be okayâalmost.Â
But you stuck to the closest thing to comfort, âIâm not going to leave you like this,â you said softly, âas long as you earn it and give me a good game tonight.âÂ
You didnât push him any further when he didnât respond. You simply steered the car into the dark parking lot, pulling into a space near the building.Â
âCome on,â you instructed softly, unbuckling your seatbelt and opening your door before quickly stepping out into the evening air. Â
A shaky exhale answered you from the passenger side, followed by the fumble of his seatbelt as he forced himself to move.Â
âYes, okay.. Iâm coming,â he croaked out, his breath hitching as he stumbled slightly on his way out of the car.
You rounded the front of the car, offering a small, mocking shake of your head at his clumsy hustle, âBlack or white?â you murmured, leaning against the hood for a second until he made his way to you.Â
âCanât you wait for two seconds till weâre relaxed and sitting to play?â he gestured vaguely with a wave of his shaky hand before dropping it to his side.Â
âYou think weâre gonna be sitting and doing nothing?â
âWell, thatâs how the game is supposed to be. We sit and play like normal human beingsâwhat else do you wanna do?âÂ
âThereâs nothing normal about what weâre doing,â you chuckled softly, turning to face him as you swung the door open before walking into the building.
âI know itâs not normal, thatâs not my point,â he huffed, trailing behind you with his hands holding onto the worn strap of his satchel like a lifeline, âI just meantâ..look, Iâm taking white. What-fucking-ever.â
A low, amused giggle escaped your lips as your hand reached out, lacing your fingers through his trembling ones and tugging him gently across the threshold of your apartment after unlocking the door.Â
âShow me what youâve got,â you teased, shutting the door behind him before pressing up against his chest, tangling your hands in his hair, and pulling him down into an urgent, messy kiss.Â
Spencer melted into it instantly, his mouth moving against yours in a clumsy, breathless attempt to keep up before he let out a muffled groan into your mouth.Â
His hands awkwardly hovered in hesitation before his fingers dug into your waist to pull you flush against him, making him hit the wood behind him and grunt at the blunt flare of the aching sensation inside him.
His hands couldnât last too long on one spot, almost as if he was overwhelmed by the touch alone until he found your face. He desperately held onto your face, parting his lips wider and pushing against you so your tongue would slip deeper into his wet mouth.Â
You pulled back just enough to catch your breath and say a few words, âItâs your turn, Spence,â you murmured against his mouth, your hand finding the strap of his satchel, sliding it off his shoulder and onto the ground by his feet.Â
His forehead rested against yours, his thumbs stroking your cheekbones as he tried to catch his breath, âOkay..â he nodded, shutting his eyes tighter, trying to collect whatever was left of his brainpower,âUmâE4,â he stuttered before diving back down to catch your bottom lip between his own, sucking on it with needy hunger that made your entire body heat up.Â
You let out a soft gasp as he tugged on your lips, your fingers tightening in his hair, âE5,â you breathed out.Â
His mouth slid down to your chin, his lips dragging warmly over your skin, âKnight to F3,â he muttered.
You bit your bottom lip, stifling a quiet grunt as he pressed closer against you, âKnight to C6,â you whispered against his jaw, pressing a soft kiss right below his ear.Â
Your feet stumbled backward, your heels catching on the carpet as you pulled him further into your apartment. Spencer groaned at your clumsinessâthe sudden, uneven sway making his stiff hips move far too much for his liking, sending a sharp pulse of heat through his frame as he swallowed down a whine, âOh my god, youâre killing meââ his fingers dug into your hips, the nails almost tearing through your fitted slacks and plump flesh, ââstop moving like that!â he rasped, his surprisingly strong hands managing to bring you to a halt by locking around your waist and pinning your hips against his own.Â
âItâs your turn,âÂ
And now you were kissing him like a starved woman, reaching up to pull him back into the kiss, hungrily chasing his mouth every time he tried to breathe.Â
âBishop to C4,â he said quickly so his lips could meet yours again.Â
He took slow, measured steps forward, his hands steadying you as he guided you both comfortably into your room.Â
âHmm,âÂ
âDonât stall,â he warned against your mouth.Â
âIâm not stalling!â you protested, tilting your head back, silently urging him to shift his attention to your neck and leave you to soak in the tingling burn of your lips, âKnight to F6.âÂ
He dragged his tongue down your jaw, trailing wet kisses along your neck before sucking on your pulse point to make your knees go weak.Â
Spencer knew all your sensitive spots by heart, and he now had the instinct to seek them out without you saying a word.Â
He wanted to show you what he can doâto prove that after months of hooking up, youâd remade him from the inside out and he was finally performing to your standards.
In Spencerâs head, your cruelty had seeped down to his marrow, making his one and only goal to earn your approval.Â
But in reality, there werenât standards for him to crawl his way up to anyways.Â
He was already perfectâdevoted, and completely under your spell, exactly the way you liked him.Â
You felt the edge of your plush mattress hitting the backs of your knees, and you didnât fight Spencerâs weight off, or flip your positions.
The two of you were growing weaker by the second, and dropping onto the bed would give your weary bodies one less thing to keep up with.Â
Spencer grunted, clenching his thighs tightly, the plug pressing against his now hypersensitive walls as he fell between your legs, âPawn to H4,âÂ
You slightly furrowed your brows, stupidly expecting him to follow the classic techniques as if it were a script crafted for you to win and eat him alive, âPawn to H5,âÂ
Your pawns faced one another, much like your bodies.Â
âKing to E2,â he whimpered into your mouth.Â
How bizarre.
Your fingers tugged on the soft locks at the nape of his neck, pulling his head back, giving your mouth a better angle to devour his. âKnight to E4, you dumb fuck,âÂ
âUmâ Queen to E1,â he hesitated before taking in a deep breath and nodding, âyeah.. E1,âÂ
âPawn to D5,âÂ
You propped your legs up on either side of his body, gasping as he rolled his hips up, driving his covered erection against your core.Â
âBishop to D3,âÂ
âBishop to G4,â you whispered against his lips, a small smirk creeping its way onto your face, âCheck.â
He let out a low groan, his forehead dropping against the crook of your neck as he bucked his hips up hard against your heat, âKing toâ fuckâ king to D1,âÂ
A small whimper left your lips as you arched your back, âSpencer..âÂ
Instead of getting you back on track, he hummed against your neck, his voice vibrating throughout your body, partially forgetting all about the game just at the pretty sound that left you.Â
âPawn to F5,â you swallowed hard, trying to ignore the rhythm he was setting right where you were the hungriest. Â
âPawn to Câ c3,â Spencer breathed out, his hands abandoning your waist to blindly fumble at the buckle of his belt.Â
The metal clinked uselessly between his shaking fingers as his other hand worked to unzip his work pants.Â
Youâd usually tease Spencer and slow him down when he got too impatient, but the sound sent a sudden, hot pulse straight to the pit of your stomach, your inner walls clenching around nothingâaching and too needy to protest.Â
âQueen to F6,â you whispered. Â
âPawn to D4â I mean, B4,âÂ
âYou canât take that back,âÂ
âWhat do you mean I canât take it back, I just said it by accident!âÂ
âWell, itâs an illegal moveââÂ
ââbecause I canât fucking keep up when Iâm all..â he vaguely gestured to where your hips met.
âSo you quit?âÂ
âNo, I can do this, Iâm just very distracted. I canât help it.âÂ
âThen get off of me.âÂ
âWhat?â
âIf you canât play and make me feel good, youâre useless.âÂ
âPlease, I promise Iâllââ he begged, his face going up to cup your flushed cheeks.Â
ââAnd you donât wanna quit the game, so get off.âÂ
Spencer paused, his thumbs brushing your soft cheekbones as he gave you those puppy-dog eyes he was certain would make you melt and bend your own rules, but you didnât budge. Â
âBishop to D6,â you simply said, shooting your brows up as a warning for him to move like he was told.Â
He let out a disappointed sigh and slowly pulled himself up and off of you,âKing to C2,âÂ
You immediately missed the warmth of his body on top of yours, the cool air rushing to replace his oddly comforting heaviness.Â
Surely, you didnât like Spencer like that, and the emptiness that washed over you for âruining the momentâ had nothing to do with himâit was the absence of a heart beating against yours; ribs that were just as shaky as yours, if not shakier, that made you feel steady and stable in comparison; hot breath that fanned over your face to remind you of just how close someone could be.Â
âCastle,â you quietly said, sitting up, avoiding his gaze as you reached to your bedside table drawer, pulling out your sleek, vibrant purple vibrator.Â
Spencerâs jaw dropped, his throat bobbing as his eyes went wide and glassy, a humiliating sting blurring his vision.Â
Only moments ago he was breathing your air, feeling your body, thinking that you wanted him just as much as he wanted you. But you hit him with reality.Â
Was it never about him?Â
Thatâs all he could think about as he watched a piece of machinery do the job he wanted to do, leaving him completely replaced and sidelined.Â
He also couldnât brush off how close the vibrator was to your reach in that drawerâhow you grabbed it as if it were second nature.Â
He knew pleasuring yourself wasnât wrong at all, but seeing how quickly you stripped down to nothing and turned it on so urgently made him sick to his stomach.Â
Were you ever disappointed by your hookups?Â
Had his frantic, desperate attempts to satisfy you been so underwhelming that you never told him, choosing to retreat to your trusty vibrator because he simply wasnât enough? Â
You dragged the toy along your soaking folds, amplifying the vibration as you pressed it harder against your pulsing hole without pushing it in just yet.Â
You rested your head against the headboard, spreading your legs to give Spencer a clear view of your pussy and inviting thighs that he didnât have the right to touch.Â
âPawn to B5,â he barely managed to whisper.Â
You relaxed your eyelids, moaning with a calm sigh before making your move that was long overdue, âKnight to D7,âÂ
Your free hand slid up your torso, the feather-light touch teasing him more than it did you, finally reaching one of your breasts, gently cupping it.Â
Spencer was losing track. Howâd you expect him to keep up with that stupid game when you so cruelly showed him no sign of mercy or pity?
âPawn to A4..â he sounded completely lost and gutted.Â
âYou can strip and touch yourself,â you let out a soft, breathy hum, âI donât wanna be too mean.âÂ
âYou already are,â he whispered, his voice barely audible as his shiny orbs burnt holes straight into your calm-looking closed eyelids.Â
He stood up, his trembling legs barely holding him up.Â
At this point, he didnât even want to be touched. He wished you would reassure him and remind him that he was enough.Â
This is why he hated you in the first place.Â
He moved agonizingly slowly, unbuttoning his shirt as he admired how beautiful you looked when you were this undone, kneading your plump breasts, fingers pinching your hypersensitive, hard nipples.Â
You let him take his time in shedding his clothes and placing them on the edge of the bed neatly.Â
You swirled the tip of the toy against your entrance before pushing it back in and bucking your hips to add more pressure against your inner walls.Â
âOh my god..â your whimpers were so angelic it almost made him come right on the spot, âPawn to G5,â you moaned, making the coordinates sound like the sexiest dirty talk ever.Â
âPawn to A5,â he shifted his gaze to his rock-hard dick, choosing to focus on his own pleasure for once, because you clearly preferred it when he wasnât the one working your body.Â
âHow are you already so hard?â you bit your lower lip, smirking and shamelessly staring at his throbbing, veiny cock, pulling the toy out just to shove back in with more force, the sight of his weeping erection driving you mad.Â
âIâI donât know,â he whined as he wrapped his slender fingers around his length, immediately giving himself the tight grip he believed he finally deserved.Â
He did knowâthey both did, but he didnât have enough blood left in his brain to put any proper words together.Â
He stroked himself faster, his asshole clenching and unclenching around the buttplug inside of him, making him shake like a leaf at the foot of the bed.Â
You let out a loud, helpless moan at the low, quiet grunts that escaped his pretty, swollen lips, your hips rolling against the vibrating silicone.Â
You donât know how you two did it, but somehow, the game went on.Â
There were probably many mistakes that slipped your mind with how overwhelmed you were.Â
It was becoming too muchâeven for you.Â
âFuck.. umâ Pawn? Yeah, pawn to F3,â you stuttered, your focus utterly wrecked.Â
There was no point in playing anymore.Â
âQueen to C7,â his lips twitched into a proud smile.Â
âOh, fuck you,âÂ
âI win,â his eyes finally fell onto yours,Â
âI know.â
He reached out to you with his free hand, his entire body leaning toward you as his fingers wrapped around your wrist, âDonât you always say losers donât get rewards. You lost, so you donât get to come.âÂ
âFuck off, Spencer,â you huffed, rolling your hips onto the toy to chase the orgasm you were so close to, but his grip held your hand infuriatingly still.Â
âPlease, Spencer..â you purred, looking up at him through your lashes, determined to make him feel at least a little bad for you, âpretty please?âÂ
âNo, what applies to me, applies to you,âÂ
âSpencer⊠but Iâm being so nice.. this is unfair.â
âYouâre being nice?â he scoffed, shaking his head as he turned off the vibrator, prying your fingers off of it.Â
âMhm,â you hummed, nodding and pouting your lower lip, giving him your most innocent, needy stare.Â
âWhat about me? I won, and I get nothing?âÂ
âDid I tell you not to come?âÂ
âNo, but I should have an advantage. I deserve to come before you. And Iâm not sure if you should come at all.âÂ
âWell you have a plug wedged up your ass and you can stroke your dick, you're already getting plenty of stimulation. Donât you think thatâs an advantage?â you murmured, tilting your head to the side.Â
âIâ itâs notââ
You donât wait for his protest, sitting right up, reaching behind him to gently tap the exposed base of the plug, pumping it into him.Â
A sharp, high-pitched gasp tore from his lips, his whole spine arching as the movement sent a shudder straight to his prostate.Â
âSee?â you whispered so nicely, âAdvantage.âÂ
His jaw stayed slack, his eyes dropping to your lips as you leaned in closer to him.Â
Your hand cradled his jaw, tickling his sensitive skin, and feeling him lean into your warm palm.Â
âHow about you come inside of me? Hm? We havenât done that in a while.â your fingers moved to brush his raw, red bottom lip that heâd clearly been chewing on, softly soothing it, âdoes that sound fair, Spence?âÂ
Spencer was completely gone. He hummed and nodded into your touch, slowly getting closer to your face, âYeah.. yeah that sounds fair,â he cooed, his lips brushing yours.Â
This way, youâll get your release too. And if youâre being completely frank, you missed feeling him fill you upânothing could ever compare. Â
âGood boy,â you whispered, slowly connecting your mouth with his, licking his slightly parted lips before slipping your tongue between them.Â
Guided by pure instinct, Spencer shifted his weight, gently pushing you back to lay against the pillows, his body hovering over yours as he lined himself up with your slick entrance.Â
You both kept your eyes fixated on his dick as he dragged it up and down your folds, spreading your slickness up to your swollen clit, his precum mixing with your juices.Â
The friction against the bundle of nerves made your hips involuntarily twitch off the mattress, seeking more of him. You wrapped your legs around his waist, tugging him down.
âDonât tease, Spence,â you whispered against his neck.Â
âOh, please. Thatâs the least I could do,â his hot breath soothed your frayed nerves before he pressed a soft kiss against your temple.
âDonât you wanna get off?â you asked, pecking the delicate skin of his neck.Â
âI hate you, you know that?â he muttered, his hips betraying him with a needy twitch.Â
âI know.. I knowâ you breathlessly giggled against his shoulder, peppering kisses to lure him into giving in already.Â
The sweet assault on his neck finally broke him. He let out a ragged exhale, giving up on his restraint as he tilted his pelvis and slowly pushed himself inside you, stretching you around him in one long stroke.Â
âThere we go,â you turned your head to face him, pressing his damp forehead against yours.Â
He began to roll his hips in a slow, torturous rhythm.Â
You ached for him every time he slid out, but he made it up to you with every push back in, hitting your sweet spot with precision that made your heart flutter at how well he knew your body.Â
âFuck,â he choked out, his eyes fluttering shut as the sensation of your pussy swallowing his entire length and the buttplug that shifted against his prostate pinned him between two sources of pressure he could barely handle. âYouâre so tight.. itâs too much,â
âItâs okay,â you murmured softly, pressing a firm kiss to his forehead, âyouâre doing so well. Just breathe,â your fingers traced his sweaty spine to encourage him.Â
He slightly shifted his legs, adjusting his position to reach deeper into you.Â
One of his hands slid down your chest before reaching your lower stomach, pressing against the warm flesh to add more pressure as he drove into you with more force, almost making you jolt at how deep you felt him.Â
âSpencer..â you moaned, your hips bucking up to meet his own.Â
The combination of his palm pressing into your abdomen and his dick buried to the hilt made your vision blur.Â
Spencer knew you liked it when he added tension to your walls, and even if he was deluding himself into thinking that fucking you right now was merely a reward for his big win, he couldnât lie to himselfâhe was completely at the mercy of your pleasure.Â
The heat pooling between your thighs was unbearable, your walls clenching tightly with every roll of his hipsâpulling him closer and closer to the edge.Â
Spencerâs hands trembled against the mattress, his head hanging low as he fought to keep his composure.Â
âWant me to ride you?â
âNoâ I meanâ Iâd love that, but I can do this. I promise, I canââ
âShh, hey.. Itâs okay,â you murmured, your palm coming up to lightly rest against his flushed cheek, âTake your time,âÂ
His brows knitted together. He couldnât tell why you were being so nice, but the hushing tone disarmed him and he was far too gone to overthink it.Â
With a desperate whimper, he resumed his thrusts, pulling out almost entirely before plunging back into you, tearing a sound that almost sounded like a cry from your chest.Â
âDoes that feel good?â he panted, his voice trembling as he maintained the relentless, fast pace.Â
Your toes curled and your hips strained up to swallow him deeper, âYesâSpencer, god, donât stop,â you moaned out, your nails digging into his back.
âIâm really close,â he whispered, parting his lips to lazily drag open-mouthed kisses against your collarbone, his saliva cooling your feverish skin, âIâm so so close,âÂ
Spencer was whining, wishing he wasnât on the brink of finishing so he could drag it out and edge you until he was ready to let go.Â
You slid your hands down to his hips, giving them a harsh squeeze, feeling them stutter under your touch.Â
âCome for me, Spence,â your fingers dug into his skin, âjust let go,âÂ
Hearing his nickname on your lips completely ruined him, and he finally snapped.Â
âFuck--fuck!â he sobbed into the crook of your neck, his whole frame trembling as he shot his load into you.Â
He held himself pinned deep inside your pulsing heat as the overwhelming waves of his hot thick cum erupted from him.Â
He couldnât stop the broken groans escaping his chest with every surge of his release, filling you until your orgasm was triggeredâa blinding, violent rush of pleasure drowning out all your senses.Â
Every nerve in your body was lit aflame as your pussy clamped desperately around him, the juices spilling past your entrance, painting your inner thighs.Â
âGod, it hurtsâit hurts so good,â he sobbed against your skin.Â
You were almost certain that Spencer had never gotten this deep inside of you, and you were flooded with pride.Â
âYou did so good..â you smoothed your palms up his back as you pressed a soft kiss to his neck, âsuch a messy boy,âÂ
You let him rest on top of you for a few minutes, hearing his frantic heartbeat pounding in your ear.
Once his breathing evened out, you gently tapped his hips, âWe still have to deal with your little accessory, though,â you stroked his messy hair.Â
He gave you a sluggish, dazed nod  âJust be careful.. Iâm really sore.â
Your fingers reached around to find the blunt base of the plug, pulling a sharp gasp out of Spencerâs raw throat as you gave the cold metal a gentle twist.Â
âIâm very impressed with how well you took it,â you murmured in an attempt to shift his focus away from the pain.Â
âIâI donât know how I even did that.âÂ
âJust push against it so it doesnât hurt as bad,â you instructed in his ear, and he immediately obliged.Â
âGood job,â with a slow, steady pull you eased the plug out of him.Â
The sudden release sent a fresh, involuntary shudder straight to his hips, making his softening dick twitch inside you.Â
âHere ya go,â you gave him a small smile, bringing the plug to his vision before he took it between his fingers, clumsily pulling out of you to get off of your body.Â
You could absolutely tease Spencer until he exploded right now, about the toy and the sobbing and everything in between, but you chose to stay silent and let him lay flat next to you.Â
âI didnât know you could play blindfold chess,â he whispered after a long beat of silence.
âThereâs a lot you donât know about me, Reid.â you turned to look at his spent face, his prominent cheekbones catching the dim light of your room, making him look so edible.Â
Spencer almost said that he wished he knew everything about you. But he simply caught his lower lip between his teeth, staring into your eyes, and using these few moments of pure peace to take in the mesmerizing sight of your relaxed face, so serene and raw.Â
âYou smell.â you teased, âYou should go shower, while I order some food.â you sat up against the headboard, pulling the sheets up to your chest. Â
Spencerâs face scrunched up in annoyance, âNo, you go first. You shouldnât delay peeingâunless you wanna contract a UTI, of course. Might as well take a full shower while youâre at it.âÂ
You reached for your phone that was now buried somewhere in the sheets, âIâll justââ
Spencer shot up as his hand slammed against the mattress, physically stopping you from finding your phone, âIâll take care of it, I know what you wanna eat,âÂ
His sudden urgency made you jolt and accept his protest, âOokay, weirdo,â you swung your legs over the edge of the bed, rolling your eyes as he stayed completely still, ogling your naked body as the white fabric slid off your skin.Â
Spencerâs favorite part of nights like this was the quiet drop of your walls. He found your presence quite enjoyable when you fell silent and allowed him to stay close without worrying about saying the wrong thing and breaking the spell.Â
He hated that your kindness only bled through after sex, leaving him selfishly wishing he could keep you in that state forever.
















