Cass Cain? Battle-wise yes, Strategy, Detective skill, Experience = no. Relationship with other crimefighter = no. Dick Grayson is the obvious choice. It takes something more than cracking skull ability to become the bat. I know you love Cass, but she have nothing but her martial arts ability.
No, dude, you misunderstand? Legitimately? This was the actual comic strategy. Iām not making this up as a āfanatical Cass fanā, this was the plan in the comics for years. Cass was training to take Bruceās place.Ā
[Batgirl (2000-2006) #58]
After the arc with Lady Shiva, Cassā series kicked into full gear with Cass expanding her horizons and training in other areas, her new goal was to live her life and to take over for Batman, itās all she ever wanted after conquering her death wish, it was her full goal and objective.
And Bruce knew this and started training her detective skills as a result. (Something Dick had already started working with her on during the Bruce Wayne: Murderer?/Fugitive arc and had been set up since the Lady Shiva arc)
[Batgirl (2000-2006) #34]
Now am I saying Dick couldnāt or even shouldnāt have been Batman during this time period after BftC? No, Iām a fan of DickBats, but hereās the thing: Dick never wanted to be Batman. And Batman was never going to be a permanent title for him, not because of Bruceās given return to the cowl, but because Dick had already carved out a well respect identity and mantle for himself outside of Bruceās shadow. He was a prominent superhero who was going to leave his own void and rift in the community the more he was drawn into the Batman mantle.
And being Batman, while Dick would grow into a new form of the identity separate from Bruceās, was never going to perfectly be Dickās style. Nightwing is an extension of who Dick is, it is his second skin, always has been.
Bruce himself has never wanted to take that from Dick. Dickās never wanted to step away from it. Dickās entire coming of age story was about him becoming something greater than the sum of his parts and influences.
[Detective Comics (1937-2011) #725]
Like the entirety of Dickās time as Batman is him having to deal with this situation, something he never really wanted to do, something Bruce never wanted him to have to do, and even him coming to own the situation doesnāt make that any less true.
He has the connections over Cass for sure, and the experience of some of the finer points of how Batmanās position works, but Dick didnāt want it, Tim never wanted it, there were two people whose entire characters dealt with them wanting the position of Batman after their father left the mortal coil or even just the mantle on its own.
[Batgirl (2000-2006) #59]
Hell this desire and ambition was so well known that even in FabNicās Red Robin run where Timās subconscious created a future Justice League of his closest friends and colleagues, guess who cameoād as not Batwoman or Black Bat but as Batma[n:
[Red Robin (2009-2011) #19]
I think what irritates me most about this entire situation, though, is this idea that I have to dislike or not want Dick as Batman in order to state the canon fact that Cass was supposed to take up the mantle as Batman next according to literally everyone from 2003 forward until OOPS actual time for someone to replace Batman.Ā
Not like the DC Universe had a 20+ year history of multiple people in the same world carrying the same mantle at that very same time. How you doing there, Green Lantern 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8āĀ Or that that would be exactly what happened when Bruce came back and no one cared whatsoever.
Or maybe Iām just increasingly put off by this idea that Iām ājust a Cass fan.ā I feel like literally every opinion I talk about anymore is somehow voided to most people by the fact that Iām a known fan of one character and that my analytical abilities is just completely useless if that characterās involved like I have no self awareness.Ā
[pfftt just forget that this blog used to be 50-50 Cass and Dick analysis before literally it became so toxic to even mention Dickās name in posts anymore or that opinions I had either were attacked or were framed as āhurting otherās feelingsā when I defended myself pffftttt]