“People getting upset when a main character is a main character” is such a tired response to genuine criticism about Jax because up until recently, it wasn’t clear that he was a main character.
Goose shouldn’t have gotten the hate she did and she is an incredible writer (I mean, can you believe this is just her “testing the waters”?), but I also think that if you have to clarify halfway through your show that someone is a protagonist, then it wasn’t very clear.
Especially when the show was advertised as this:
This post was super misleading when you realize that episodes five, six, seven, and now nine are focused on Jax. He takes up a good 50% of the narrative and receives much more complexity than Pomni, another main character.
Don’t get me wrong, I love Pomni! But we don’t get much on her backstory in the way we do for Jax. Jax, as a character, could remain distinct on his own, whereas Pomni, as a character, heavily exists in relation to the other characters. That isn’t inherently bad, because a core part of her character is her empathy and connection with the others, but you can have that and still give her some interesting lore to work with.
So even then, it’s unfortunately imbalanced.
It’s also the fact that Ragatha, Zooble, and Kinger were all forced to have only half of an episode dedicated to themselves (although I do think that they have great development outside of those episodes), all so that Jax could get more screen time.
I wasn’t even going to rant about this but I am so sick of people telling you that you lack media literacy the second you point out that the attention given to Jax, regardless of he is a main character or not, is heavily imbalanced.
And while I do find Jax interesting, it’s a strange choice to have Kinger’s dead wife — one of the creators of the Circus and Caine — have less build-up than Jax’s dead friend.
(Also, I’m biased, but having Caine — the antagonist with a backstory we don’t even fully know yet — have half of the screen time of an abusive misogynist is a little disappointing, but that’s just my opinion.)
Criticism doesn’t equal hatred. I don’t hate the show, or Jax, or anyone involved. I love TADC and am excited to see how Jax’s story plays out in episode nine. So please don’t interpret this the wrong way. <3
I’m not saying you have to dislike the amount of screen time Jax gets at all.
But I do also think people are so intolerant of different opinions and the responses are so irritating.