A Brave New World: Retirements, Roster Changes, and adapting the Korean Mindset for the North American LCS.
When the Spring Split ended with a now all too familiar victor in Cloud 9 in dominating fashion, and with the rise of the powerhouse LMQ in the Challenger League, some change in the NA LCS was expected. I don't think anyone expected this. The community was shocked when Nien removed himself from CLG's starting lineup, and then all was quiet for a few peaceful days. Then TSM announced they were benching the best Support in North America, the player that almost single handily secured them 2nd place over CLG, and one of the few NA players recognized world-wide for his skill. Xpecial, who'd been with the team for three years, benched for attitude issues. And no one believed it would last. Not his teammates. Not his fellow players in the LCS. Not even Montecristo. And again, a few peaceful days passed as TSM fans contented themselves with the fact that there's no way Xpecial would actually stay benched. Coast and XDG disbanded and rumors began to circulate about where Mancloud, Xmithie, Shiphtur and ZionSpartan would end up. Dignitas won the arms race, picking up both ZionSpartan and Shiphtur, announcing themselves as a threat for one of NA's three spots at worlds. This was comfortable. The community was fine with this. They had to go somewhere, and neither player they replaced was especially well loved (if we assume Scarra never planned to return). Then, oddly enough, it was something that happened across the pond in Europe that hinted that things were different this time around. Alex Ich, one of the most famous players in the world, left Gambit gaming. With that single move, one thing became clear: nothing was certain and nobody was safe. A Brave New World was coming.
And then the Oddone stepped down from TSM. The longest standing member of TSM, and the only original member left, was gone. Tears were fully stacked, big games were reminisced, and eulogies were said for arguably the most popular, most enduring player in the history of League of Legends. The Oddone had been a member of TSM longer than every team in either the NA or EU LCS has even existed, apart from CLG and SK Gaming. But a new day was rising, and TSM picked up former Copenhagen Wolves jungler, Amazing, whose skill on Lee Sin led him to the highest KDA among EU junglers. And suddenly TSM looked more formidable than they ever had.
Then the bomb dropped. Xpecial was in fact leaving TSM...for Curse. There were no eulogies. Only confusion, frustration and a whole lot of unanswered questions. Questions to which answers began flowing out. There'd been a tryout between Xpecial and Gleebglarbu. The entire team had voted for Gleebglarbu. Reginald had immediately set out to find a new team for Xpecial, likely as payment for years of service. Curse bit, and they had the best Support in North America gift-wrapped to their door.
Now we're at the present, and one thing is clear. League of Legends, and the NA/EU LCS will never be the same.
Whenever a player "retires" the community immediately begins to wonder whether they voluntarily retired, or were forced out and given the opportunity to save some face. Think Bloodwater. At least for now, none of the recent retirements stink of such a maneuver.
The Oddone and Nien voluntarily stepped down, both believing their team would be better with a different player in their role. While Nien appears to be taking a break (likely to recover from the mental stress he was under during the Spring Playoffs), the Oddone chose to remain as a Coach.
Cruzerthebruzer was replaced, and then chose to retire to focus on finishing his education, with the possibility of returning to competitive league in the future.
Scarra was at first replaced and moved to a coaching role, and then returned for the playoffs, and then stepped back again to be Coach when Dignitas picked up Shiphtur.
Benny retired after XDG disbanded, citing a lack of interest, and too much stress after going through a trying year with XDG.
You may note that none of these retirements could be considered going out in the midst of their prime. The Oddone and Scarra's time had come, after long careers in the competitive scene, and both should have no problem making a living merely streaming League. The rest were, quite frankly, not quite up to snuff. It takes a lot of effort, and adaptability to be able to sustain a long career in esports.
Player Acquisitions and Roster Changes
The first major change of the off-season was CLG picking up Seraph, a sub for Naijin White Shield, to replace Nien. To my knowledge, he has played in exactly one game in OGN, and acquitted himself well, though his team lost quite badly. Not much is known yet, but considering Montecristo is involved, CLG fans can rest easy knowing CLG is in good hands.
Until the TSM madness of the past few days, one could have reasonably assumed that Dignitas would be the most changed team in the LCS, having replaced Cruzer and Scarra with former coast players ZionSpartan and Shiphtur. Both are reasonable upgrades at their respective positions, though it will take good coaching to bring out the best in both players, and to give Dignitas a real chance of going to Worlds. Strategy and the ability to adapt to the Meta is more important that individual mechanics in today's League of Legends. To that end, Scarra announced that he is currently in the process of assembling a full support team for Dignitas, and it is quite possible that Dignitas becomes the threat they claim to be.
I was sorely tempted to jump right to the mad weekend that saw TSM lose it's two oldest remaining members, it's important to follow the train of events in order. The Oddone was a founding member. Xpecial was the best Support player in North America, with a reasonable claim to top 5 in the world. Player's like that just don't change teams. Except he did. Both Amazing and GleebGlarbu have massive shoes to fill, not only within the contours of the game, but with the community as well. The pressure to perform will be enormous, and if one or the other can't handle it, the Summer Split could get ugly real quick.
Of course, Xpecial moving to Curse also means that Bunny Fufu was removed from the lineup. He does have options, as Liquid is on record saying that he will try his best to find him a spot on an LCS team, and failing that, will give him the option to craft a new Curse Acadamy team around himself. That is currently neither here nor there. What does Xpecial mean to Curse? Possibly not much. There was a reason Chaox was benched, and Cop has a very similar playstyle. It's quite possible the move could end up a train wreck, if one or the other isn't able to adapt his playstyle. I can already envision times where Xpecial engages, and Cop just doesn't respond fast enough, or at all. And having a passive ADC will drastically limit Xpecial's play-making ability. It would be hasty to call this a huge improvement for Curse until we see them in action.
Throughout all three completed Seasons of League of Legends, the European Region has outperformed North America in international competition, and it hasn't really been close. EU teams have consistently challenged for the World Championship, while NA teams struggle to make it out of groups. But times are changing. Without a doubt, North America has a far better infrastructure than EU. Part of this is because it's just two countries, Canada and the United States, and it's very easy for all the teams to set up shop near LA in gaming houses. The studio is a short ride away. Gambit drives an entire day each week to get to the EU LCS. It's becoming clear that this wasted time is hurting EU teams. And in a shocking assertion of real life into virtual, the issues in Ukraine may prevent Gambit from returning to their gaming house. It also goes without saying that the talent pool in Europe is much larger than that of North America. What is currently happening in the NA and EU LCS is the answer to a very interesting question: What is harder, improving a player's mechanics, or teaching them proper strategy and how to play within the Meta. Clearly, LCS teams think the answer is the latter. Thus, EU talent is moving to North America where the infrastructure is better, coaching is better, and competition, until recently, was weaker. While the former is most certainly still true, the latter may not be. While the EU LCS was competitive in the sense that all the teams were pretty average, a definitive top tier has begun to develop in North America, and with the recent roster changes, that tier is gaining in members. If you were to name the Top 6 teams in either LCS, it would likely include 4 NA teams, with Alliance being 6th, and Fnatic somewhere in the top 3.
Adapting the Korean Mindset
I've said before that the biggest thing holding North America back was an overvaluation of friendship, versus performance. I think it's safe to say that's no longer the case. An arms race has started in North America, with talent in both regions up for grabs, and NA teams and fans coming out the winners, with the EU region the losers. And these roster changes have given rise to what may have been an unforeseen development. Previously, it was very difficult for NA teams to afford the coaching staffs provided for Korean teams. Now we have extremely popular players like Scarra and the Oddone, perfectly capable of making a living within the game without that LCS salary due to their popularity, stepping down and moving to coaching roles. Scarra plans to assemble a full staff, while TSM has one purely from retired players. Yes, both these teams are in far better financial situations than the average LCS/Challenger teams, the fact remains that as the old guard retires, a pool of possible coaches will open up that previously didn't exist.
So here we have two major advantages the Korean scene has over NA beginning to disappear. Teams are more likely to replace under-performing players (maybe even a little too quick sometimes), and more and more teams are picking up coaches. While it's too early to call the end of the Koreans dominance, that time may not be that far off.