Star ☆ @starlight--lover - Tumblr Blog

Third time's a charm?

Corny title, I couldn't think of anything.

CW: Suggestive details

It hadn't been the first time someone had attempted to flirt with them. "Them" as in mainly Mateo since he was the more charming one in the relationship. Whenever they were in his world, more people would giggle and point at him but never make the effort to come up and actually get his number. In the very rare times that it would happen, he always politely denied people and would say that he was already a taken man. During the early days of their relationship, most people assumed he was only saying it because of his marriage with Gabriel, even though he had died years ago. That was before the public knew that he was with Scarlet. Regardless, no one tried to push him to sleep with them and he always denied everyone. Having a loyal man like that always did calm Star's nerves down and helped her feel more relaxed in knowing he was only hers. Although she had trusted Mateo to the fullest, things started to change a bit after their date on the beach when a familiar man came to flirt with both of them. It was the first time in a while that she began to question their relationship.

A few days ago on the beach, Mateo and Scarlet were approached by a very handsome man who they quickly realized looked a lot like Gabriel. His name was Gally, a charming man on the beach that instantly had their hearts the moment he winked at them. Not only had Gally spent time flirting and teasing the both of them, he left them with his number with the promise of seeing them again if they called him. The man wanted them and they were starting to question if they wanted him. By the time they got home, the question was still lingering in the air. Call him for a hookup or delete the number and act like they never met? But the issue here was that they both wanted this. I mean come on, the man reminded them so much of Gabriel and it wouldn't hurt just to feel something like him again, right? They trusted each other with this and Gally was greedy enough to want both of them at the same time. But the biggest issue was Scarlet's insecurities beginning to return to her mind and make her overthink the whole situation.

Two days after their beach date, they still hadn't contacted Gally. Scarlet had been lost in thought about the situation, feeling that they should delete the number and ignore what happened. But another part wanted to try this new experience, she just feared what would happen afterwards. But while she was lost in thought one night, Mateo came into the living room and sat down on the couch, wrapping his arm around her. "Everything okay, shiny? Yer awfully quite today." He kissed her head, hoping that everything was okay with her. Scarlet finally snapped out of her thoughts and looked at him, "Huh? Oh yeah, I'm fine." She lied which he instantly caught onto. He frowned and took her hand in his, "Shiny, yer doing it again." He knew when she was trying to hide things from him. Frowning, she turned to fully face him, needing to finally bring up the topic. "Okay fine. I keep thinking about Gally and what he asked."

"Gally? I thought we were going to delete his number?"

"What made you think that?"

"Well ya haven't told me we should call him. This isn't just my choice here shiny."

"Yeah well…" Her cheeks briefly went red as she started to think about the main thing she needed to bring up, "…I've never exactly been in a threesome before."

"Oh. Right. It's not anythin' to be afraid of though."

"That's not.." Okay, it's true that having a third person did scare her but it was also something else. "We've never…let someone else come into our relationship like that. What if something happens? Like what if one of us…falls for him?"

"What do ya mean?" He slightly tilted his head.

"Gally looks a lot like Gabriel, sunshine. I mean come on, that's one of the main reasons we even started to get all flustered."

"Yeah but that doesn't mean anythin'."

"How? What if we do this and you like him better?"

"Star…?"

"I'm serious, Teo'. If he reminded you so much of Gabriel, you would leave me. He's from your universe too which would give you the higher advantage!"

He blinked, wondering where that assumption came from, "Scarlet, I would never do that to you!"

"Bullshit! You say that now but if we do sleep with him, how do I know that I won't be shoved away? That you won't remember Gabriel and just replace me with him! You got to marry your Gabriel so you still have that love for him!" She stood up from the couch and paced around.

"Scarlet, yer stressin' yerself out and makin' this worse than what it is." he spoke calmly, "Let's just talk about this…"

"This isn't stressing you out?"

"I…no, it's not stressin' me out that much."

"Then what is it?! Because for all I know, you could be thinking about letting more people come between us and you're just getting tired of me!" Her insecurities were beginning to slip out and only reveal how much the thought of a threesome was starting to scare her. Mateo was unable to respond for a second, catching onto how she was scared about him potentially allowing more people to sleep with them while hiding that he wanted someone else.

"Scarlet…do ya think I want to be with someone else? That having Gally come over will make me want more people over? That I want an open relationship?"

Scarlet didn't immediately respond but the way she looked at him with anger and hidden sadness gave her answer away. She faced the ground and sighed. Mateo wasn't done and he sat up straighter, leaning forward to try and see her eyes, "Star, I'd never want that. Having Gally sleep with us would just be…a quick hookup. And I told ya before, we don't have to do anythin'! I'll delete the number and this'll be behind us. If ya said no, I wouldn't be upset whatsoever."

"That's not just my only issue either, Mateo. It's how calm you are about this! Do you not understand what we're trying to do!? To sleep with another man?! You're not even getting mad about this!" She gestured to the both of them.

"Why would I get mad?"

"Because of this situation! Mateo, this is a serious thing and you're so calm about it that it's pissing me off!!" Then again getting angry had been pretty easy for her.

"Shiny, I told you, we could just delete the number!"

"But you want this!"

"I never said if I did or I didn't."

Scarlet became frustrated and nearly pulled at her hair before standing up, "You slept with multiple people in the past and had threesomes like it was the shocking thing to do! That's why this isn't scaring you or even making you see why I have an issue with it! This…this feels like some kind of break in loyalty!" Mateo slightly titled his head in response to that and she groaned louder, "Don't look at me like some innocent puppy!"

"I'm not!"

"You so are and you know it!"

Mateo sat up straighter, "Shiny, yer takin' this way out of proportion! Okay fine, I'm calm about this because yes, I've had a threesome but I'm not doing this just for myself! Yer the one who also was willing to do it!"

"Yeah but I thought about it more! What if you fall in love with Gally and realize he's a lot like Gabriel? What if I get kicked off the bed and you two forget I'm there? What if you realize you don't want me anymore?!" That made Mateo's eyes widen and he was almost speechless for a second. Here he was being calm as ever about this while she was worried about what could happen during the hookup. "Scarlet, I would never leave ya for Gally. We just met him!"

"That doesn't mean shock."

"Ya really think I'm gonna sleep with Gally once, fall in love, and then leave ya?" The way he said it made it sound like he thought that was stupid. And yes, she caught it.

"Fix your attitude, Orlin." Her calling him by his last name was a sore subject but not one to deal with at the moment. It was something she did when she was getting angry or annoyed and it's not like he was the first person she's doing it to. Whenever she was mad at Gabriel, she'd do the same thing.

Although he had been thrown back by her calling him by his last name, he continued, "I mean it, Scarlet. Ya can't just…" He paused for a second and sighed, "ya can't just assume that I'm gonna be the one to fall for Gally and leave ya. That's not who I am and ya know it."

"Well you never know!"

"Seriously Scarlet? I'm not going to go that low and cheat on ya. That's not what I do." He watched her pace around. "I love you, Scarlet. And…I'm sorry that this is scarin' ya so much. But Ya have to believe me when I say I'm not just willing to do this for myself either. I trust ya with this and even if we did sleep with Gally, who's to say we'd ever see him again? He's not ma boyfriend and he's not yers either."

"I'm just having second thoughts on this, Mateo. I mean do we need to call him right now?"

"What? No! No. Of course not. I wasn't trying to rush ya into doing this, Scarlet. We can take as long as we want, there's no deadline to this."

That finally made her relax and begin to realize that she was taking this farther than it needed to go. Maybe it was time for them to have a deeper conversation instead of diving head first into a hookup. After all, there were some unspoken things for Scarlet to bring up. "Can we just…call it a night please? The argument felt like it could only get worse if she didn't calm down more and she didn't feel like fighting anymore since he was being very reasonable. Mateo nodded and stood up, offering his hand to her so they could go to bed together. There was a moment of hesitation before she took it and followed him to the bedroom. In the room, Scarlet changed out of her clothes, putting on one of his shirts with nothing underneath. With both of them not saying a word, it felt like there was still unresolved tension between them and neither didn't know if it was time to apologize. But it wasn't Mateo's fault either since Scarlet was the one to get snappy first but that didn't mean he didn't feel bad and felt like he had some fault in causing her to get upset.

Even with the tension of the argument still in the air, Scarlet got into bed and laid down on her side as Mateo joined her on his side. For a second, neither of them moved or scooted over to the other, feeling like the tension still was too high for cuddling. Thankfully, Scarlet was the one to move first, wrapping her arms around him and holding him tighter than normal. Teo' didn't say a word and instead just held her close to his chest while gently stroking her hair. It was enough to make her tear up and quietly cry but not enough to hide it from him. He could feel her trembling, knowing it was because of her insecurities getting to her head. They should talk about it instead of going to bed so they could clear the air but right now this was all they could do.

Normally in the morning, Scarlet and Mateo would wake up together and take their sweet time in bed and eventually get up to have breakfast together or just laze around. They deserved that kind of peace together anyways. But this morning, Scarlet woke up first and looked at Mateo, making sure he was still fully asleep before attempting to slip out of bed. Only issue was that he always has a tight grip on her so she doesn't slip away. Any other day would have been fine but today she just needed to get away for a bit. She squirmed and tried to push him without waking him up but it felt like he held her tighter whenever she moved a few inches. "Jammit honey" She muttered and continued to squirm away. Barley using her telekinesis, she very carefully lifted his arms enough so she could escape and quickly shoved a pillow where she was at so he'd think he was still holding her. Standing up and staying completely still, she watched him mumble something in his sleep before settling into the pillow. Scarlet finally could breathe and make her escape. Guess there is some good things about being a thicker woman.

Throwing on a hoodie and sweats that she's left at his place before, she looked back at him for a second before leaving to get some fresh air. All she needed was a few hours to herself and maybe watch the sunset in a beautiful spot before the day officially started. She never had the heart to fully leave and it wasn't like her world was any more peaceful to roam around. Leaving his apartment was easy. Flying out into the sky and passing through the clouds as the sun was beginning to rise had been much more peaceful than staying in bed. Just for today though. The golden sun slowly began to rise and brighten the city, allowing Scarlet to feel its warmth and take a breath of the fresh air. It was much more different than what she experiences back in her world where the air feels too thick and often trapped. It was more a prison over in the universe than here. What a joy it must be to live in such a peaceful world where order is better controlled. Not run by a corrupt society where drones stalk every citizen and mutants would be deemed as monsters. It wasn't fair. But Scarlet was grateful to be able to experience it and see a universe where things aren't so bad. It wasn't perfect but it had been so much better than hers. As she continued to fly and feel the sun begin to wake the city up and warm the earth, she put on some wired headphones she brought with her and plugged it into her phone. Selecting her playlist, she pocketed her phone and continued to fly around, letting the music calm her down more. Random songs played while she flew past buildings and felt like she could fly without needing to run away from a group of people. She stayed outside for hours and let the whole playlist finish before she decided it was time to head home. On her way back, "Brooklyn Baby" by Lana Del Rey began to play which only made her chuckle to herself. "Kinda reminds me of a certain cowboy…" She couldn't stay mad at him forever. Although she was supposed to be heading back, she made a quick stop at a restaurant to pick up some breakfast.

The breakfast spot she went to was one they commonly went to when wanting something quick. It was called "Cozy Eats" and they would go so much that most of the workers recognize them. There weren't a ton of places where people would recognize Star so coming here actually made her feel good. Entering inside, the smell of fresh bread and sweet pastries made her stomach growl. The whole vibe of the restaurant was very calm and it was warm inside with the workers also being extremely friendly. Today for breakfast, Scarlet ordered them some breakfast bagels with some sweet coffee for herself and lavender matcha for Teo' with extra sweetener. Right before paying for it, there was a fresh batch of doughnuts being glazed in the back which instantly caught her attention. The cashier caught onto her gaze and smiled, "I'll add two to the order." Star's cheeks went red from slight embarrassment at being caught like that. "Could you actually make that two boxes?" The worker paused what they were doing and looked back at her with a surprised expression. "As in…2 dozen?" This poor worker. She nodded and the worker looked back at the baker that brought out the doughnuts. "I'll get that for you right now."At least they weren't judgmental about this because anywhere else they would have been concerned.

Getting everything which was a small bag that had the bagels, the two boxes of doughnuts, and a cup carrier with their drinks. Thankfully having telekinesis was helpful in times like these so she was able to carry everything back home where they would have a nice breakfast.

Back at the apartment, Mateo was barley starting to wake up once the sun was hitting the curtains and barley peeking inside. His arms instinctively tightened around what was supposed to be Scarlet but he caught onto how much softer "she" felt. When seeing the pillow in his arms, his heart stopped for a second when realizing she wasn't here and clearly had left in secret. The blankets flew off as he jumped out of bed, getting worried that she left him after the argument last night and only making him feel much worse. Did it go too far? Should he have apologized last night instead of waiting in the morning? Did she leave him for good? But even with these thoughts floating in his mind, he calmed himself down to process that she wouldn't do that. "She just…left real quick. She'll be back. He told himself while pacing around. It wasn't like her to just get up and leave without saying anything but this was their first argument in a while which did go the wrong way. His fear of abandonment was really beginning to kick in while he waited for her to hopefully come back. He was sort of like a dog that was waiting for their owner. Poor cowboy :(

Luckily it didn't take very long before the front door opened and in came Scarlet, carrying all the stuff she got from Cozy Eats and humming along to the song playing through her headphones. Mateo looked up quickly and rushed over to pull her into a tight hug. "Oof!" She squeaked when he unexpectedly hugged her. Didn't think he would already be awake but she did lose track of time and it wasn't going to take long before he caught onto the pillow trick. "Good morning, honey." She could feel him squeezing her tighter than normal, only giving away his worry. "Teo'?" When she said his name, he pulled back and really looked at her for a second before finally speaking, "I thought ya left and went home…"

Scarlet took off her headphones and saw how worried he looked, "Oh…oh no, I would never do that. I just needed some air and some time to myself."

"Ya could've told me, shiny."

"I didn't want to wake you up."

"Well do it next time. Please?"

A slight frown formed for a moment before she sighed and nodded, 'Yeah, I'll make sure to wake you up next time. I promise." She kissed his cheek and he hugged her tightly again. When they pulled away from each other, Scarlet brought the food into view and smiled softly. "I uh…brought some food for us." Mateo looked at the items and chuckled softly, "And you bought breakfast without me? I'm hurt, shiny."

"I won't do it again, I promise." She kissed him again, this time on the lips.

The couple went to the kitchen and Mateo carried most of the stuff now although Star had it. He just wanted to help her and she didn't argue since she already had him worried. Setting everything down, Mateo was already sipping at his drink and sat down next to Scarlet as they began to enjoy some breakfast. The breakfast bagels were sandwiches with egg and sausage, Scarlet's had bacon as extra, and then there were the doughnuts. Any normal person would have assumed the doughnuts had been for the both of them to split and eat over time but no. One whole box went to each of them because yes they could eat a whole box of a dozen doughnuts. But as they ate together in silence, there was still a slight tension in the air that lingered from the argument last night. They both were aware they had to address it eventually if not they would have lingering issues. For a while, no one ate until they finished their sandwiches. Mateo reached for his box of doughnuts and took one out while Star took a sip of her coffee that looked like it was a cup of milk. She finally spoke up, "Can we talk about what happened last night?" Mateo looked at her and nodded while still eating his doughnut.

"Look I'm…." The first rule of an argument is to admit that you were wrong. "…I'm sorry about what I said. I shouldn't have been making those assumptions and saying that you would leave me if we slept with Gally." She sighed and fiddled with her hands, rubbing her fingertips. "I should've been more honest about this whole thing and how it's been scaring me."

Mateo finished his doughnut and then closed the box, turning all his attention onto her, "It's okay shiny. That's ma fault too for not askin' ya how ya feel about Gally and this potential hookup. I was too calm about the whole thing and failed to see how it was effectin' ya."

"We messed up there. I mean, don't get me wrong, I really want to do this. You saw how I reacted when Gally came to flirt with us. I just got…scared thinking that if we do this that you'd leave me."

"Shiny, I would never do that to ya. I know he looks similar to Gabriel but he's not him and I could never do that to ya." He took her hands into his own, "I won't lie to ya about one thing though. My love for Gabriel is still there and….Gally does remind me of him. But I can't do that to ya and just abandon ya like that. We've built this relationship together."

"I know that you still love Gabriel and so do I. We lost him…" She frowned.

"I'm always going to regret that. I couldn't….save him."

"Hey…' Scarlet cupped his cheek and made him look at her. "It wasn't your fault. There was nothing you could do in that moment. Trust me, I always think about what I could have done to save him."

"The universe must hate us, huh?" Mateo lightly joked.

"When it comes to loving Gabriel, I guess so. That's something I can't control" She scoffed.

"That's just how the timelines work, I suppose"

"Stupid…" She scoffed again. Thinking for a second, she looked at him again, "You know I love you, Mateo. And I do trust you. I just got in on my own head.

"And I love ya too, Scarlet. I promise to talk to ya about somethin' like this if it ever happens again. Ya deserve that much." He kissed her head and she finally relaxed, now remembering that she had nothing to worry about. But the thought of a threesome still scared her only because she didn't know if she could handle two people at the same time. Butttt….she did still wanna try. "So um…did you…wanna try to call Gally? Or text him? Unless he somehow already got tired of waiting and deleted your number."

Mateo laughed at that and then grabbed his phone, "I could try. But yer positive that ya wanna do this? Don't agree just because ya wanna make me happy, shiny." She looked at him again and really thought about it for a moment. What could possibly go wrong about this? The most that could happen was just embarrassing herself. "I'm positive that I want this too. Besides, if I can't handle it then I'll just step out." "Well then I'm doin' the same thing if ya can't handle it."

"Teo'…"

"I'm serious, shiny. If ya get uncomfortable, we can always stop. I promise.:"

"…thank you."

"Of course." He pressed a kiss to her head. "We'll text him later today, okay? Why don't we just relax for now?"

She nodded, wanting to take the opportunity to take her time before they allowed Gally to come over. "Yeah that sounds good."

Later that day, Gally gets a message from an unknown number while he was eating some food alone at his home. Checking the message curiously and reading it over, he smirked when realizing who it was from. He sent a response back to say that he would be on his way in about thirty minutes which would allow him to get ready for this fun night. "Looks like that cowboy wanted me after all." He chuckled to himself and got up, forgetting about the food he was eating. Just as he entered his bedroom to grab some fresh clothes, he remembered the woman that was with the charming cowboy. He quickly sent another text to confirm how this night was potentially going to go. Either he would be sleeping with one person or two, which he wouldn't mind either or. But when he got the text back saying both of them were there, he grinned and felt more giddy, knowing he was about to have a very good night. Getting in the shower and freshening up, Gally put on his sunglasses and threw on a dark green plaid shirt over a white t-shirt followed by some jeans. He made sure to put on some cologne before leaving to really seal the deal. Not that he needed to since he remembered how flustered the two of them had gotten when he did simple flirting.

The drive to the apartment hadn't been a long one and he made sure that he still looked presentable by the time he arrived. Before Gally arrived however, Scarlet and Mateo had been making sure the place was clean and lets face it, that whole building doesn't have a spec of dust anywhere. Teo' rushed to change into something more presentable and Star went to go rush a quick shower. These two don't really need to get ready like that but when its a man that looks like their dead fiancé/husband, they basically forgot all their charm and flirting skills. By the time Gally managed to get up to the door, they had just finished and made sure nothing on them would give something away. None of Star's skin had been showing her true form for now and Teo'…well he doesn't need to worry about hiding much, everyone just sees him as the sexy country singer. They exchanged a quick kiss and smiled before answering the door. Seeing Gally there made both of them forget how to speak for a moment and blush. Gally himself smirked and place his sunglasses on his head, "Oh man, am I glad to see you two again." he winked and already knew he had them flustered. "Uh, it's good to see ya too. Come on in." Mateo let him inside. The moment Gally entered, he looked around and almost felt like he went back in time seeing the vintage looking theme inside. It was a two story penthouse and the entrance alone had a view to the stunning swirling staircase followed by a marble flooring. The lighting was warm and dim and it smelled faintly of cinnamon and vanilla. He let out a low whistle as he looked around, "Wow. Quite a place you've got here. The entrance alone feels bigger than my own room."

Mateo sheepishly rubbed the back of his neck and had a faint blush on his cheek, "Ah, thank you. It is quite a ton of space." He chuckled. Gally nodded and wandered around but didn't get too far as he wanted to respect the space. "Soooo…" He started, "How are we doing this? Sit down and relax for a bit or just get straight into the good stuff?" Both Star and Teo' nearly stopped breathing when he said that and looked at each other. Scarlet managed to speak first, "Um! Why don't we just…relax for a bit?" "Alright, fine by me." He followed them to the living room where the couple sat next to each other and Gally sat across from the on the other couch. For about an hour or so, they all had a nice conversation together, mainly trying to learn more about Gally while also telling him things about them. He knew officially now that Star and Teo' had been dating for quite some time but were willing to have a third just for hookup purposes. Gally respected that, not wanting anything serious with them anyways, although the idea hadn't been a bad one. Although Star had been the one to try and stretch the conversation for as long as possible because she was becoming nervous, they started to discuss how the hookup was going to go. She let Mateo speak more which was mainly about consenting to certain things along with setting some boundaries such as Scarlet getting uncomfortable would mean they would fully stop. Once again though, Gally had been okay with that and wasn't one to push anyone out of their comfort zone.

"So, why don't you two go get comfortable and then I'll see you in the bedroom?" Gally suggested. The couple nodded, leaving to their bedroom. Mateo just went to take off his clothes while Scarlet went to the bathroom to fully change into something better. She had been more and more nervous as if this would be her first time sleeping with someone. "Why is this getting to me? It's one night and then we're done! It can't be so bad…jeez…" She mumbled to herself while getting undressed. Meanwhile, Mateo was perfectly fine while getting undressed until he was shirtless and looking charming as ever. By the time Star was done, she exited out the bathroom and came back to the bedroom while pacing around nervously. Mateo caught onto this quickly, "Shiny? What's wrong?"

"I dunno. I'm just…we're really doing this, huh? Sleeping with another person that looks a lot like Gabriel. I can't believe we're doing it." Although she had been stressing around and pacing back and forth, she failed to realize that she was wearing a new lingerie piece that was meant to be a surprise for Mateo but now was going to be a surprise for him and Gally. Mateo got distracted by the piece as it was a mix of a misty dark blue and purple to look like outer space that had white constellations patterned on it . The top piece had black lace trimming along the bra and waist whole the bottom piece had lacing so it could rest at the hips. It looked amazing on her which only made him flustered. While she was yapping away about how nervous and shy she was about this, Teo' had been staring at her and admiring how she looked. He eventually stepped forward and stopped her from pacing around. "Hey hey…listen to me." Putting his hands on her waist to stop her, she looked up at him curiously, "Everythin' is going to be okay, shiny. Just remember that if it gets too much to handle, we can stop immediately, okay? I'll be right there with ya."Scarlet took a deep breath and nodded, holding his hands to calm herself down more. "Right right…it's going to be fine. This is going to be fun." Her nerves began to calm down and she leaned against him. "Guh…this is so embarrassing. Feels like I'm having sex for the first time." Mateo chuckled at that, "There's just more work to put into it."

"Oh fun." She weakly chuckled.

"It's going to be fine. Just focus on me if ya need comfort. I'll guide ya." That was hot. He kissed her hand and then looked down at what she was wearing again. "How long have ya been hiding this from me?"

She blushed and chuckled, "Why Do you like it?"

"That's one way of putting it." He kissed her neck and she giggled softly, letting him kiss her more for a bit before Gally came into the room. "Aw, don't tell me that you two already started without me." He joked. The couple looked back at him and moved apart, getting flustered from getting caught for a second. They were different people when it came to Gally. But he chuckled some more and moved closer, "I never said stop." That definitely had them blushing more.

Scarlet and Mateo went to sit on the bed together while Gally began to take off his clothes. He stripped down slowly, giving them a mini show of his body as he knew how much he got them hot and bothered. First was his pants that he slid down and then his shirt which finally let them see his caramel skin that had some faint freckles on it. When he looked back at them, they were already staring and blushing more than before. He climbed onto to the bed to join them, not saying a word yet. Although Mateo was flustered, Scarlet was much more shy about this, more than normal. Often times, she gets flustered when Mateo takes the lead but this was on a different level and she didn't know what to do. She sat back in the bed and Gally noticed how tense she looked, "Hey, it's okay baby. I'll be gentle." He reassured her. Even though she knew that, it didn't calm her nerves down. But it wasn't enough for her to leave the room and Gally instead decided to focus on Mateo first.

It started off slow with them just kissing and their hands slowly beginning to explore each other. Gally laid him back and had his hand on his chest to feel his muscles while feeling how he twitched. He had to learn what made Teo' flinch and shudder first and that required him to take his time. His hands went to his waist while Teo' let him sit on his lap and continued to kiss him. Scarlet watched, her heart pounding rapidly in her chest as she saw Gally passionately kiss him. Gally wasn't silent as he let out quiet groans and soft whimpers when Mateo touched the right places. Their kissing led to Gally kissing down his neck and finding his sweet spots, occasionally nibbling certain areas enough to barley leave the smallest mark on him. Star didn't know how much time had passed while she was watching them get to explore each other better. But eventually, Gally pulled back from Teo' and gently pulled her closer to them to remind her that she was here too and was going to get the same treatment. Laying her back as well and next to Mateo, Gally came down to not kiss her on the lips bit on her neck. From how flustered she was from watching them and already feeling aroused, she was already whimpering and letting him know what spots felt good and what was making her twitch. Mateo joined in to make sure she felt as comfortable as possible in this moment and although it had been overwhelming at first, she was slowly beginning to melt into their embraces.

The first round together had Gally feeling both of them and getting to know their bodies. To figure out what made them twitch and what made them gasp. He never pushed it but learned that Mateo had been quicker with adjusting to him and certain spots he touched. Scarlet was a little longer as she was tense throughout most of it but started to feel more relaxed when remembering Mateo was close enough. Gally learned how both of them were into praise and Scarlet was into being guided through certain commands. It didn't take him very long to see how effected the two of them had been by him alone and it only made him feel much more confident in making them feel good. Every touch, every moan, every gasp, it allowed him to feel even better about himself.

The sheets were starting to get ruined and gripped, some of the pillows nearly fell off the bed and the creaking of the headboard surely had to make the neighbors notice that something could be happening. Overtime, Gally and Scarlet only became more vocal the more they went on, crying out in pleasure and moaning either names like it was a prayer. When they both focused on Mateo and praised him, whispering in his ear on how good he was doing, how good he felt for them, and begging him to keep going, it made him nearly melt right then and there, groaning louder and barley saying a curse under his breath that only gained him more praise. The room was beginning to feel hotter and much more tense with desire once the first round was done. Scarlet's stars were beginning to form in the room, something she wasn't able to fully control. She had to lie to Gally that it was just something he was seeing or was because of the lighting in the room. Thankfully, he believed it. But once they were done with the first two rounds, Gally assumed he had them finished for the night like most of his hookups were. However, when he sat up and looked at both of them, he quickly noticed how neither of them looked like they broke a sweat yet while he was already feeling tired. Scarlet's shyness had faded and Mateo was beginning to feel much more confident in what he was doing. Gally weakly smiled as they came in to handle him for the rest of the remaining rounds he could handle.

Scarlet focused on kissing Gally while Mateo did the majority of the work for the third round, occasionally switching positions and even attempting to try new ones that he could handle. Gally had been moaning much louder during these rounds, mainly because his body was becoming much more sensitive and he was slowly losing energy and becoming overstimulated. He hadn't complained once as he heard more praises while hearing the two of them either moan or grunt. Now he had been the one gripping the sheets, begging for more until he nearly lost his voice or couldn't handle much more. He barley was able to handle the fourth round when realizing neither of them were tired yet, only concerning him more about how his poor body was going to react overtime. But thankfully, the two of them finally stopped when they saw how tired he appeared along with how he was ready to pass out from exhaustion. "Okay, I think that's enough for tonight." Mateo pulled away from Gally and let him catch his breath while Scarlet helped him get comfortable in bed. "You two…are crazy." He was barley awake while forcing that out. The couple managed to lay him down in a better position and fix the bed so he was comfortable enough to get some rest. While they did this, he noticed the stars floating in the room and how it almost looked like they were in outer space. "Have those always been there?" He questioned while trying to clear his vision to get a better view. Scarlet noticed how much brighter her stars looked and knew this was something she needed to hide. But instead of trying to force them away or laugh it off, she lied, "You're just tired, honey. Think you're seeing stuff now." She giggled and pressed a kiss to his cheek. Gally nodded, too tired to figure out the lie, "Yeah…you're probably right." His eyes fluttered shut just as Mateo kissed his head, "Get some rest now, darlin'.

Once Gally was fully asleep, the couple looked at one another and chuckled, laying next to each other but close to Gally so he knew they were there. He was completely knocked out from their night of passion and had visible marks on him such as bites and a few scratches on his back. His hair was messy and lips were slightly swollen from how much they had been kissing him. But he was going to be treated well by the morning time and for now he would have a warm bed to sleep in with Scarlet and Mateo. They both decided to recover together since they weren't tired yet but were now relaxing in each others embrace.

"You doing okay?" Scarlet asked Teo' while resting her head on his chest and holding his hand.

"Perfectly fine, shiny." He kissed her head and rubbed her back. "What about ya? Feelin' better than before?"

"Much better. After that first round, I felt so much more comfortable. Didn't think we'd try some new things though." She giggled.

"Glad he was able to handle that much though." They both looked at Gally as he slept, taking in how gentle his expression was while sleeping. Mateo was holding his hand while Scarlet was resting hers on top and rubbing his knuckles.

"Did he remind you of Gabriel?" She quietly asked.

"Yes…just a bit."

"I almost said his name a few times. I hope he doesn't remember that."

"I nearly did. But I'm sure he was too distracted to have caught it."

While relaxing for a bit and enjoying the aftermath of everything, Mateo kissed her head again, "Shiny, how are ya feelin' now that it's all done? About what ya said before all this?"

"Oh…that?" Thinking back to how nervous she had been about the situation and how she felt like Mateo would leave her, she finally realized there was nothing to worry about. Everything had gone extremely well and there was so much trust between each of them. Gally was patient with both of them during the first round when he was feeling them and even took small breaks if anything had been too much. The same applies to Mateo as he had been reassuring throughout their time together and would check in on her to make sure she wasn't too overwhelmed. Even when it was him over her, he would whisper sweet things and even slip in how much he loved her.

"I shouldn't have been freaking out so much," She finally admitted, "I shouldn't have put so much blame onto you and assumed you would leave me. I was just so scared about….y'know."

"About being abandoned?"

She nodded.

"Oh shiny, I could never do that to ya. And I'm sorry again that I didn't talk to ya about this before we texted Gally. This was a huge choice and I should have made sure everything was okay between us."

"I'm sorry too. But hey, this was sorta new for both of us. And it was good. Well, besides the argument part."

Mateo chuckled, "yeah, besides that." He cupped her cheek and made him look at her, "I love you, shiny. I really do."

Melting every time he said, she smiled, "I love you too, sunshine." They shared a quick but loving kiss and stayed in each others embrace for a second before Scarlet caught glimpse of her stars again, "Geez. I didn't realize how bright these things were going to be." She laughed.

"After so many rounds, I'm not that surprised!" Mateo laughed with her.

"Poor Gally probably thinks he was hallucinating. That's definitely not a normal thing for him."

"He might question why we hadn't been so tired"

"That too!" As they laughed and joked about how much Gally might be confused about, Mateo eventually looked at the stars in his room now and chuckled again.

"Could've changed how they looked so he wouldn't have questioned it." he started to bend the shapes of the stars, making them appear much different than normal. Scarlet's eyes widened and she gasped softly, "Wait, you can do that? Ohhhh its light…" She watched him mess with the shapes of them and giggled at how silly they started to look. Just a bunch of different shapes floating in the room. Scarlet was able to change how bright they were and was also able to move them, pulling them closer and even grabbing a handful and sprinkling it onto Mateo's hair. It almost looked like glitter that was able to faintly glow on him. In their moment together, they laughed about the stars and made different shapes and forms with two being shaped like a heart just as they fell asleep.

The morning sun was fully up in the sky when Gally woke up, only to find himself between Scarlet and Mateo. This had to have been heaven as both of them were holding him close and he was warm in the spot. The bed felt like a cloud, they were both next to him, and he was warm enough that he could sleep here for another few hours if he really wanted to. Although staying in bed sounded like a much better idea since this was probably the best thing he had ever woken up to, his curiosity was beginning to take over. What was supposed to be an easy way to get out of bed had quickly become a huge challenge for him. Just attempting to sit up, the couple kept him down and tightened their grip on him. Being squished by both of them was another issue since any kind of movement immediately alerted them that he was trying to leave. It was really nice but he wanted leave! Squirming around while not trying to wake either of them up, Gally had to slide down and off the bed to finally get free from their embrace. Standing up at the foot of the bed, he saw that they didn't wake up and instead scooted closer to each other to cuddle. It was pretty cute to him and he sighed while running his hand through his hair.

Finally free, he threw on his pants and walked around shirtless through the penthouse, taking a moment to really see what he had gotten himself into. While walking however, he was very sore in certain spots that almost made it hard for him to walk. "Jeez…how much did they do to me?" He chuckled to himself while also thinking about how much stronger the two of them really were. The bedroom itself had been extremely nice with the large white bed in the middle of the room with the actual mattress feeling like you were sleeping on a cloud. The dim lights that had a warm tone to it allowed the whole place to feel comfortable and that same warm tone continued in each room. The more he explored and saw each part of the area, the more he realized who exactly he just slept with. But even as he explored, something faintly came to mind. How many people have stayed here? He noticed a photo in one of the rooms that had a photo of Mateo and someone else that wasn't Scarlet. The closer he looked, it almost looked like it was…him? But that's not possible? How—

He didn't get the chance to look into it further when he suddenly heard the two of them waking up and talking. Forgetting the image for now, he went back to the bedroom to greet the two of them. "Morning sleepyheads." He smirked, acting charming once again. Scarlet yawned and stretched while Mateo sat up looking stunning already. "Whoa. Does bedhead even exist for you?" Gally joked while rejoining them in bed to share some kisses. Scarlet kissed him and smiled softly, "Morning pumpkin." She sleepily spoke. Gally, although finding the nickname to be cute, had been confused about why she suddenly called him pumpkin. "Pumpkin? Where'd that come from?" Scarlet was confused for a second before catching her slip-up, calling him by the name she gave Gabriel, "Uhhhh it's because you uh….smelled like pumpkin last night." She came up with a poor lie. Mateo caught onto that and quickly agreed with her to really sell the lie, "She's right, ya did." Gally looked at both of them and felt like that had been an odd thing to say but he started to believe it, "Huh…I guess I did." The couple looked at each other nervously but also glad that he ended up believing it again.

Although Gally had been expecting to start the day quickly with him changing and thanking them for the passionate night together, he was pleasantly surprised when the couple pulled him down back into bed to give him more cuddles and more gentle kisses. They were taking care of him and planned to for the duration of the morning. They spent about an hour in bed to snuggle and talk before finally getting up to start having breakfast.

"So what's for breakfast?" He eagerly asked, expecting a nice home cooked meal. "i'm thinking maybe eggs and some bacon with some pancakes or maybe french toast…oooohhh I can help cook!"

"Whoa whoa whoa, easy there tiger. Teo' and I don't know how to cook." Star stopped him and chuckled.

Gally was rightfully shocked, "No freaking way. Neither of you know how to cook?! But you've got the largest kitchen I've seen! And it just goes to waste?!"

"It doesn't go to waste. Star knows how to bake." Mateo chipped in.

"Bake what?" Gally asked her.

"Like sweets and stuff. Cookies, muffins, cake, brownies-"

"None of that is breakfast stuff." He deadpanned.

"I never said it was."

"That's all just a bunch of junk food. And although I would kill for some brownies, I don't wanna eat anything fatty."

"Well listen here wise guy-" Scarlet almost flew to him but Mateo kept her grounded, "Or-! Why don't we just buy some breakfast, hm? I'll pay for it." Gally looked at him and thought about it for a second, "Fine, okay. That sounds good…"

Mateo ordered breakfast to be delivered while Gally and Star had argued over what they could cook. It wasn't a serious argument and had been a more playful one. But he insisted on teaching her on how to cook an egg even though she did know how to make that.

"An egg is easy to make! I can scramble one!" Scarlet defended herself.

"Oh yeah? I'd like to see you try." Gally smirked.

"Fine!"

Grabbing a pan and snatching an egg from Gally, she turned on the stove and cracked the egg onto the pan once it was hot enough. Gally watched, already catching her mistake of not adding oil or butter to the pan. There weren't any shells in the yolk though so that had to be good. But not realizing how high she had the heat, the scrambled egg burnt pretty quickly and she was shocked to see how fast she managed to ruin it. Gally was laughing while she stared at her ruined creation from trying to prove a point.

"I—stop laughing! It's not that funny!" She yelled at him while he was holding his stomach and laughing more. Mateo was watching nearby and could see her ruin creation. It was pretty funny that she ruined it so quick. Gally snorted with laughter. "I can't believe you messed that up!"

Star was red in the face from embarrassment as she threw the egg away and scrapped off the burnt part with the spatula. "Whatever! I just got too cocky and put the heat up high! I can make an egg!" She still tried to defend herself.

"A crispy egg." Gally corrected and laughed more.

"Y'know what? I should've made you eat that shoc—" She realized she couldn't curse how she does at home and held the word for a second before correcting herself, "—fucking egg. Yeah. I should've made you eat the fucking egg!"

"No need to get hostile, honey" Gally chuckled and kissed her as a quick apology. She scoffed but wasn't too mad anymore. Mateo came up and chuckled, "It's weird hearin' ya say it like that." It was the first time he heard her actual curse instead of saying "shock". She nodded in response, "Yeah I know…" Gally didn't hear them but it was still a funny moment for them.

Their playful banter continued until breakfast finally came. Once again, Gally was questioning them because of the amount of food they got. While he got a protein shake, a bagel, and a doughnut since Star bought some, the other two looked like they were about to have a whole feast. Two boxes of a dozen doughnuts, one box for each of them, a drink that looked like it was more sugar than an actual drink, and a bagel breakfast sandwich. He had no idea what he had just gotten into but even with some previous slip ups and odd things happening like the stars in the room, he was definitely willing to see them again if they were willing to make it happen.

Who knows though? They'd likely call him back for more.

#oc x oc

Trending Blogs

Recently Viewed Blogs

Star ☆