Not too long ago, I had the distinct pleasure of making the acquaintance of Chef Joe Letteri. Italian born, Boston raised and Dallas transplanted, he was buoyant and bursting as he detailed the fine dining experience he was seeking to cultivate in the Dallas area.
The idea is simple: an intimate "dinner party" where the guest list caps at 24 people, involves, at least, 7 - 9 courses and features fresh, local ingredients. Guests are encouraged to dine lazily, the European way, savoring each bite. Communal dining is required and conversation is encouraged. Dinner service begins promptly at a predetermined time and guests are forewarned that a late arrival does not guarantee their entry into the dining room.
I arrived at the secret location, only disclosed upon a confirmed RSVP, and was pleasantly surprised to receive a warm greeting and welcome from the Chef himself. The floor staff consisted of two individuals, neither of which, to my dismay, introduced themselves as such, but were involved in serving, bussing and attending to the needs of the diners. Their attentiveness throughout the evening waned only once, as my finished plate continued to linger before me even as the next course arrived. Whether out of necessity or desire, Chef Letteri maintained a presence in the dining room throughout the evening, conversing with guests and answering any questions, and was quick to correct the oversight.Â
While tastefully appointed, minimal decorations made it clear that Chef Letteri intended to focus on the food and the experience, not the dining room.
Eight courses were presented for consumption and below you will find the highlights and lowlights of the evening.
The first course to arrive was a potato leek soup with walnut pesto and white truffle oil. The dollops of pesto lightly floating on a sea of white beckoned to me as I slowly dipped my spoon. The texture of the soup was thick and creamy as it coated my tongue, but the flavor was light and airy, with the only interruption being the slight crunch of walnut, adding a nuttiness to an otherwise decidedly "leek-y" dish. The truffle oil added a nice finish and lent a hint of earthiness that captivatingly complimented the bright punch of the leeks.
A Swai fillet arrived, sitting atop a blue crab cake and drizzled with truffle cream. The first thing I noticed was the amazing carmelization on the outside of my Swai. A slight glimpse of the crab cake underneath, revealed a perfect sear with a gorgeous crust. The fillet was cooked to perfection, flaking gently with the pressure of my fork and seasoned only with a modicum of salt and pepper, allowing the freshness to shine. The crab cake was a delicate mix of fresh crab and breadcrumbs, providing for a texture and taste that practically melted in my mouth and the touches of truffle cream provided a nice finish.
Beef tenderloin was served on a bed of cauliflower mousse with a side of roasted asparagus. While the combination may sound pedestrian, do not let the simplicity fool you. The cut, quality and preparation of the beef tenderloin did not require the use of a knife and allowed the meat to melt away the instant I placed the fork in my mouth. The mousse was velvety smooth lending a heavenly note to the dish. The slight crunch provided by the asparagus gave a necessary punch to the dish. The flavor profiles were spot on, with seasonings kept to a minimum, allowing the quality of the ingredients to come through.
One disappointment to the evening was a Maine lobster with roasted chick peas and a pindi chana masala. At first glance, the dish piqued my interest and I was intrigued by the pairing. At first taste, however, I was let down and instantly confused about the decision to serve these ingredients together. If the aim was to evoke an Indian flavor profile, Chef Letteri failed. Instead, the overwhelming taste of cumin leant itself to a dish that was born and bred in Mexico, slightly reminiscent of a store bought packet of taco seasoning. To add injury to insult, the lobster was completely drowned out by the seasoning, and, being perfectly cooked, would have shown nicely otherwise.Â
Chef Letteri also served a dish combining venison back strap, poached pears, wild mushrooms and hand-rolled gnocchi. The dishes were originally conceived as separate entrees, with the gnocchi being served on its own, and should have stayed that way. The venison rested atop the poached pears, which were drizzled with a sweet caramel sauce. The gnocchi and the mushrooms, however, appeared to have been placed on the dish as an afterthought, lacking any flavor, including salt or pepper, and coming across as dull and lifeless on my palate. The saving grace of the dish was the combined bite of the venison, pear and caramel sauce. The sweetness of the pear and caramel served as a delightful pairing to the gaminess of the venison.  Â
As the final course, a potato gelato was served, garnished with a ruffled potato chip and drizzled with chocolate sauce. The gelato was firmer than I would have anticipated and lacked the creaminess I expected, however, to my surprise, the only hint of potato that I detected was in the slightly grainy finish. The dish was adequately sweet and did not have the starchy quality I expected, with the chocolate sauce giving an extra sweet kick.  Â
By the conclusion of the dinner, my appetite was satiated and I had walked away with a gaggle of new friends, courtesy of the communal dining. Chef Letteri is innovative and forward-thinking, using commonplace ingredients in unexpected combinations. I eagerly anticipate my next invitation and give a hearty, "Optimo!" for his efforts, concluding, as he would, with hopes to see you all...at the table.