2ruin asked: Promise me one thing—don’t pretend this was nothing. / from jeremiah fisher to belly conklin.
i can feel my hands trembling even though i’m trying so hard to steady them. the dress is heavy, the veil scratching at my neck, and every sound — the chatter of the guests, the faint music in the background — feels like it’s coming from another world. because this world, this moment, should be him. conrad. and it’s not. it’s jeremiah. and i’m supposed to be happy, and i am, but… not in the way i thought i would be. i keep seeing him — conrad — in my mind. the way his eyes used to find mine without trying. the way he could make me laugh when nothing else could. and yes, part of me will always love him a little. a little piece of my heart will always belong to him, no matter how much i try to shove it down. but that’s not the same as choosing him. choosing him would mean throwing away what i have with jeremiah. choosing him would mean ignoring the way my heart beats faster when i see jere smile, the way his hands feel in mine, the way he makes me feel like i belong, truly and completely.
i swallow hard, forcing down the panic that rises in my chest. i have to tell him — jere — everything. he deserves the truth. he deserves to know that i’ve been honest about conrad, honest about my heart, honest about where i want to be. ❝ nothing happened with conrad, ❞ i whisper to myself, the words barely leaving my lips. ❝ not at christmas. not ever. not since it's been you and me together. ❞ even saying it makes my throat tighten, because it feels like i’m defending myself against ghosts he’ll never meet. but it’s true. and it has to be true. because my heart is here. with him. even if a part of me aches for what could have been with someone else, the bigger, braver part of me knows that choosing jeremiah is choosing real love. choosing the person who sees me, who loves me, who fights for me. I love conrad, yes — but i need jere. i need him more than i’ve ever needed anyone.
promise me one thing — don’t pretend this was nothing, he says, his voice low, almost breaking. my chest tightens, and for a second i can’t breathe. how could i ever pretend? every memory of him — the laughter, the late-night talks, the way he made me feel like i mattered more than anything — it’s all stitched into me. i take a shaky breath, trying to find the right words. ❝ i could never pretend, jere, ❞ i whisper, my voice trembling. ❝ it wasn’t nothing. it could never be nothing. it’s every bit of me, every moment we ever had, and it always will be. everything i’ve ever felt for conrad, it could never compare to what i feel for you. ❞ i pause, letting the words hang between us, hoping he can feel the truth behind them. ❝ i love you, jere. i always have. ❞ the words spill out before i can stop them, raw and trembling. ❝ and yes, conrad will always be a part of me. a little piece of my heart will always belong to him — but the rest of me, the part that matters, that’s yours. that’s the part i’m choosing. you. i want us. i need us. and i can't be without you, i don't know where i end and you begin. ❞ i take a shaky breath and hold his hands in mine, like holding on will somehow make it real. ❝ please… please don’t think i’m pretending. please don’t think i’ve forgotten what we had, what we are. but I’m here, jere. i’m here, and i’m choosing you. today. tomorrow. always. ❞