7Five Brewing Shiver Giver IPA (Picked up at Total Wine). A 3 of 4. The nose is a relatively standard pine/citrus hop profile, and the body has quite a lot of caramel malt sweetness. Not an absolute ton of bitterness in the finish, so this feels slightly out of balance. But, by old-school West Coast IPA standards, this is pretty middle-of-the-pack.











