summary: after secretly getting a tattoo of your wedding along with Aaron’s initials to surprise him for your fifth anniversary, you’re forced to put your plans on hold when a difficult case sends the BAU out of state. The team accidentally discovers your secret and helps keep it hidden until you return home.
authors note: I hope you enjoy this one. This is the third time I’ve re written it after having the idea when I got another tattoo today, so I really hope you enjoy reading; your support means so much 💗💗
The anniversary had been circled on Aaron Hotchner’s calendar for months.
Not because he needed reminding.
Not because he’d ever forget.
But because after years of missed dinners, interrupted vacations, and spending birthdays in conference rooms with crime scene photos pinned to whiteboards, he’d promised himself that this year would be different.
Five years with his sweetheart.
Five years since he’d stood under a canopy of fairy lights, slipped a ring onto her finger, and quietly vowed that he would spend every day trying to deserve her.
And somehow, she still smiled at him like he hung the moon.
Which was why he had absolutely no idea that she had been keeping a secret for almost six weeks.
“Can I ask you something weird?” Garcia asked one afternoon, appearing in the doorway of your office.
You looked up suspiciously.
“With you, that sentence could mean anything.”
“Excellent point. Come with me.”
Garcia dragged you to the restroom with all the urgency of someone about to reveal classified information.
You followed her finger to the mirror.
Or rather, to the edge of your t-shirt where the fabric had shifted slightly, revealing a glimpse of ink near your collarbone.
Your hand flew up immediately.
Garcia practically vibrated.
“Is that your wedding date?”
You covered your face with both hands.
Penelope Garcia nearly cried on the spot.
“You romantic little angel.”
“Penelope, if Aaron finds out before our anniversary, I swear—”
Unfortunately, Emily Prentiss walked in three seconds later.
And then, somehow, Derek Morgan.
“How am I in trouble?” Morgan asked immediately.
“You’re not,” Garcia said.
“He’s in trouble,” Emily corrected.
“No one is in trouble,” you hissed.
“Wait.” Morgan squinted. “Is that Hotch’s initials?”
“It is absolutely none of your business.”
“Oh, pretty girl, you got his initials tattooed?”
“Sweetheart, nothing says forever like permanent ink.”
“A word and I’ll have Garcia leak your high school yearbook.”
Morgan held up both hands.
And somehow, that was the hardest part.
Because every time he smiled at you or called you honey in that soft voice he only used when no one else was listening, you wanted to blurt it out.
The anniversary dinner reservations disappeared beneath stacks of files and packed suitcases.
“Sorry, sweetheart,” Aaron said quietly while throwing clothes into his duffel. “We’ll make it up when we get back.”
But you knew he hated it.
You could see it in the way his shoulders tensed.
The way he kept checking the date.
The way his eyes softened every time they landed on you.
By day four, everyone was exhausted.
The unsub had changed patterns.
The local police were frustrated.
And Aaron hadn’t slept more than three hours at a time.
You stood over the map in the conference room, staring at photos until they blurred together.
“We’re missing something,” Aaron said.
“No, we’re missing something.”
“No.” His voice sharpened.
Aaron closed his eyes immediately.
But stress was wearing all of you thin.
“Aaron,” you started softly.
“No.” He pinched the bridge of his nose. “Forget it.”
And then quietly walked out.
Morgan looked at the ceiling.
JJ suddenly found her coffee fascinating.
Emily physically backed away.
Because everyone knew that Aaron Hotchner never raised his voice at you.
And everyone knew he was already regretting it.
You sat on the steps outside the station, arms folded against the evening air.
Two minutes later, the door opened.
“I didn’t even make it to the hallway before I knew I was wrong.”
“You snapped because you’re exhausted.”
“No.” You looked over. “Aaron, we’ve been chasing a monster for four days.”
“That doesn’t excuse it.”
“You should never have to absorb my bad days.”
“Good thing I love you, then.”
After a moment, he slipped his hand into yours.
“I know this isn’t how either of us wanted our anniversary.”
He looked almost offended.
“Sweetheart, I remember what you ordered on our first date.”
“You stole half my dinner.”
The unsub was caught the next morning.
Everyone flew home exhausted and relieved.
Garcia insisted on decorating your office with enough balloons to violate several fire codes.
Emily claimed she had nothing to do with any of it while actively hanging streamers.
And Aaron walked in halfway through the chaos.
Garcia whistled innocently.
“You’re a terrible liar.”
The team filtered out with suspicious speed.
Leaving the two of you alone.
Aaron leaned against your desk.
“Still putting up with me.”
“Still stealing your food.”
You stepped into his arms immediately.
His chin rested on top of your head.
You’d been married five years.
You reached up and gently moved the collar of your t-shirt aside.
He stopped breathing for a second.
He stared at it again like he wasn’t sure it was real.
“It was supposed to be a surprise before Oklahoma.”
“A surprise,” he repeated softly.
His hand came up, fingers feather-light against your skin.
Like he had all the time in the world.
When he pulled away, he rested his forehead against yours.
“You know,” he murmured, “I’ve spent five years wondering how I got so lucky.”
“You tell me that every anniversary.
“Because every year, I’m more convinced that I married entirely above my station.”
And then the office door burst open.
Morgan, Garcia, JJ, and Emily all fell inside.
Nobody had even tried to pretend they weren’t listening.
Garcia gasped dramatically.
“Since the bathroom incident,” Emily admitted.
“You people are unbelievable.”
“You love us,” Garcia informed him.
And for the first time in days, the weight of the case was gone.
Just Aaron’s arm around your waist.
His thumb absentmindedly tracing over the tiny initials he’d spent five years earning.
And as everyone argued over cupcakes and Garcia demanding pictures, Aaron leaned down and whispered softly into your hair—
“Happy anniversary, honey.”
And if he had anything to say about it—
There would be fifty more.