So after buying a flannel shirt a couple weeks ago, and seriously questioning why it’s taken me 30-odd years to discover this wonderful thing, @once-a-polecat suggested trying one of these shirts for a cut-for-women option that maybe has room for huge aerialist shoulders. (I’ve been away from it for about 10 months now. I’m still stacked.)
I’m between sizes, so given shoulder issues and that I’ll be wearing it over t-shirts, I went for the larger size. As you can see in the top two photos, it’s unsurprisingly kind of a sack - it’s about four inches too wide (when laid flat) through the chest, waist, and hips. I’m pinching it where my waist actually is. But, the shoulders and arms fit! The shoulder seams are actually on my shoulders! I can move my arms fully and it doesn’t rip the hell out of my armpits! And the cuffs are a good length!
I’ll tailor down the sides, which will help. I can’t do much about it being too wide across the chest, since that’s level with the armpit, and I’m not messing with that. I don’t need it to fit closely, that’s not the point of a flannel shirt. But a bit less like a tent would be good.
These photos were taken before washing it, and it did shrink a bit. So keep that in mind if you’re buying one. The fabric is heavy and feels like it’s good quality, though it’s only moderately fuzzy by flannel standards.
We’ll see how it feels with alterations and more wearing, but so far, 8/10, would buy again.