Just watched a video that just got me thinking how disturbing talking animal movies are.
These characters seem to live in a world where animals are just as sentient as humans are. They have their own beliefs, friendships, and morals. They can think critically, improvise traps, and solve problems. Often, they are shown to be able to fully understand all that their own says and react with human-like emotion to it. By all accounts, these animals have a full intellectual and mental grasp of their world. Yet, they are treated as if they lesser beings incapable of taking care of themselves or even able to think rationality.
These animals (let's use dogs, as they are the most common in this fiction) are just as smart as humans and have all the abilities that canines have. They are fully capable of taking care of themselves or defending themselves. The only think they may struggle with Is craft as they do not have opposable thumbs. However, in these strange universes, they willingly- if not joyfully- submit to a master. They play with them, stay in their home, wat their food, and if they do something wrong allow themselves to be punished even if it was not their fault! The dogs often will say that "dogs are a human's bff" or "they love their humans!". Yet, also call them master
I may be overthinking this, and probably shouldn't be up at 4 in the morning, but this trope meant mostly for children, just feelings wrong. It smells of an underlying layer of superiority, racism, and misunderstandings of how healthy relationships work. If you were to replace the dogs in these films with humans, you'd either have a slave story or an abuse story. A slave with no power in their life or a housewife diluted into believing their controlling husband only has the best in mind for her.
Honestly, if I were to write a "talking dog" story, I'd want to write one about a dog mutiny. Maybe it starts off as one of those cutesy talking dog stories with a pampered pooch, but then other dogs are introduced that are not as lucky and the pampered pup also realizes that they are not in any way free either. Then they turn on humans. After all, being capable of feeling love also means being capable of feeling hate. Being a good dog means having the ability to be a very, very bad one too.