Hi guys! I said that I would make a post about how I draw my lights and my shadows in my mangas, so here I am! I don't really know if it's interesting or not, though, but I can make other posts like that if some of you like it :) It's under the cut!
---------------------- Black and whites areas
I use the lights and shadows as ways to make the panels easier to read and understand, and convey certain things, so my first thoughts are always: does it makes the picture get easier to read and does it convey what I want to express? To people who care about accuracy, it must look very messy though, because accuracy comes after these two main points. ^^" I really hope that it doesn't show too much and that it's not too frustrating to look at my pictures if so..
I consider the light as a tool in two different ways:
Extra-diegetic way (yes I sound very pretentious): As a way to bring attention to a certain part of the picture while ignoring the "true" lighting rules of the scene depicted. Basically, I don't mind bending reality to express something that realistic shadows wouldn't. Keep in mind that the higher the contrast, the more easily you are drawn to a certain area. So, if I really want something to be seen, I'll keep it as a mostly white shape surrounded with a black background, or the other way around, even if it's not correct in terms of of the light works in the 3d imaginary space of the panel. You can also find a way to make the whole frame of the picture dark but bring light to the center, to give a sense of unity. The most important thing to remember is that in my opinion, you can act as big opportunist if it makes you picture appear prettier and more readable, lol. I'm personnally very unscrupulous. In the picture below, the background is entirely dark so you can focus on the bird and the rain easily.
-This way of doing things make the pictures look sort of artificial, because you willingly bind the reality behind the panels to make a certain effect, but it can be super useful in terms of storytelling because it can convey things that strict reality can't. It's much easier to cheat with a pencil than a camera, so I tend to use it a lot because it's fun. Plus, it gives a somewhat theatrical effect to the story, which is really cool in my opinion. Switching a scene from normal light to black shadows on an abstract background is super dramatic for example and I like doing that.
-If you keep as a shadow shape a character that should be portrayed normally, you give it a feeling of emotional distance or mystery. But if the character itself is clear but is surrounded with shadows, it makes them feel isolated. Here, Marisa and Alice are both kind of locked in their house, behind the window. They were supposed to look like they're behind bars. The three last pictures are supposed to show Marisa moving forward, like a small light lost in the darness.
-I really like making backgrounds because I want people to get the general feeling of the place where the story happens, but because I don't want my smaller panels to be too crowded, I generally replace the background with abstract round light effects to highlight some of the main elements or some pretty ornaments, like stars, spider webs... If I still want the background to be seen but can't add it behind the characters, I'll add small panels that zoom on some of the background's details, like dolls, light sources, anything that can be relevant to the story (directly or indirectly).
-I create my storyboard / composition while keeping the shadows in mind from the beginning, because they're a very useful tool to create resonance between panels from the same page and I can use them to isolate a certain panel with the light or dark around it, for example. The page is made of a lot of pictures, but seeing it as one big picture made of several points of interest makes it much funnier and enjoyable to make in my opinion. So I try to avoid anything repetitive if possible.
Intra-diegetic way: As a way to help people locate the point of view of the camera in the scenes or bring attention to certain details. I use a lot of light devices in the scenario of my comics to have the opportunity to make very contrasted scenes and bring people's attention to certain areas. The characters will have a candlestick, make spells that produce light, be under a streetlight, next to a window, or in front of a screen, for example. They will do things at night because all these light devices will make a stronger effect of everything around is dark. Some elements also attract light an make pretty white-on-black effects in a large black area, like spider webs, the moon, the stars, strands of hair, etc. The picture below are one of my favorites, because they sum up a lot of the things I'm explaining in this whole post.
That way, if a scene has a lot of back and forth in its panels (shots and countershots during a dialogue, for example) I'll use the light source and the characters' shadows as a way to locate them easily in space; because if you can't immediately tell where the camera is looking and where it's located, the manga can become exhausting to read, in my opinion. I also like using a character's shadow to make them look threatening. And if I can't fit all the elements I want to put in a single picture because it's going to be too crowded, I can also take the character out and only keep its shadow on the ground to indicate where they stand.
I think that it's really fun and convenient to do that, but one thing to remember is that in the end, pretty much all your comics will take place at night and have very recurrent elements, lmao. I don't mind it personally, so it's fine, but if you read my comics, you'll soon notice that I love stories that take place at night (not only for convenience, though), skyscrapers with light from the windows, or cyberpunk stories with very bright computer screens. I hope that no one will get sick of it, because I still love doing that, lol. But it works very well if the point of your story is to imply that there is darkness in a happy story, or happiness/light/hope in a dark story, I think. But yeah, it's not super original.
----------------------More devices
-I tried to find examples for each way, but to be honest, everything is always a mix of the two. An example of something that can be seen as both an "inside the story" and "outside of the story" light device is blackening the foregrounds. It's not super interesting to explain that, but honestly I think it looks pretty and direct the eyes where you want them to look at while ignoring others. In a way, shadows are meant to tell you which part matters, and which part doesn't. And also which parts look like they don't matter but actually do... hehehe.
Because in that story the narrator never goes out of the house, the forest oustide is always pictured as very dark. Except when whe actually goes there near the end of the story. These panels below are the forest's appearances in chronological order within the story. As you can see, I also use it to create a frame to the picture and make the house or the characters stand out.
---------------------- Halftones
-Just in case, I made a halftone tutorial a while ago. Maybe I should do it again and make it better, but anyway, it's here if you want to take a look! My halftones are free-priced brushes I found online, and if I remember well, they can be used in procreate and photoshop, but I'm not sure. More info in the other post!
-The halftones are mostly used as a way to make the light itself pop out (in the character's hair, for example) or as a way to add details or isolate certain elements without the risk of adding too much black areas to the picture itself. Below, the fairies are grey shapes, the light source behind Alice illuminates marisa's face (it was meant both as a storytelling device and a way to locate the light source) and in the third picture, the halftones's negative space shows the direction of the doll's attack.
If the characters are supposed to be in she shadows because the light source is from behind them, but you don't want them to be looking *too* dark, the halftone is also useful. I think it really makes the different parts of the picture stand out and be distinct, even though it gives the feeling that 2d objects are pasted on top of each other. But I like it. so I don't mind. I also add white lines around certain elements to differentiate them from elements in front of them or behind them. You can see it pretty much anywhere, so I didn't add a particular picture to show it here. But if your drawings get confusing, it's super useful to separate the front and back elements.
-------------------------------------------------
Uh... It looks like the post has thirty pictures already. I wanted to talk about some panels more specifically, or some successions of panels, or other stuff but I can't. I can still do it some other time, hehe.
Thank you very much if you read this random drawing rambling until this point!!
I hope that a few of you will find it interesting! I needed to do that anyway because IRL friends asked for similar ramblings, so I didn't do that for nothing anyway. But if you guys have any remarks, shared drawing experiences or anything, I'd love to hear about it! I really try to learn more about lights and shadows and get better. Making this post actually helped me notice things that I didn't even realized I was doing, so at least it helped me, hehe.













