truly cannot imagine shipping Alina with someone that sold her best friend into a sex trade and then also mutilated the same bff. go off, I guess.
And I can’t imagine coming into someone’s inbox to insult them on an anon for their fictional preferences because I’m too afraid to show my face, but here we are.
But hey. I’ll address the accusation. Because I’m not a fan of your word choice and I don’t think it captures what happened in canon.
First off, I’ve never defended his mutilation of Genya. In fact that was the deed that sealed for me that the Darkling wasn’t going to get a redemption. There are certain actions authors will have their character do to over emphasize evil and that’s one of them. I think it was a little over the top from a writer’s perspective, but in universe, yeah, it’s definitely horrible.
The whole ‘sex trade’ thing. I don’t understand why people assume the Darkling knew what was going to happen to Genya when he gave her to the queen.
First off, being made servant to a queen in a monarchy would be a huge honor for someone not born into the nobility. According to the story she has a good relationship with the queen at the start and isn’t mistreated. The Darkling places her there to be a potential spy. Not because he’s lying in wait for the king to start going after her. He just hopes she might hear things he can use.
Then the king does start going after her and she comes to the Darkling for help. He doesn’t say ‘sucks, you’ve gotta keeping doing it because it’s part of my grand plan’. He gives her a choice. He can send her away to a place she will be safe or she can stay and have her revenge on the king. She chooses the latter.
Now, is it fair to put that choice on a young woman (it’s unclear her age at this point)? No of course not. Is the Darkling thinking of how he can use this awful situation to his advantage? Yes he is. But he does give her an out. A chance to not be a part of any of it.
People ask why the Darkling didn’t just protect Genya from the king or bring her back to the Little Palace. And I think those people.... don’t understand how monarchy works? The Darkling has to do what the king says. If he tried to protect Genya or remove her from the queen’s service, the king could have said ‘no’. And the Darkling needs to toe a line with him. The best thing he could do for Genya was send her away. Out of sight, out of mind for the king.
If he was like... a moral guy, he would have sent her away without putting the choice to her. But he’s the villain, so here we are. I don’t exactly ship him and Alina for their moral righteousness. But at the end of the day ‘sold into a sex trade’ is complete hyperbole to what happened. ‘Took advantage of a girl’s abuse to overthrow a king’ is closer.
Anyway that’s my two cents on the Genya thing. And probably the last time I’m gonna answer anons about it because now you guys know my stance— it was bad, but the Darkling is often given more blame than the actual king, and Also the Darkling is a villain so he’s gonna do bad things. That’s how villain x hero ships go