Charlie’s face when Mac lacks........self-awareness.
Each gif’s context available under "keep reading”
From left to right of each row:
1) “The Gang Group Dates”...Dennis says “You get your self-worth from when you convince yourself that you're tough and that you're straight.”....Mac says “I’m tough.” Cue Charlie face.
2) “The Gang Tends Bar”...Mac says “Because I show no outward signs of being gay, and that’s just the end of the story.” Cue Charlie face.
3) “Hero or Hate Crime?”...Mac says “I honestly have no idea what you’re talking about.” Cue Charlie face.
4) “The Gang Misses the Boat”...Mac says [to Dennis] “But no one was ever good enough for you, man...” Cueeeee Charlie Face.
5) “The Gang Tends Bar”...Mac’s line from gif #2.
6) “Psycho Pete Returns”...Mac says “Look, dude, I feel guilty all the time for my thoughts and urges...” Charlie’s face responds accordingly.
7) “Dennis’ Double Life”...Mac says “Just go with me here – Brian's not above having a one-night stand with a woman, but he's got no room for her emotionally – because he's in love with me." Charlie briefly overviews idea, the his face responds to undertones.
8) “Ass-Kickers United: Mac and Charlie Join a Cult”...Mac says “It could not have been more clear – no women, no gays.” Charlie does his eye thing, while saying “I don't ever remember you reading anything about that...”
9) “Dee Gives Birth”...Mac says “Well, clearly they're working for her, 'cause Rex is a quality lay.” Charlie necessarily pulls face in reply.