Do you think Okhubo regretes making Kid be a charachter everybody just found out about a few days into the story and not someone who had prior history with any charachters besides his dad, patty and Liz?
I am way too mean to Ohkubo for a lot of things that are me overreacting.
(That doesn’t include how he handles girls, women, and fanservice, because, LOL, no, that fucker has that criticism coming.)
(Oh, and spoilers below for Soul Eater and Fire Force. And a content warning regarding potentially disablist representations or arguments.)
It is hard for me not to look at how he handled Kid and not think, “You passed up so many storytelling opportunities.”
Some of this, I think, is just out of his sense of humor, the equivalent of saying, “I could do this kind of story–but it’s funnier if Lord Death just one day made another child out of nowhere and based it off of the guy from 800+ years ago that brought him into existence.”
There are at least two reasons why that “joke” doesn’t work for me.
First, if you keep having joke after joke without moments of sentimentality or just honest affection, the jokes drag, and the serious moments fall apart. We are supposed to care about Kid when he sees his father has died. I don’t ignore that, yeah, that moment of Lord Death dying, and Kid learning about it, both land. But I think those moments would land better if you had more there to make us think Kid and Lord Death had a deeper relationship–which is harder when Kid seems like he barely had a childhood.
(There is a counter-argument that I will address, as all of this does explain how Kid turned out how he did, and how Kid and Lord Death are just not human–but I’ll get to that in a moment.)
Second, I get little sense Ohkubo knows how to represent varieties of parenting in his story, or a refusal to show them. It’s not as if there aren’t untraditional families in his all of his works–but those are either ones fans read into (Blair as more of a parental figure to Soul and Maka instead of…whatever the hell that last chapter was about) or ones that Ohkubo confirms in the story (Sid took in Black Star) but doesn’t pay off (Has anyone felt any sense of a familial bond from Black Star to Sid? I don’t mean whether Black Star has parental regard for Sid–I mean, has there ever been any sense that Black Star sees Sid as anything other than just another teacher at the DWMA?).
This isn’t to ignore that there are parents in his works, whether literal (Spirit is a well-developed parent, and I do find Maka’s regard for him to be earned in-story given what was shown to us) or otherwise untraditional (although some of it is either like a “big brother” like Yohei in B Ichi, or just confusing and underdeveloped, like Akitaru’s role towards Shinra in Fire Force).
This leads to my counter-argument. I am convinced by fans who say, “Kid being introduced so late, and then Fire Force showing his origins in the finale, explains how Kid turned out how he did, and how Lord Death just screwed up as a parent to him and Asura.” Like, Lord Death just makes a child–and skips past baby stage, maybe even preschool stages, so that Kid is formed as more of a little adult rather than an actual baby and an actual child who has to slowly learn about the world and develop mentally and emotionally. Given how Kid behaves in the manga, and how Lord Death regards him, all of this checks out: regardless how much Lord Death did love Kid, and how the story insists he was making him to be his own person, there is still all of this other content that emphasizes that Lord Death saw Kid as his heir, and did handle his creation and development as preparation to be the next shinigami, not to be a human being.
Which is also part of this counter-argument: if there is any good in Ohkubo’s choices, it lets him show how a shinigami like Lord Death and Kid differ from other people–because Lord Death made choices that a human wouldn’t typically make, and maybe that explains how Kid turned out, both genetically and socially. That being said, while it lets Ohkubo _show_ it, it all still feels half-baked and reliant more on what readers bring into the story than what the creator clearly shows. And I think this all raises really uncomfortable questions (given how Kid has been read as having obsessive compulsion and maybe other mental and behavioral conditions, writing all of that off as “he’s just not human” seems disablist).
So, no, I don’t think Ohkubo regrets making Kid be a character everyone just found out about a few days into the story–because, sorry, I don’t think he planned much well. He avoided storytelling options: just as we don’t get to see Black Star’s regard for Sid after he dies, we don’t really get to see how the rest of the DWMA, and the world, views Kid. It helps with worldbuilding (if you suppose that Lord Death kept Kid’s identity secret to avoid him being a target, and out of his own desire to focus Kid on training to be a shinigami rather than having a, ahem, “normal” childhood as a student). But then we don’t get canon stories about, say, how Spirit regarded little Kid, or the other Death Scythes, or whether people who were involved with the DWMA since they were babies (Maka and Black Star) may have encountered Kid. Even when he gets the chance to “fix” any of this with the ending of Fire Force, he just doubles down: “Lord Death made Kid a small child at birth, there was no baby kid, all your fanfics are ruined–oh, and I’m going to pretend Kid always looked like Shinra when, no, he fucking doesn’t.”











