What are your thoughts on instead of young Derek falling in love with Paige, he falls in love with Stiles, and instead of Paige dying, Stiles dies (But he comes back to life later because I can’t handle the pain). Idk if anyone has already thought of this, or made a fanfic on it, but I’ve been through the young Derek tag on AO3 and I haven’t seen anything like it.
There’s a fic called Fly a Little Faster, which involves time travel, which is sort of what you’re describing. You should definitely check it out if you’re interested in a play on the Paige situation with young!Sterek.
And yeah, I 100% think Derek would’ve fallen for Stiles if they’d been the same age in high school. Paige was written to mirror Stiles in a lot of ways (and they even picked an actress with a lot of similarities, appearance-wise), so all the snark, challenge, and slight misfit tendencies that drew Derek to Paige would have drawn him to Stiles as well.
One thing I’ve got to wonder about, though, is whether things would’ve hit the point of manipulations and uncontrollable Alphas if Derek were with Stiles. Because as similar as they are, there’s one major difference between Paige and Stiles.
We find out, when Paige is dying, that she’d known what Derek was, more or less. She’d known there were supernatural things happening in town, she was clever and observant and she’d pieced it together (another way she and Stiles are similar).
But she didn’t say anything. She kept it to herself. And I have to wonder, if Stiles was in the same position –– if he’d been picking up on the same stuff, if he’d noticed his boyfriend prooobably had some supernatural weirdness going on... would he have stayed quiet about it? Or would he have done what he’d done in the very first episode with Scott, come out and said “hey dude, you kind of seem like a werewolf.”
And really though, think about it. If Stiles had noticed Derek picking up sounds he shouldn’t be hearing, being stronger than he should’ve been, he would’ve commented. And if Stiles had commented, even jokingly, about his boyfriend being some kind of wolfman, would Derek have still agreed to let his boyfriend be given the bite without so much as a conversation first?
With Paige, Peter manipulated the hell out of Derek, ostensibly through some serious fear of rejection. That’s why he agreed to let Ennis bite her first, and didn’t talk to her about it. But if Stiles had already opened that door –– and we know Stiles would have. Especially early Stiles, season one Stiles? He was not the quietly observing and keeping theories from his loved ones type –– I can’t imagine that Derek wouldn’t brave a conversation before asking Ennis to bite him.
Of course, Peter might just decide to “helpfully” arrange the attack anyway, that’s definitely a Peter move. And things might’ve played out exactly the same either way.
But I’m curious to know what everyone else thinks. If Stiles had been in Paige’s place back then, would he have mentioned his boyfriend’s supernatural hotness? Would Derek have felt emboldened enough to be honest, and to ask him if he wanted the bite, instead of making the choice for him? And, ultimately, would that have changed anything or would Stiles have met the same fate Paige did?














