Preference: You Catch Sarah’s Characters Masturbating
Billie would be annoyed at herself for not thinking about locking the door, but when you eyed her, eyebrow quirking up, then damn, was she glad she didn’t. She had to orgasm now, so she swayed over to you, letting the sheets fall from her body.
“Get over here and kiss me.”
Lana would ramp up her reactions. She would slyly smirk, open her legs wider, and moan your name louder, as her hand moved faster and faster. Why would she be embarrassed? She needed you, right now.
“Think you can give me a hand, Y/N?”
My angel would be so embarrassed, especially when she was caught mid-orgasm, hissing your name. Cordelia would shriek and almost fall off the bed as she tried to cover herself up. You couldn’t help it—you laughed when she saw the mess she got herself into. Cordelia would be mumbling apologies, but you wouldn’t mind. At all.
“Y/N! Oh my god, how long have you been standing there?”
Anytime the girls took care of themselves (which was rare), they always made sure to lock the door. But when they glanced up, you were standing in the doorway, mouth gaping open. Whatever your reaction was, they would both react with embarrassment. Bette would yank her hand away, and Dot would grab the blanket. Though, if you offered to help, I’m sure they wouldn’t decline.
Sally wouldn’t be embarrassed at all. In fact, she would only be more aroused with your eyes on her. She would spread her legs wider and moan for your help. The only other option was to grab you and pull you down with her.
“Oh, baby . . . I—ah!—need a bit of help here.”
Audrey would a flustered mess. She would shriek and try to run away, but you blocked her way. So, Audrey would hide under the covers as you flopped next to her. It would take some coaxing to get her to meet your eyes, though she would feel better when you told you didn’t mind. At all.
“Oh my god, I’m so sorry!”
Ally would be the most mature about it. Though she would be a bit embarrassed, she would stop and pretend everything was normal. But you wouldn’t let her go away that quickly. Round two would commence.
“Oh, Y/N! I didn’t know you were home!”
Wilhemina would be a tiny bit embarrassed, but she would make you forget about her. She would grab you and dominate you until you couldn’t even remember your own name, let alone walking onto her. You would only laugh and tell her not to worry.