Book Review: “This is All a Dream We Dreamed: An Oral History of the Grateful Dead” by Blair Jackson & David Gans
Virtually no one outside the Grateful Dead’s inner circle knows more about the band than Blair Jackson and David Gans.
Between them, Jackson and Gans have written seven Grateful Dead books, edited a fanzine and hosted radio programs about the band beyond description.
So when the pair decided to write yet another book about the legendary group - whose long, strange, 30-year trip paved the way for bands like moe., Widespread Panic and Phish - they went back to those who lived it and some who died doing it.
Acting more as editors than authors, Jackson and Gans skillfully weave together decades worth of archival and original interviews to tell one of rock’s most unlikely tales. And in the process, the authors-cum-editors also manage to dig up revelatory material 20 years after Jerry Garcia’s 1995 death at 53 - a remarkable feat.
The result is “This is All a Dream We Dreamed,” a thoroughly engrossing oral biography of the group that includes input from every band member (except the famously quiet Keith Godchaux and lyricist John Perry Barlow), friends, family (both blood and “thicker than blood”), promoters and - in one of the book’s rare missteps - members of Dark Star Orchestra to tell the Dead’s unique story.
Legendary concert promoter and unabashed Deadhead Bill Graham sums up the Grateful Dead’s impact perhaps better than anyone ever has when he says:
“But if the Dead gave me the highest experience of my life, they also gave me the seventh, nineteenth, twenty-sixth - so many separate experiences with the Dead are part of my top fifty or one hundred experiences.”
The speakers take readers on a three-decade journey from Magoo’s Pizza Parlor, where the nascent Grateful Dead played its first gig in 1965, to Soldier Field, where the American institution performed its final concert in 1995. In between are stops at the Acid Tests; Woodstock; the Great American Music Hall; Cairo, Egypt; Club Front; and Deer Creek among other famous and infamous Dead haunts.
Readers who lived some or all of it receive unexpectedly vivid insight into the eras they may have missed and are given the chance to compare their memories to what actually happened during their time on the bus. It’s a rare and different tome that allows for such enjoyable reading and “This is All a Dream We Dreamed” keeps the magic going over all of its 512 pages.
Younger Deadheads will revel in hearing Pigpen in his own words - Jackson and Gans seem to have used virtually everything available from the late Ron McKernan - and musings from family members such as Carolyn “Mountain Girl” Garcia, Rosie McGee, Ken Babbs, Steve Parrish, Ken Kesey and Wavy Gravy.
Also revealing are sections on the band reintegrating Mickey Hart after the 1974-‘76 hiatus and their struggles as keyboardists Brent Mydland (1979-1990), Bruce Hornsby (1990-‘92) and Vince Welnick (1990-‘95) found their footing among five musicians who spoke a unique musical language.
It’s interesting to note that vocalist Donna Jean Godchaux, Mydland, Hornsby and Welnick, more often refer the the band as “they” rather than “we” when speaking of their time as Grateful Dead members.
The book is highly recommended for both hard-core and new Deadheads because it paints with a broad brush and also fills in small gaps in the tapestry - and Deadheads love minutiae.
Jackson and Gans declare Hornsby a full-fledged member of the band in the Who’s Who section by calling him “Grateful Dead keyboardist;” they reveal that Hart was a huge fan of Saturday Night Fever and may have been responsible for the Dead’s mid-'70s disco arrangement of “Dancing in the Street;” they cite Bob Weir claiming he doesn’t forget the words to “Truckin’” so much as he has a hard time getting them out because they’re tongue-twisting; and they prove Hart to be a clairvoyant percussionist with this prescient quote from 1980:
“In 1990, we’ll be absolute killers! We’re pretty good now, but if we keep healthy, we’ll go on. Look at Count Basie and (Duke) Ellington. There’s no reason we couldn’t be one of the dance bands that last thirty years.”
Given that many band members and several fans cite 1988-1990 as the band’s high-water mark and that the Grateful Dead lasted exactly 30 years, this statement is remarkable on many - two, that is - levels.
If the book has a flaw, it’s that it comes to a screeching halt with Garcia’s death in 1995 and doesn’t even attempt to address any of the post-Grateful Dead collaborations the surviving members have played in during the intervening two decades. Instead, the book includes a handful of appendices that appear to serve no purpose other than to allow the authors to use material they couldn’t otherwise fit into the book proper.
In the end, it doesn’t really matter, because “This is All a Dream We Dreamed” is undeniably the best Grateful Dead book to be published since “Darkstar,” Robert Greenfield’s 1996 oral biography of Garcia, and a must-read for both die-hard fans and those who just want to know what all the fuss was about.
Grade card: “This is All a Dream We Dreamed: An Oral History of the Grateful Dead” by Blair Jackson & David Gans - A-






