Elementary Sherlock, BBC Sherlock, Jeremy Brett Sherlock, Basil Rathbone Sherlock, Robert Downey Jr. Sherlock, Larry the Cucumber Sherlock.
Push off a cliff: RDJ Sherlock. It wouldn’t really hurt him in the end – pushing Holmeses off of cliffs never does – but he’d know how pissed I am about his pulling that floral armchair shit on Hotson.
Kiss: Larry the Cucumber Sherlock. He’d blush and giggle, and that would be the end of it.
Marry: Elementary Sherlock. You know it’d be some in name only poppycock about taxes or immigration with him, he’d have no actual interest in being married-married. We’d each do our thing, and one day he’d say to Joan, just to get a rise out of her, “Oh, I’ve been married for the last seven years, did I never mention that?”
Set on Fire: BBC Sherlock. He’ll no doubt escape due to an eleventh-hour retcon, but I’d enjoy the attempt.
Wrap a Blanket around: Jeremy Brett Sherlock. Because he just kept getting sicker and sicker, and I desperately need to put a warm blanket around him and make him all better. :-(
Be Roommates with: Rathbone Sherlock. This is guesswork (I haven’t seen any of the Rathbone films!), but he’s from an era when Sherlocks were still allowed to have manners, which is an encouraging sign. Plus, the Universal Baker Street set was nice and spacious, so even if we got on each other’s nerves, we’d still have plenty of room to get away from each other.