The San Francisco Board of Supervisors, acting as the San Francisco County Transportation Authority commission, will decide whether to provide the $60 million SFMTA needs for early replacement of the aging Breda trains.
Supervisors delayed the funding last April after San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency officials encountered multiple mechanical issues on the new trains — passengers were caught between the train’s doors, wheels had flattened and an issue arose with the train’s coupler system.
An outside firm was hired to look into the issues involving the LRV4s.
At a meeting last month, SFMTA director of Transit Julie Kirshbaum told the Supervisors that Siemens has addressed the defects, including the coupler problems. You never want to discover any flaw with a new type train after it's started passenger service or entered mass production, but the practical reality is some problems just won't turn up until riders have put some wear and tear on them.
The shear pin problem indicates that the train’s couplers are absorbing more force than what they can handle at specific intersections — a design issue that Siemens should have initially anticipated given San Francisco’s steep grades and sharp turns, Kirschbaum said.
“There’s 10 times more force at those intersections than Siemens anticipated when they designed the coupler. Now that they know the problem, they can fix it.”
Supervisor Aaron Peskin, who lead the effort to block funding last year, is now onboard:
“I have increasingly become convinced that they are on the right path [and] that all the numbers are moving in the right direction. This is a product that The City should acquire particularly as the old aging Breda fleet is failing and becoming outdated.”