Discover Top Posts Tagged with #bsd theory

Popular Recent

What's all this talk about choosing? People need to realise Dazai and Chuuya's bond is no ordinary and they are literally said to be 2 souls in different bodies. they never have to ACT in order to understand each other and mind you all... next time you doubt their bond, go see what they did to Fypdor after he called their bond "shallow".

You do realise if Dazai and Chuuya actually knew you were talking about this they'd find you and Fyodoize you? *JUST look the the manga for accuracy*

Seriously could we stop with all the Dazia would choose Oda and Chuuya would choose flags and whatever?

Both Chuuya and Dazai lost their precious people, Dazai lost Oda and Chuuya lost flags and many more. What stays consistent is the fact that despite everything... they still haven't changed. The bond they formed over the years is so strong and deep that cannot be put into words. The manga clearly showed the depth of their relationship when they were against Fyodor.

Dazai appreciates Chuuya. This boy literally took his breath away when he met him at 15 and CONTINUES to do so. Chuuya is his FIRST reason for living and finding life interesting.

Oda was a dear friend Dazai met along the way and the one impacted his life path.

Like yes Dazai found life worth giving a shot (cause of Chuuya) but Oda helped him choose the path (good or bad).

Let's not forget in one AU Chuuya is said to leave along with him as well and join the agency.

For Chuuya, flags were his first real friends. The ones that actually cared for him not for his power.

But no matter what happens and how many different people come into their lives...

Dazai and Chuuya are still Dazai and Chuuya to each other, partners in crime who understand each other without needing words.

Did anyone ever think about Fyodor's ability having more than one use? Like Shibusawas for example(keeping him alive and collecting crystal abilities). Perhaps Crime is the killing by touch and Punishment is taking over other persons body when he's killed. I know this sounds op but I also have a theory that crime must be used before punishment and vice versa/ he can't use crime part of his ability twice in a row, same with punishment.

#this would explain the whole karma scene #because no way he teamed up with nathaniel that early right?#bsd fyodor #bsd theory #bsd fyodor dostoevsky #fyodor bsd #fyodor dostoyevsky bsd #bungou stray dogs fyodor #bsd #kofein talks #bungou stray dogs

ON OR ONTO SOMETHING??

Wait, FUCK, no, I AM onto something. It's the SAME scrap of paper I swear.

Oh god the quality is shit. Whatever. I tried to explain it as best as I could.

These aside, we only see the page (not counting cameos) in chapters 119 and 121. Throughout chapter 121 we can only see one side of the page. Even when Kyouka is handing Atsushi the scrap in 129.5, it's the same empty side we've been seeing. Atsushi flips it over to look at the inner side, and even then, we, as the readers, see the other (empty) side. I don't know what's on the other and what Atsushi saw. Fyodor said he used one side of it and told Atsushi he'd give the other side to him to write on.

Now I don't remember if he explained anything later on with things such as "oh no this wasn't the page at all I wrote it on smth else" so I'll pretend it really is THE page of the book and that there really is smth written on the inner side. I don't remember missing such a crucial part but idk it's best to be cautious.

In 119 there is barely a moment where we seem to see the "inner" side but that could easily be twisted as there is no smooth transformation between panels. And what use is there to pretend that's it's THE page you said you wrote on if both sides are empty? Anyone could figure out you're lying. So I'm choosing to believe there are writing on that side.

Moving on. As you see in the image, as Atsushi is in despair, Fyodor's gaze lingers on the inner side of the page scrap. Mind you the same "scrap" that teleported Atsushi to the other side of the world. I have no idea how it activated but that ain't my point.

If it really is the right bottom corner (or any of the bottom corners) as I figured, then it makes sense to think Fyodor filled the page, saved the last sentences to get Atsushi to London and deliver him into Agatha's hands as the last part of his plan.

But that makes me think about whether Kyouka saw whats on it or not. Maybe she grabbed it in a hurry to reach Atsushi and didn't read it.

AND THE REASON I THINK THE SCRAP WAS PLANTED IS:

I firmly believe that the rain when the Hunting Dogs gathered wasn't for atmosphere purposes only. The area where Fyodor ripped the page was open, no rubble nearby. (It's also the place where Tanizaki, Kenji and Fukuzawa were "killed", Kunikida's was nearby) You can maybe say it got a little dusty because of those creatures but it wasn't even close to that chaos area. Atsushi and Akutagawa had already distanced themselves from there because Fyodor was making a move for the plane. If it hadn't been collected by someone before:

1 ▪︎ It would've been ruined further by those weather conditions (rain) and 1 month of just staying there for maybe numerous more. It would have gotten wet even if it was under a small rubble but that's another thing.

And if you wanna argue that a page of the book wouldn't get ruined easily like that I'm going to have to remind you that Fyodor just ripped that shit to shreds. But let's say it didn't get ruined under the rain. And that brings me to:

2 ▪︎ Kyouka said that the Special Divison swept the place and apparently, they didn't find it. Considering that it's a page of the book, and that the whole thing is a result of that, I don't think they would've done their job sloppily. They didn't "miss" anything because it wasn't even there to begin with when they started searching.

Now I don't want to immediately start pointing fingers. Someone might have collaborated with Fyodor with their own agenda in mind OR walked into their plan accidentally and had to continue it. I really don't know who's the most likely to do this. As I said before, the whole avengers cast was there at one point, it could've been anyone. Although I do have some suspicions.

One of the ideal times to retrieve the page scrap would be after Atsushi and Akutagawa left to stop Fyodor from flying the plane. The other would be when they tied Fyodor up because that's when things had calmed down for a while. And if this person knew when Atsushi would go to the ruined airport, then they could have planted it in a place where he could have found it with minimal looking but not in plain sight. Because there is no guarantee that Atsushi would go rubble diving. Or they didn't hide anything at all and the person who actually tricked Atsushi is Kyouka but that's not likely at all so I'm automatically considering how someone else could achieve this without being seen.

Anyway, that's it for now. Please correct me if I get some parts factually wrong. Especially about the text on the page part. Maybe if another delusional spark goes up in my head I'll add some more things :3

#bungo stray dogs #bsd chapter 129.5 #bsd theory #bsd atsushi #bsd kyouka #bsd akutagawa #bsd fyodor #bsd agatha

I'm aware we don't actually know where abilitues come from (or, like, 90% of the magic system in BSD, for that matter) aside from the hereditary stuff presented through Kyouka or Tachihara and his brother; but there are some devastating implications to the way Atsushi's ability manifested for the first time (as told in Dead Apple).

Beast Under the Moonlight came from his desperate need for survival and having no other way to protect himself. So, a breaking point. A devastating one at that. What was the breaking point for other characters like?

Sigma's main emotional wound comes from having no memories, no knowledge of his past, of his existence, no place to belong. And his ability is to exchange information through touch. Sure, this might have been written in on the book alongside everything else about him, but there is still a poetic element to it.

Or, what drove Kyusaku to manifesting an ability that only works on people who hurt them? A child who has the ability to drive those who hurt them insane. What happened to them?

What was Dazai doing before his attempt that made him end up being able to nullify other abilities, essentially making him impossible to attack via non-traditional means?

How desperate was Fukuzawa for human connection while dealing with his trauma from the war that he manifested an ability that works by bringing people together?

How much love for life does Yosano carry that her ability is to heal and revive people with essentially no limit to it?

How strong is Kunikida's resolve to bring his ideals to life, no matter how impossible they might be in practice, that he can bring objects to reality from a blank page?

What did Oda want to prevent? What did Ango want to find out?

I could (and do) think about these characters all day long ahhhhhhg

#luan's thoughts #bungou stray dogs #bungo stray dogs #bsd #bsd theory #bsd dead apple #bungou stray dogs dead apple #atsushi nakajima #dazai osamu #bsd sigma #kyusaku yumeno #fukuzawa yukichi #yosano akiko #kunikida doppo #oda sakunosuke #ango sakaguchi #bsd meta

Why does nobody talk abt how many space related abilities are there In bsd

Like rashoumon let's akutagawa cut thru space, so do byakko's claws

Lucy's ability creates a 4d space for her

Nikolai's ability creates portals between spaces

Rimbauds ability quiet literally let's him create his own subspace, sort of like lucy's ability but with less restrictions (yet lucy's ability could be limitless too if she were given more screentime I think)

And then the whole quantum physics sht with the flying creature and the sword or smth i forgot what it's called

#bsd theory #bsd akutagawa #bungo stray dogs akutagawa #akutagawa ryuunosuke #arthur rimbaud #lucy montgomery #lucy bsd #bsd atsushi #atsushi nakajima #nikolai gogol bsd #bsd nikolai #nikolai gogol

This might as well be crack so don't take it as a close to factual theory cause there's like a 0.1% chance of this ever happening lol. Though for my own personal enjoyment I like to play around with senerios of Rashomon being the Dragon but to explain that ig I kinda have to get into theoretical territory.

Which I'm not very good at so bare with me.

The only actual Dragon we know of in bsd is the Red Dragon singularity from dead apple but personally, I don't think it's much of a stretch to believe there could be a Dragon ability that parallels the Tiger. I believe if there is a Dragon ability it will be reminiscent of the Dragon singularity we see in dead apple as fits like an opposite to the Tiger thematically.

We know Atsushi's Tiger is the antithesis to all abilities and it's implied the dragon is it's opposite; the chaos of all abilities. Atsushi as an antithesis seems to be something of an anti-ability, which I think has something to do with how Atsushi can physically cut through abilities. The Dragon we see in dead apple is like the opposite to that, it's an amalgamation of many abilities. Something than can destroy vs something than can elevate. The dragons ability to strengthen other abilities seems to come through merging with or consuming other abilities, this trait reminds me a lot of Rashomon, Rashomon is the only ability (as far as I know) that is seen being able to fuse with another so effortlessly. Case in point, sskk's "Beast Beneath the Moonlight–Rashomon".

I say all of this to propose the idea that the Knight state Akutagawa went through was something of a temporary merging between Bram and Akutagawa's abilities and consciousness (abilities are tied to consciousness after all). Which in this hypothetical, perhaps it's a hint towards other unique skills of Rashomon's maybe it'd be possible for his ability to fully consume or merge with another oneday.

After all, Atsushi is a character known for breaking ability rules as well as Shibusawa (another character who's tied to the Dragon) perhaps Akutagawa could become the first user to truly wield more than one ability? That part is really where the crack of this theory comes in lol.

Anyhow thank you for reading my rambles and have a good day 🫡