Urban vs Rural Garden Macro Post
In our working with Dixon Road Elementary a growing rural community, we attempted to make contacts with multiple schools in more urban schools that also had a school garden to look into the differences and similarities between the two. However, contact was never made in return to our reaching out. We were, however, able to make contact with the Raleigh City Farm to compare gardens between rural and urban communities. While the comparison is not direct in scope it does highlight the main differences between the two garden types, it also illustrates some of their similarities.
The garden at Dixon Road has the goal to educate students about the joys and importance of healthy eating and gardening. While a lot of students in this rural area are highly aware of farms and crops, they may not have direct access to fresh options in grocery stores that their families frequent. This garden experience incites excitement about the process of gardening and even towards creating healthier habits. This hands-on experience also shows the students what foods are grown in certain seasons and times. Like the online exercise, we did this when we first started teaching them. The excitement and hands-on also creates an air for their complete willingness to try the foods in the garden and encourages them to ask if they can take it home.
Our preceptor informed us that students only have physical education classes once a week. Once we became aware that it made more sense why the students always wanted to go outside with us. The kids did not want to spend all of their classroom days, inside slouched looking at computer screens or a smartboard. Working in the garden with activities such as planting seeds, raking the garden beds, pulling weeds, and even adding more soil to the beds; promote the idea that the physical nature is beneficial towards their health.
Similarly, to Dixon Road, the Raleigh City Farm allows for community members to have a better understanding of farming. The Raleigh City Farm is viewed by upwards of 10,000 potential community members on a daily basis, some aware of the garden and some unaware. This non-profit works diligently to offer chances to community members to be involved within the upkeep of the garden through various opportunities.
With the Raleigh City Farm getting viewed from the street, the farmers and volunteers work extremely hard to maintain the area to ensure that it remains looking aesthetically pleasing to all vantage points. This type of concern is not seen at Dixon Road. Mrs. Tingen works diligently to ensure the maintenance and upkeep of the garden; she occasionally has parent volunteers that come and help. However, a majority of the upkeep is done by her, her students with supervision, some other faculty members and their classes, and this semester she also had our help. This is a striking difference between the two gardens, as the Raleigh City Farm not only has their community volunteers, but they have experienced farmers.
Both of these gardens provide educational opportunities to encourage and promote healthy eating habits with fresh produce. In class we’ve talked about the rise in obesity, these gardens work diligently to illustrate a different way of life. The rise in obesity is due in part to the rising cost of healthier food options, and the lowering costs of foods that are highly processed and not considered to be the healthiest of choices. They do this through their access of fresh options and creating areas in which the youth can learn the ways gardening, healthy food habits, and getting more physical activity into their daily routine. The school garden especially works to change the narrative for the rural students through measures of increasing the student’s knowledge about the food that they choose to eat. The children we worked with always wanted to immediately eat the food that they pulled from the garden.
However, the Raleigh City Farm works to inform their entire community about choosing fresh produce options. Due to their location within the city, community members from every walk of life are able to view it and participate in helping with the tasks that they outline to create a helpful learning environment for those with every knowledge level of gardening as a whole. Both areas with gardens have their respective barriers towards healthy living, however, both gardens can work towards educating and using their resources to further inform their communities, especially if the resources were geared towards every income level.
From what we’ve learned from our classes and directly from our experiences at Dixon Road Elementary these educational methods are definitely ensuring that the students have a better understanding of the importance of building healthy lifestyles and that the choices they make now could have an impact on them later in life. While our comparisons are not direct in nature there is an amazing amount of overlap in what both places seek to accomplish with their target populations, and both places have worked tirelessly to execute their plans within their programs, and both plans are done well for their environment.