Top 5 animated Batman films!
Return of the Joker, still my favorite, I think, even though I'm not really invested in the actual A-plot of Terry because I just never really watched Batman Beyond. But it's a testament to the strength of the writing here that it works totally on its own. The Joker is at his most terrifying here, and the finale is just heartbreaking and amazing and perfect, and it's just always going to be one of my favorite arcs.
Under the Red Hood, SERIOUSLY GREAT. I love John DiMaggio's performance as the Joker, and there's great voice acting all around, really. (Vincent Martella plays baby!Jason, and his younger brother plays younger!baby!Jason! I ADORE IT.) It's beautifully adapted, and nothing will kill you more quickly than Jason's FAAAACES. :( :( :( Breaking my heart. Breaking it.
The Dark Knight Returns, Parts 1 and 2, the story is really bizarre in the way a lot of Frank Miller stories tend to be, and I still haven't read the comic, but it's so audacious that it rides on that momentum the whole time, and there's not a single dull moment. I love Carrie Kelley's presence SO MUCH, so even though it's a very ~gritty film, it retains Bruce's essential humanity by valuing that connection he has with the young men and women he inspires. Michael Emerson's Joker is amaaaaaze, and this is just one of those films that left me breathless at times. Definitely worth a watch.
Year One, which is one of my favorite comic stories, and the only complaint I have about the film is Batman's voice actor, who just felt so lifeless to me. BOO. But it's worth it for the story and there's fantastic imagery throughout.
The Lego Movie, obviously. (This is a copout because I haven't seen some of the original DCAU films in years, like SubZero or Mask of the Phantasm. I'm really hoping Assault on Arkham is good enough to make the list, but we'll see.)












